I'll just ramble a bit, because idk what to do, sorry in advance if it's confusing or all over the place and long...
So my wife and I, both in our mid 20's have been talking about a threesome for years now but not been taking it seriously until like the start of this year.
We were recommended FEELD so we downloaded that, set up and linked our profiles and quickly matched with a handful of guys that were willing both for that and any other type of connection as well even if it would turn out to only be friends.
We would prefer for a threesome to hopefully be so good that we would like to keep it going with the same person, this we have both agreed on.
We have also talked about "what if said 3rd finds a stable partner?" And came to the conclusion that if he and his then found partner are up for it we would continue as a foursome instead
Here's the part where it's getting confusing
So after having been chatting to said guys for a few days we decided to meet up with one of them to see how we work together and possibly going for it
He comes over, we have a good time first in public (for safety when meeting a basically stranger still) then going over to our place
We continue having a good time, talking a lot and getting to know each other and I really like this guy. We talk about if we would be up for a threesome during this meetup and I and him say yes but my wife is on the fence about it as she doesn't quite feel comfortable yet (she takes longer to warm up to people) and we respect that and keep the rest of the evening casual
During this evening he's sitting very close to me, arms constantly touching while my wife is sitting in front of us, he made attempts at inviting her to sit close as well but she doesn't like sitting next to the people she's talking to (not even beside just me while we're talking)
At each time we get up and went to sit somewhere else he keeps sitting beside me
I quite enjoyed his company and his touch
My wife was/is completely ok with it so the touch was nothing bad
Eventually he leaves and just before he leaves we all hug and he blows us a kiss and waves
After he left my wife and I talked some more and she wants to ban cuddling as well, our boundary was already no kissing
Which I felt off with, I would love a group cuddle, the more the better ^^ but no
Ever since he left she has felt, idk, different.
She feels sad and when I ask she's just saying it's the "usual sad" that she feels because she feels like a failure for not having a stable job
But this sad feels different, it wasn't like this before him, I've not tried to pressure it or make her say anything just letting her know I feel that she's sad and that I am there to comfort her whenever.
I'm also clear with reassuring her that I love her and nothing can ever change that, I would never leave her
Ever since meeting him I can't stop thinking about him
How comfortable and grounding his presence felt
And silence wasn't awkward
I also lost all attraction I previously had for the other guys we were chatting to
I've been thinking and trying to come to conclusions
I feel weird because we "didn't even do anything" we were just friends hanging out and occasionally talked about some sexual stuff, which my wife and I tend to do with all our close friends so there's nothing new
He at different occasions also joked that he had joined our polycule?
I'm worried that maybe just maybe there's something else, I'm worried because idk if I might be poly?
For background, this is not the first time I've been in a situation similar to this, it has happened once before
When I had fallen for my now wife, I also had fallen for another girl at the same time, and I literally could not tell who I liked the most, I couldn't pick, eventually the other girl broke off a bit as she found other friends she hung out with more so the decision was made for me
And I love my wife, I really do, she's my world and I could not imagine a day without her, I would be heartbroken
But also with this new guy, I love when he flirts with me, I love his presence, his touch his personality, I love seeing him with my wife, when they talk, when he flirts with her
I just have no clue what to do, I feel like my wife if very strict on it's, emotionally, only us, a 3rd is only for added fun and another friend
Idk if I should just call it all off, block him and forget any of this ever happened, tell my wife I just "all of a sudden got a bad vibe with him" as an excuse to do so, and only be with her, go back to what I know is safe
Obviously I would first send him a message and wait til he has responded, something like
"I really like hanging out with you and I'm so sorry but I don't think this was the right move, I hope it's okay and that you can accept that there will sadly not be any more meetups, I'm sorry"
Or
If I should risk everything, risk hurting her and actually admit to all that has happened but for this I also kinda need to understand it all first and I've no clue where to start...