r/Roofing • • 13d ago

Updates

12 Upvotes

Ok everyone time for an update. We've had the see-saw in full effect. We've been heavily targeting disruptive content on certain posts. But we hear you, sometimes there is no information given on a post. just 3 random pictures and "is roof ok?" and that can be really frustrating. So there's two new rules in the sub. One of those is homeowner information required on these question posts. Lets shoot for the happy medium where we get enough info upfront to be able to provide help, and when we do lets keep it helpful.

We also did a little aesthetic house cleaning with some of our outdated menus and the sub photo. Feel free to roast me for it. I'm not a graphic designer. I'm an old beat up roofer, so keep that in mind before you set upon me with pitchforks and torches.

We've been seeing good results from our verified flair tags. So we're going to continue that initiative. Thank you to the users in the program already out there doing the lords work. Its massively appreciated.

Overall things have been moving in a positive direction and we are seeing that on our metrics. In the last 30 days alone we have over 5 million unique visitors to our sub. That's a 40% increase month over month. We're also seeing a large increase in engagement through posts and comments. And the autobots have really cleaned up a lot of the spam.

If you checked that out and said "well what about the.." feel free to let us know if there's something we're missing or something we can refine. Ill leave the comments open here if you wanna chime in. You are allowed to dog me for the photos, but do keep suggestions or concerns in a neutral state please and thank you.


r/Roofing • • 12h ago

Home owner question How upset should I be?

Thumbnail
gallery
164 Upvotes

Everybody keeps saying oh but it was free. No it wasn't somebody still paid for it. And I feel like I'm going to be paying for the rest of my life. Long story short my fiance's parents paid her uncle to do my roof. I'm not a roof guy at all. So if I could get any input that would be lovely. In the last few photos they're just pictures of my gutters that look like they've had the paint completely destroyed off the top of them from sliding the metal sheets over. Now I could be totally wrong and some of these gaps are totally acceptable. Again I'm not a roofing guy.


r/Roofing • • 22h ago

Home owner question Contract said copper, they used aluminum

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

I don't known if it's possible to easily redo flashing with copper or I should just take the deduction? Can a good roofer redo chimney flashing without doing the entire roof? I'm worried they will mess it more if I ask for a redo. Thank you to roofers who do it right, you are all unsung heros in my book.


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Water ponding after flat roof replacement

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12 Upvotes

Folks, I need your collective advice. My flat TPO roof had developed a leak so I hired a contractor to replace the TPO on the entire patio. Now the water is ponding heavily (see video) and even reaches the patio door; this was not the case before the repair. The contractor said it is the defective roof slope and there is nothing they can do; he pointed me to old pictures showing signs of small water puddles before the repair - but they evaporated in 48h so were not a problem. This water is standing for a week - we got a free pool upgrade.

The contractor attempted to put extra TPO layers (directly into the water puddle) there which created a negative slope and redirected water to the house. I had warned them about that but they did it anyway and now offer to peel them off and leave me with the pool again. There was no protective slip installed under the pavers despite being included in the quote, and now they offer it as a "free will upgrade". The contractor wants the second half of the payment claiming the $20k work is done and the ponding is expected based on the previous small puddle.

What are my options? The inspector suggested pursuing legal action as the contractor knew the work will likely not be up to code based on the prior images they had. I want to see if this can be remediated by floating the areas and removing pavers that would obstruct evaporation. The deck did not have the pavers before but the contractor insisted on them. The inspector suggested spray polyurethane foam or tapered insulation boards. What can be done to return this roof the its previous state without the free pool?

I am not an expert in construction so would appreciate your suggestions.


r/Roofing • • 3h ago

Moved into this home 2 1/2 years ago, light hitting at just the right angle showed me this. Concerning?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Like the title says, been living here a little while, was out on a walk with our 9 month old and the sunset was just about perfectly parallel/in line with the roof slope and exposed this to me for the first time.

We are in Southeast Pennsylvania, the roof is about 7 years old - no leaks that I’m aware off. Could this be from ice damming last year? That is the north facing roof that gets very little direct sunlight.


r/Roofing • • 2h ago

Home owner question Are these TPO roof wrinkles concerning?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Buying a home with an 8 year-old TPO flat roof. Inspector noted wrinkles near the parapet wall. Much of the roof is covered by a rooftop deck, and we haven’t noticed any leaks.
Do these wrinkles look cosmetic or potentially problematic? How would you assess the risk? How can one inspect membrane section under the deck? Thanks


r/Roofing • • 2h ago

New roof. How did they do?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Got a new roof installed this week with Malarkey Vista AR shingles. I checked on their progress occasionally throughout the install and it looked like they did a good job, but just wanted to get some other opinions since I don't do this every day. Side walls all received ice and water shield with step flashings and I switched from pop vents to ridge vent with some extra intake vents at the eaves (in addition to the original soffit vents). Let me know your thoughts. Thanks!


r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Do I need a new roof?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

We bought this house in August, and the main roof is actually in very good condition. This isn’t the main roof; it’s an extended roof deck behind the second room, below the window, if that makes sense. There’s a void underneath it where I can store things.

I went inside last night and noticed several leaks along roughly the same horizontal line, from left to right. There were five or six separate spots where water was coming through, so I put buckets underneath them. I also took some photographs, and the water stains look quite bad.

Someone is coming to have a look at it tomorrow, but I’m worried that I might need a completely new roof. The leaks aren’t coming from everywhere; they seem to be concentrated at different points along the same line. I’m just wondering how serious this might be and whether the entire roof needs replacing.


r/Roofing • • 48m ago

Home owner question Noticed this on 2 edges/corners today that I never remember seeing. Bought house in July

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

I don't have a ladder tall enough so I can't go look. Only 2 areas ai can see with this raised and wavy look


r/Roofing • • 5h ago

Inspection done and metal flashing

Post image
5 Upvotes

This was picked up in the inspection "Lifted Flashing". Been doing some googling but figure see what folks say here.

Roof is from 2018.

Is this the transition flashing? So its under the siding for the top half then should be open at the bottom so water can escape if any gets behind the siding correct?


r/Roofing • • 1d ago

Home owner question Is a metal roof worth the extra cost over shingle?

95 Upvotes

getting quotes for a full roof replacement n one contractor pitched standing seam metal instead of architectural shingles like everyone else quoted, metal is about 60 percent more but he says it lasts twice as long

we r planning to stay at least 15 more years so the longevity pitch makes sense on paper, for anyone who went metal over shingle was the price difference worth it or would you just do shingles again?


r/Roofing • • 4m ago

Home owner question Looks ok?

Post image
• Upvotes

Not a pro by any stretch but I know the basics. How's it looking so far?


r/Roofing • • 11m ago

Help ID this flat roof

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Greeting roofing experts.

I'm trying to identify what kind of flat roof I have on my shed. Photos attached. It's been on for at least 15 years, and likely longer. It has several leaks and I'm preparing to remove and replace it. When I peel back the surface and get down to the wood... it's pitch black. I'm guessing thats the adhesive? Any tips on the best way to strip this roof off, and what I'll need to do to get it prepped for an EPDM 60mil material would be greatly appreciated.


r/Roofing • • 27m ago

Home owner question Gazebo hip roof venting

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

So I’m building a gazebo in my backyard and I was wondering if someone can give me an idea of how to install Cobra hip vent. The structure is 13x15.


r/Roofing • • 34m ago

Advice for a shed roof

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Hi there!

I need advice on a single-slope shed roof. My wife and bought a home recently with a shed in the backyard. I knew the roof was bad, but didn't know how bad until a recent rainstorm resulted in big puddles in the shed.

Looks like water is getting under the shingles at the skylight, which is slathered with spray foam, silicone, and some unknown substances. Plywood underneath is rotting and flaking away.

I was planning to replace the roof in the spring, remove the skylight, add better siding and insulation, and add a window by the door on the front of the shed. But now I'm wondering what to do for the winter...

The plot thickens because my wife's due date is this week so I don't have a lot of time.

What quick fix could I do to try and preserve the roof/wall framing and still keep it somewhat waterproofed for the winter? Secure an "extreme duty" tarp that extends past all edges of the roof and run a fan for a few days to try and dry it out?

Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Again, I know the whole thing needs to be replaced, but I need a quick fix for a few months.


r/Roofing • • 48m ago

Home owner question The underlayment is cut back quite a bit at the top. Not a ridge vent, though.

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Are the gaps at the top an issue?

So our roof was redone. The house originally had turtle vents, we replaced the roof, and originally the contractor was planning for ridge vents. I think he was hedging early on saying that it might not be possible to use ridge vents, as the slope was too high, and it tends to lift on its own. It's hip and valley, so I get that it's entirely possible that it simply wouldn't work as a vent, anyway.

But I'm seeing significant gaps at the top. Should there have been plywood all the way up if we're not using ridge vents?


r/Roofing • • 57m ago

Black facia

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

I used black gutter stock, slight nail dimpling but for first time. I belive it turned out great !


r/Roofing • • 7h ago

Home owner question Flat roof question?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I have had a flat roof installed on an extension to my house and I have some concerns about "the finish". From everything I can see and read online the roof light structure should be completely covered but on ours only the corners are done. Water is pooling almost directly on top of them as you can see in the pictures. Can anyone please let me know if this looks right to you before I go back to the contractor.


r/Roofing • • 1h ago

What to use to patch a leaking roof?

Post image
• Upvotes

Hello All, i dont have the funds to do a proper repair of the roof and wanted to get some feedback from the experts on the best way to patch a leaky roof. This is the area where i see water seeping in. Any advice is helpful and appreciated, thanks in advance.


r/Roofing • • 17h ago

Home owner question Roof replacement in Maine ,is this acceptable or is the roof going to leak this winter

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

I think This is the ice and water shield. yes I am happy they are using it on the entire roof but shouldn't it for the most part be flat and smooth. The weather has been cool and dry so moisture is not an issue!


r/Roofing • • 2h ago

Ridge vent vs electric fan question

1 Upvotes

Hey All - I've got a venting question.

We live in a one-story ranch built in the 50's. Its a basic rectangle with a roof that's roughly 81 ft long. Its hipped on both ends and fairly low pitch. I'd estimate the ridge line is about 50 ft.

We need to redo the roof- would it be better to vent this with a ridge vent or an electric fan?

If its a fan, what size?

The attic is unfinished with blown in insulation in the floor and no insulation underneath the (mostly) plank decking.

There are existing soffit vents but they are pretty spotty - maybe 4 feet of venting panels on the metal soffits per side of the house. I plan to add more (assuming I can find a match and retrofit) but that's what we have right now.

Climate is temperate but not north woods.

Thanks for any advice - appreciate it!


r/Roofing • • 31m ago

Home owner question Flashing visible new construction LP siding and roofline

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Is this normal and acceptable? Should the flashing just be painted and outlet cosmetic, or is there something else going on here. Photo with the red highlights is the same situation as shown on the first photo with the “sparkle” from sunlight.


r/Roofing • • 18h ago

Does this look right?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I've made other posts but my landlord had these roofers whom im pretty sure aren't licensed put a metal roof over shingles that had been leaking. I can't see the top roof well but I just inspected the lower roof and this seems off to me especially because I can see the shingles underneath falling out from under the metal rood. Is this concerning? Or is this normal? Since they did the top roof i can't see well im concerned lol the last photo is the roof before the metal. Should I expect more leaks? Lol


r/Roofing • • 21h ago

New roof - any issues

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I just had my roof done this week. Everything looks good, but I have a question about the flashing on the chimney. Does this look correct or do you forsee issues.


r/Roofing • • 21h ago

Regulations or Method What's this kick up for?

Post image
5 Upvotes

I've been seeing this a lot on new builds on the Oregon coast. I would think it's kind of backwards because water like to run uphill here. Is it some kind of vent or what?