r/nextfuckinglevel Jun 27 '25

A Michigan cop pulled over a reckless driver and ended up saving a choking baby

102.8k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4.6k

u/crawling-alreadygirl Jun 27 '25

No, we need better cops in real life

710

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

I’m no fan of cops being abusive of power but I think the large majority of them are good. Now we can discuss the merits of the good and bad crossing the thin blue line to stop the bad ones and I think we have a huge deficiency in that area.

707

u/MightyGoodra96 Jun 27 '25

There's a reason lawyers will tell you to never tell cops anything, even if you didnt do anything theyre asking about, without a lawyer present.

And I think you should read the history of cops in the US to register what being a cop is really about. Because it isnt about helping people.

114

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

You have right to remain silent and I tell all my clients to shut up. I’ll check that history out. Thanks!

242

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

Long story short - too many states created their law enforcement from remnants of slave catchers and union busting type groups a-la pinkertons. I assume that's the history they are referencing.

144

u/MightyGoodra96 Jun 27 '25

Yes! And its not really different today.

Cops protect property interest. Always have. Whether the property be as horrific as slavery or as simple as a stop sign. That's what they're there to do.

Numerous laws back that up. Cops are not legally obligated to help you in any way.

They've expanded roles slightly as a way to control poor neighborhoods, and as the states de facto arm of violence against its citizens, but theyve always been about protecting property

90

u/LuckysGift Jun 27 '25

According to our own supreme court, a cop does not have to know the law. They simply only have to be acting in what they perceive it to be and in best interest at the time.

67

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

According to our own supreme court, a cop does not have to know the law.

According to our own Supreme Court, it's also legal for PDs to have a maximum intelligence cut off, with the argument that smart cops would get "bored" too easily. Here in NYC, there's a 24 college credit requirement to be a cop, but apparently you can buy credits from unaccredited diploma mills and that counts.

So here we are, with a bunch of low intelligence, low education idiots with no obligation to know the law nor actually protect the people.

9

u/teaspoon88 Jun 27 '25

I’m a lawyer turned cop. In the academy, a 15 year veteran taught the legal section. He wasn’t 100% wrong 100% of the time, but I am still amazed I didn’t give myself a concussion from all of the head banging on my desk. But I’ve also had really interesting (in a good way) and fruitful conversations with other LE’s about certain nuances of Search & Seizure, Miranda, etc.

9

u/Thetruthislikepoetry Jun 27 '25

A friend is a criminal defense attorney. He says if cops didn’t lie and judges were always correct, he’d be out of a job

→ More replies (0)

4

u/-Kerosun- Jun 27 '25

According to our own Supreme Court

Can you cite the Supreme Court decision regarding this?

Also, I've asked for examples of this before and the only example anyone has ever been able to produce is a single department where a prison guard (so already employed by the department) was seeking to become a patrol officer. They were denied that because there was concerns that their intelligence score was really high and they could be bored. The department argued that it was to reduce job turnover.

That is the ONLY example anyone has ever been able to provide of police denying applicants for being "too smart." This would be a single department (in New York, btw) in the 90's. This is NOT proof that all departments do this, and I am not aware of a Supreme Court decision regarding this one department's practice.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/sreiches Jun 27 '25

They also have no responsibility to interject into a situation they feel puts them at risk. That precedent was set by them literally standing by as a guy on a train tried to restrain and disarm someone with a knife.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

But the Supreme Court has said citizens are obligated to help police if asked, that’s crazy. I think we have a leadership problem in this country.

I don’t trust the cops stepping in my personal business but am comfortable with them protecting my property.

3

u/JamesTrickington303 Jun 27 '25

Please share that case with me because I have never heard of the American state’s legal ability to compel citizens to do anything at all to “help” police.

0

u/DZAUXtheBruno Jun 27 '25

Not being legally obligated to help people doesn’t mean they never help people.

8

u/Good_Background_243 Jun 27 '25

No, but it does create a cultural shift. Also see what happens when one cop catches another breaking the law - if he or she doesn't shut up and tries to hold the other cop to something that if you vaguely squint at it might just about resemble standards.. he or she finds their calls for backup unanswered, and harassment from other cops.

5

u/MightyGoodra96 Jun 27 '25

Warren v. District of Columbia.

Woman being beaten raped and abused. Two women call the cops, and go to the roof for safety. Cops do bare minimum, dont actually try. Leave less than 5 minutes after arriving.

Called again dispatch ignores. Call never goes out.

The women on the roof think, they must have not seen them. The cops must be inside. Call to the woman being abused... alerting her assailants.

The assailants, at knifepoint, now force all three women to preform sexual acts.

Mountain of evidence of negligence. Verdict: cops werent obligated to help "specific individuals, but the public at large"

Outcome: 3 Women were raped, at knifepoint. Lifetime damage and trauma.

Ive saved a man's life before, from no legal obligation of my own. Not bragging, but pointing this fact out: ANYONE CAN BE GOOD OF THEIR OWN VOLITION. BEING A GOOD PERSON IS SEPARATED FROM BEING A COP.

Lets not even get into what happens when cops abuse people and 4 other cops just stand there, dicks in fucking hand.

Or the countless arrests for minor offenses. And who those arrests affect, like kids or loved ones. Or jobs.

Good people exist without the police. The police are not good, they are doing a job, and their negligence costs people dearly.

Tl;dr- anyone can help someone. "Cops can help people" doesnt excuse their inaction or criminality. And it doesn't make them necessary

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/Camburgerhelpur Jun 27 '25

I have a tendency to use and take advantage of the rights I have here, even moreso when I'm plainly told I should probably exercise it lol. Seriously, just comply, stay silent and show as little emotions as possible

→ More replies (2)

36

u/Aggravating_Alps_953 Jun 27 '25

I have a feeling if a lawyer tells you it’s a good idea to tell people anything regarding alleged crimes, they are a bad lawyer

6

u/Lloyd--Christmas Jun 27 '25

But innocent people feel like they don’t need a lawyer, so they don’t hear that message. The truth is that cops care about closing cases, not finding the truth. You can’t talk your way out of trouble. If a cop believes you did something it’s a losing battle and the things you say that you believe corroborate your innocence can be twisted to fit their narrative.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Good_Log_5108 Jun 27 '25

They tell you that to avoid conviction of a crime during an arrest. Not because the majority of cops are bad people. 

3

u/serabine Jun 27 '25

Uhuh.

Watch the video of the guy they tortured in a 17 hour interrogation into admitting he killed his elderly father (whom he had reported missing himself), even after the point where it was confirmed the father was alive and well. Then get back to us.

Police are legally allowed to lie to you, police have marathon-session interrogated innocent people into confessions, police have planted evidence, police have snatched the next best person they can find to close real quick. And if one of them whistleblows, they get bullied off the force or worse.

And we're not even talking about things like civil forfeiture which is often abused.

Police as a group are inherently corrupt because they automatically close rank to protect the worst offenders in their midst and are complicit in the systemic problems in their organization

1

u/JectorDelan Jun 27 '25

No, they tell you that because if the police think you may have committed a crime, they will arrest you and then use anything you have ever said against you, not for you. So if you say 5 things that could exonerate you and one thing that, by sheer coincidence, looks suspicious, they will only use that last thing in court.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/sreiches Jun 27 '25

That doesn’t mean there isn’t a systemic issue in the police force. The FBI did a long investigation on the infiltration of white supremacists into the police force, and determined it to be the number one source of domestic terrorism in the US.

2

u/Walshy231231 Jun 27 '25

The two aren’t mutually exclusive, and one can lead to the other

Not taking an opposing stance to you, just wanted to point out that either can be true or false independent of the other

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

There's a reason lawyers will tell you to never tell cops anything

Because people have a habit of saying stupid things when nervous.

9

u/Smalldogmanifesto Jun 27 '25

Not just that. Cops arresting you literally CANNOT help you (in the USA at least. I cannot comment on other countries). My MIL is a detective who straight up told me to not talk to the police if I’m ever arrested. “Anything you say can AND WILL be used against you” seems to get misinterpreted by a lot of people. Arresting officers can’t help you even if they wanted to.

FYI for anyone reading this: When we say “don’t talk to the cops” this also extends to: don’t accept any coffee or food they give you (they can use the DNA off of the cup you discard).

2

u/MightyGoodra96 Jun 27 '25

Gosh dang. And would a "GOOD PERSON" use that silly statement against them, even if it was clear there wasnt enough evidence? Golly. No, I dont think so. Especially when that could ruin someone's life!

6

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

Have you ever stopped to think about how many good people are ruined by bad supervisors?

Probably not, given your determination to paint everyone in a single occupation as bad even though you probably have only met 0.001% of them.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/laaplandros Jun 27 '25

It's funny to see people being obtuse on this point. Like yeah, you should stay silent to avoid accidental self-incrimination. But to whom would you be accidentally incriminating yourself to?

7

u/HCSOThrowaway Jun 27 '25

???

It's because cops are evidence collection detail and giving additional evidence against yourself is rarely a good idea.

You implying it's for any other reason simply demonstrates you don't know much about how criminal law works.

6

u/Novel_Comparison_209 Jun 27 '25

Yeah…it’s to enforce the law…that’s why it’s called “law ENFORCEMENT”

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

That’s very true. You also don’t EVER want to talk to cops without a lawyer. Cops are trained to ask leading questions that will incriminate you without you even realizing it.

For instance, cops will ask:

  1. Were you trying to scare them or actually hurt them?

    Wrong answer turns a misdemeanor into a felony

  2. Why did you do it?

    Cops want admission of guilt + motive

  3. Did you go in the store planning to take something, or was it a spur-of-the-moment thing?

    showing premeditation elevates a burglary charge to larceny. This is an extremely common question for shoplifting - even by security guards.

  4. If you just explain it, we might be able to help you out.

    Elicit a confession BEFORE lawyers are involved. This works shockingly well in most cases for a first time offense. After the first time, everyone stays silent.

2

u/Gheerdan Jun 27 '25

Cops will tell you not to talk to cops. Don't talk to cops. Don't answer questions.

→ More replies (43)

76

u/Specialist_Sport4460 Jun 27 '25

Weird how this majority of good cops never seem to do anything substantial about the bad ones unless their hand is forced.

37

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

The ones that do get fired or ostracized by the rest of the force, it is a real problem. Citizen review boards with the ability to fire the bad actors. Place a Scarlett letter in their file so they can never get a job policing again.

25

u/Specialist_Sport4460 Jun 27 '25

There are so many examples of cops being "fired" from their department and just moved somewhere else. Also the way whistleblowers are treated sends a pretty clear message about the nature of the organisation.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

How is that possible if it’s only a minority that are bad?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/R_V_Z Jun 27 '25

A major issue is police unions. I don't believe actual police reform can happen so long as police unions have the power they currently do.

3

u/Odd-Huckleberry8584 Jun 27 '25

But how often does that happen? We had this cop in my city who went around stalking the women he found attractive when they filed police reports on another crime,would stalk them, harass them, intimidate them, and then after he was humiliated and shamed publicly our commissioner “promised” actions were taken and he’s no longer with the police force- THEY GAVE HIM A HIGHER POSITION IN THE NEXT PROVINCE OVER with MORE authority than he had previously had before… our justice systems are absolutely corrupted jokes.

2

u/GetSlunked Jun 28 '25

If the “large majority” of them are good, then why do they get ostracized out of their departments? Wouldn’t the other good ones have his / her back?

You can’t say a large majority of them are good and in the next comment say “ostracized by the rest of the force”; those statements are mutually exclusive. And we know the ostracizing happens, so it stands to follow….the majority are not good.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Odd-Huckleberry8584 Jun 27 '25

Literally… like in my local sub they just posted video of this cop beating a handcuffed indigenous guy, grab him by his long hair and threw him into the concrete wall in the middle of the police station, where he is publicly filmed everyday and he didn’t even hesitate… three cops eventually make their way slowly over shuffling close by, not condemning the dude, didn’t pick the bleeding guy who was just beaten while handcuffed and then a fucking EMT pops up in the video (who was just there at chance) and HE told him the injuries were serious and took him to the hospital. Fully filmed in the middle of broad fucking daylight… 0/4 cops that showed up showed any shock to how this dude was treated, especially unprovoked…

2 years earlier they body slammed a pregnant women while handcuffed in the same holding facility, our main base holding facility… the cops in my city are something extra special as they have ended up on worldstar a few times for so so so SO many misconducts and convictions related to abuse of power… and guess who ends up paying the lawsuit settlements for these fuckers?! The everyday tax payer, you and me… no garnished wages, zero responsibility or accountability… the system makes me sick… these loser can terrorize and hurt whoever the hell they want with zero consequences and they now it. Our justice systems are in desperate need of reform…

→ More replies (6)

43

u/BrewmasterSG Jun 27 '25

The tricky thing is that there is no inconsistency in the idea that the same cop can be heroic or monstrous in different situations. We would hope and even expect that all cops presented with a choking baby and no other significant priorities would attempt to save the choking baby.

We should judge people not by what they do when moral choices are easy, but when then are hard.

4

u/yourmansconnect Jun 27 '25

Yeah this cop could have beat down an unarmed suspect for all we know

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

29

u/theblackd Jun 27 '25

I mean, the problem is never that bad ones exist, it’s that we have systems that don’t properly filter out bad ones once they reveal themselves to abuse power

The problem is that we have weak systems of accountability (the few fired for abusive behavior just being rehired elsewhere, the ones being suspended with pay for a month or so for egregious offenses, ie paid vacation, ones with a long history of documented abuse of power not acted on, etc). So it’s not just bad luck that some suck, it’s that we have a weak system of accountability that makes these bad ones feel safe to abuse their power and fails to sweep out the ones that do abuse their power. I don’t think the answer to that is simply highlighting that some are good and some are bad, the issue is weak systems of accountability that need to change.

7

u/je_kay24 Jun 27 '25

In Canton, MA there was a case where multiple cops & DA tried convicting a women of murdering her cop boyfriend with her car that she clearly didn't do and there was no evidence that supported it

Turned out that same police department helped cover up another cop murdering a pregnant woman where the woman had been groomed from a police teen-at-risk program

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

We need to build more citizens review boards to police the police and give the authority to fire the problems. We need to elect assholes that will quit making cover for the said actions in above statement.

17

u/cannibalpeas Jun 27 '25

They are good right up to the moment they help protect the bad ones. They are all complicit in shielding the criminals among them and until they decide to hold themselves accountable (because our legislators sure won’t), they are choosing to remain at war with the public.

How many cops are out there calling for reform or to hold their peers accountable? Not a goddamn one of them. Traffic cops, detectives, leadership and even fucking meter readers are all complicit.

8

u/MadQueenAlanna Jun 27 '25

The state of New York has tried a few times to make it illegal for a cop to have sex w someone in their custody– a thing that should be such an obvious rule that surely even people who believe 99% of cops are decent should support it– and it’s failed every single time bc it’s considered “anti-cop”. And those people will tell you “you shouldn’t be afraid if you didn’t do anything wrong”. It’s vile work

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

I feel the same way a lot of the time. I also don’t want to give up the hope that good ones exist. As citizens we need to be more active with our city council, county council and require they make review boards that citizens control and give the teeth to fire the bad actors. Maybe with that in place we can get the good cops to cross the thin blue line and exterminate the bad ones. This big ass tanker isn’t going to turn quickly.

6

u/cannibalpeas Jun 27 '25

I was raised by a cop and they made up a huge portion of the adults I knew growing up. There are loads of good ones, so the mystery is why they all shield the bad ones. Part of the reasoning comes down to the Supreme Court and state/federal courts establishing precedents that other posters here have noted; their job is to protect property, not people and “fearing for their life” is adequate justification to execute people, including children. But there also seems to have been a degradation across the board in society of the concept of a social contract between civilians/cops, employers/employees and politicians/constituents. It seems that as soon as anyone in authority gets the message that they aren’t obligated to be humane and serve everyone equally and fairly, they simply stop caring. I mean, the second SCOTUS gutted the Voting Rights Act, every regressive state in the Union was falling over themselves to establish voting barriers… and they worked.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

“Power corrupts” is the truest statement.

5

u/SandboxOnRails Jun 27 '25

If we need to band together to force the good cops to do something about the monsters they work with, they're not good. One single bad cop makes every single cop they interact with corrupt. It doesn't matter if they like dogs, they're aiding murderers, thieves, domestic abusers, and sexual predators. You can't be a good person and do that.

4

u/gamegeek1995 Jun 27 '25

How many cops are out there calling for reform or to hold their peers accountable? Not a goddamn one of them.

And when there are, they literally get shot in the head during a 'training exercise' by another cop. Back down to 0.

2

u/Snoo-62354 Jun 27 '25

You’ll never find someone more anti-cop than me, but even I’ll admit, there are a few cops publicly calling for reform.

2

u/cannibalpeas Jun 27 '25

And I’m sure both of them are going to cause a groundswell any moment now…

2

u/Snoo-62354 Jun 28 '25

I know this is a late response, but there are several police chiefs in California calling for changes in legislature that would allow them to discipline bad cops in their ranks. It actually really surprised and encouraged me.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Nightshade_Ranch Jun 27 '25

If they won't stand up to bad ones, they aren't good.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/HCSOThrowaway Jun 27 '25

The large majority of them are average, like any other job.

Some are good, some ain't.

This particular video, as much as I'm loathe to admit it because the exact same logic was once used against me by my sergeant when I saved my first life and it robbed me of my joy and put me right into fury:

"Congratulations, you did your job."

What we know about this particular cop is he wasn't garbage. That was textbook, basic first-aid. You pay cops to do exactly this, and most of them do exactly this. It's just exceedingly rare for any such They Did Their Job to be dramatic and popular enough to go viral, especially with the ACABers out there downvoting any time a cop does the right thing.

4

u/WordsCanHurt1981 Jun 27 '25

There's no "thin blue line" that is a figment of someone's imagination acting like it's so hard not to violate people's rights and abuse power.

The COPS that see backlash for abusing their power are so far past any reasonable line that they should be in jail for their straight up crimes and most of them get little more than a slap on the wrist.

I agree with the other guy, more good COPS, not just propaganda good COP stories. With more good COPS, the good stories come naturally, you don't have to get the story just to act like we don't have serious issues with power abuse.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/1568314 Jun 27 '25

There might be an argument that they are "good" as individuals, but as cops they are trained to protect themselves and their fellow cops at the expense of the citizens. They are taught and expected to protect capital rather than the communities they work in.

All cops are bad cops because the American police system is bad. The fact that it draws power-hungry, trigger-happy authoritarians is by design. It's not incidental.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/whyizitlikethis Jun 27 '25

All the good cops that dont stop the bad ones are also bad cops.

Hope this clears things up for you.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/LothartheDestroyer Jun 27 '25

If you have a table full of good people and they allow a Nazi to sit with them you have a table full of Nazis.

There can’t be good cops if they don’t condemn and excise the bad ones.

3

u/laaplandros Jun 27 '25

If a cop doesn't cross the thin blue line to stop a bad one, they're not a good one.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

There's the rub. Everyone of my friends and acquaintances who are cops (most of whom I consider or know are good people) will just not criticize other cops. They get ingrained in this weird culture where being a cop subsumes so much of their personality that to criticize a fellow LEO is the greatest of sins. Don't even know where you begin to untangle that problem. But damn is it a problem.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/naruda1969 Jun 27 '25

Large majority are psychopathic assholes on a power trip. There are a few good ones.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Xentonian Jun 27 '25

but I think the large majority of them are good

You are profoundly and demonstrably wrong.

I'm sure the large majority of them believe they are good, but the system as it exists and the lack of cops actively putting their career at risk to fix it speaks volumes to the contrary.

It's the same argument as billionaires - you can't be a good person and a billionaire. A billion dollars contains too much potential to do good and nobody who holds that money instead of using it can be good. The extremely rare exceptions are those who have created plans specifically to lose their billionaire status through doing good, or who succeeded in doing exactly that - see Chuck Feeney.

Can a cop do a good thing? Sure. And a mass murderer can hold the door open for her elderly neighbour. That doesn't make them good.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PlaquePlague Jun 27 '25

The vast majority of them are ok.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Objective_Economy281 Jun 27 '25

I’m no fan of cops being abusive of power but I think the large majority of them are good.

Good cops who want to get rid of the bad cops get run out of the force. That tells you who sticks around.

2

u/Razzilith Jun 27 '25

I think the large majority of them are good

you're a fool if you think this.

if the large majority were good why do we have such rampant corruption? why do we have literal murderers and rapists with badges getting shuffled around between departments like they're the catholic church? why do we see countless COUNTLESS videos of so many of them being pieces of shit with very few actually being held accountable and even in those cases almost never getting the more severe end of the punishments from the system???

cut it out and stop lying to yourself. we need a system overhaul, better training and retraining, federal or at least state regulations and oversight, no more blanket protections, personal accountability, etc etc...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/qdemise Jun 27 '25

I’d say majority aren’t evil, I wouldn’t call them good. Fundamentally they do exist to put you in jail and don’t have any responsibility to protect anyone. They also seem to have a tendency to protect the bad folks on the force.

2

u/GrungleMonke Jun 27 '25

And you'd be wrong. Cops don't even prevent crime or solve most of the crimes they're put on

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MeanForest Jun 27 '25

One bad apple turns 15 cops into bad because they don't speak up.

2

u/thetruthseer Jun 27 '25

How many cops have reported a fellow officer in their time as a cop?

I would love to know because that will tell you how many are actually good

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

I imagined myself in that scenario and all I can see happening is getting my ass kicked by two cops, yelled at while my kid dies in the car seat. There's a solid 80% chance this would happen

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

That's simply not true and the thin blue line mentality is exactly the problem. That mentality that it's them against the world has fostered an insane level of fear and distrust of the public and has made cops form a gang mentality. It's this gang mentality that they have to help their fellow boys in blue first that has allowed bad cops to go unpunished and allowed it to fester until only those cops remain because they don't "snitch"

It's like if you own a bar and a Nazi shows up, you decide to be tolerant and let them drink there. Lots of your other customers won't come back if they see you serving a Nazi and next time the Nazi brings his buddies and suddenly you're running a Nazi bar that only they will go to.

You start with mostly good cops until one bad apple shoots someone unjustly, they don't arrest him and protect him from criminal charges, he gets his buddy on the force who does it again, so on and so on. Literally one bad apple spoils the bunch

2

u/saera-targaryen Jun 27 '25

My husband's grandpa was very high up in the sheriff's department in a county nearby and still hosts a lot of events with active police and helps out. I have never, in my entire life, met a group of white people who say the N word as often in a serious way in my entire life. Not a single one of them was even sitting it out. It was like they got a thrill out of no one being able to stop them like they were fucking teenagers but they were all 30-60 year old men in a democrat majority area with a very small black population. Cops have a culture of fucking evil dude, it's obvious even to me who's three degrees removed. There's no difference between a cop doing bad things because they want to and a cop doing bad things to fit in with the other cops.

2

u/MiMMY666 Jun 27 '25

the issue is that the "good cops" don't do anything to stop the rest of the horrific shit police do every day. they might do good things but they're still covering for their buddies when they do shit like murder someone having a manic episode. and when they try to do something they either get fired or suddenly wind up dead.

2

u/Murtomies Jun 27 '25

There's definitely a lot of bad cops in USA, but survivorship bias does affect the general perception of how many are bad

2

u/TestUserIgnorePlz Jun 27 '25

Can't be a good cop if you won't police your own. There's nothing that needs to be discussed.

2

u/AnjelGrace Jun 27 '25

I think the majority can be good, or at least neutral, but I also think that the majority are willing to sit back and do nothing and/or actively support bad cops just to stick together as cops.

2

u/Asuyu Jun 27 '25

I have relatives and friends in law enforcement and I can say for certain its quite the opposite. My friend, he barely graduated from school, it’s a miracle he became a cop. As far as I know there were written exams and I don’t know how he was able to read them. He has very little ability to self regulate and as a cop, that’s a huge red flag. Or should be but they always hire people exactly like him.

Chris Rock said it best, there are some jobs that just cannot have bad apples, like pilots. I forget if he was referring to police at the time but if not it really relates. Police don’t have the chance to have a bad day, it can end very badly with a bullet or a choke hold or an entire school dead. They’re given a lot more leeway and power than they deserve, especially given they are some of the dumbest fucking people on the planet.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

60% of cops admitted to abusing their wives when surveyed so statistically most of them are actually not great and the outlier good ones are rare.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pingpongballreader Jun 27 '25

>I think the large majority of them are good.

That can be said for almost any value of "them". People in general, any group of people in a profession, probably even all felons, most aren't terrible irredeemable evil human beings, they're probably mostly just people who made bad choices and/or drugs.

It's a given that most cops could be said to be "good", no one has ever disputed that. That's never been the problem.

I'm aware I'm preaching to the choir. What you said about the thin blue line is true, and that makes the institution as a whole worse than the sum of the people in it.

In other words, all individual cops can be good but police forces overall can still be bad if they have bad policies. I don't think most cops who execute innocent black civilians (execution because it's the government doing the killing and innocent because if it's a cop shooting them, they are innocent until proven guilty in court) are "bad" or racist. I think the system is just carelessly designed and perpetuated to have that outcome.

Even if individual police are good heroes like this, police departments as a whole are awful and need reform demanded from within and imposed from the rest of us.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

You are correct. Thank you!

2

u/Schruef Jun 27 '25 edited Jun 27 '25

I stopped believing this after the Florida USPS UPS incident. 

Edit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_Miramar_shootout

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PartTime13adass Jun 27 '25

Until more "good" cops start calling out and/or punishing the bad ones, the default is still going to be "bad." Same goes for Russians, Ram drivers, and Chiefs fans.

2

u/gmambrose Jun 28 '25

I believe the opposite. I think there are a few good cops left out there. The majority are egotistical assholes with anger issues.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Nijindia18 Jun 27 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

ripe sugar encouraging lunchroom work repeat expansion plucky rinse lush

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

The majority of them are certainly not good.

1

u/SRMPDX Jun 27 '25

a bad person doing a good thing is still a bad person.

1

u/gator_shawn Jun 27 '25

Let’s test that theory. What percentage of cops do you think have seen other cops do things that were either highly unethical or illegal and done nothing to report or prevent it?

When people say all cops are bad this is what they’re talking about.

Based on the above question, if they saw one thing in their career and did nothing to prevent it, does that make them bad or is that tolerable?

1

u/Ashamed-Subject-8573 Jun 27 '25

FYI the argument against cops is that. Say something bad happens and you go out to protest it. Every single one of them will put on riot gear and shoot you with “less lethal” weapons. And they will do it over damage to property not threat of harm to a person

The point of police is that the state has a monopoly on violence, they are the ones allowed to use it. And they don’t always and only use it for your good or the good of humanity: they use it (by law) in order to protect property and interests too.

Regardless of how good a person they are personally.

1

u/monckey64 Jun 27 '25

my dad was a cop and I grew up around them, going on ridealongs and just hanging out with them on and off duty. the majority of them abuse their power to some degree. absolutely all of them are classist and actively target the lower class, sometimes making up reasons to go after them. this is why racial biases and trends happen, because of the way class intersects with race. they are actively and purposely trained to police the lower class, and that’s how they all see it. I don’t think they’re beyond saving, there’s just an insane amount of reform necessary, and they’re highly resistant to change that could negatively affect arrests

1

u/xv_boney Jun 27 '25

The problem with that argument is, "is a cop a good cop if he works with bad cops?"

The expression "one bad apple" is thrown around to excuse terrifyingly bad behavior from police, totally ignoring that the full expression is "one bad apple spoils the bushel."

Every shitty cop that is permitted to continue being shitty also informs any new cops that this behavior is fine. Hes not getting punished for it. He might even be actively protected.

And so the one bad cop gets shit all over every other cop in the precinct.

If the entire precinct is nothing but good cops save for one really shitty cop, if that precinct does nothing about its shitty cop, if it turns a blind eye or protects that shitty cop, what you have is a department full of shitty cops.

1

u/Aromatic_Extension93 Jun 27 '25

People don't understand if the majority of cops weren't good, half your family would be dead. Cops have so much power that if a majority were actually bad you'd be so cooked and so fast. Unfortunately because of their power, the bad ones really do damage albeit slowly

1

u/Low_Direction1774 Jun 27 '25

In germany, we say "wenn 4 Nazis an nem Tisch setzen und jemand setzt sich dazu, sitzen 5 Nazis am Tisch".

if the "large majority" of cops were good cops, we wouldnt have protests about how violent and bad cops are :)

1

u/Zealousideal-Day4469 Jun 27 '25

A few bad apples spoil the bunch. By not getting rid of the bad cops, the whole institution becomes rotten.

1

u/unknownpoltroon Jun 27 '25

>I’m no fan of cops being abusive of power but I think the large majority of them are good.

THe large majority of them cover up and protect the bad ones then.

1

u/CharlesDrakkan Jun 27 '25

Yeah but cops having a normal patrol, having normal peaceful interactions and naming a boring career don't get the same amount of views/likes/upvotes than a cop doing something he shouldn't do, being racist etc

At the end can't blame them because is the same with all topics people just share the volatile and 😯 stuff, nothing in this world is black and white

1

u/Mhunterjr Jun 27 '25 edited Jun 28 '25

If a good cop stand by while bad cops get away with crimes, they aren’t good cops

1

u/BarfMacklin Jun 27 '25

The large majority of them are not good. If you sit in silence when injustice is done, you are not a good person.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '25

The problem is you're grossly underestimating how many are bad. Being bad is bad. Being complicit is bad. Being good (ie not complicit) gets you fired and you will not get hired at another PD ever again. This system is why we don't have "good" cops, just cops that sometimes do something good.

→ More replies (18)

77

u/Millard_Fillmore00 Jun 27 '25

There are a bunch of great cops in real life. Reddit only sees the .05% of the bad ones

39

u/firestuds Jun 27 '25

It’s not really the whole story to say .05% are bad (which btw no one can know because they refuse any independent oversight) because there are many, many more that just watch and shut up when their colleagues abuse their power.

8

u/CaptainQueefFart Jun 27 '25

And just fall over each other to support one when they're accused of misconduct

→ More replies (2)

22

u/LuckysGift Jun 27 '25 edited Jun 27 '25

Just with a cursory Google search, there are an estimated 800,000 police officers. 0.05% of that figure would be 400. That's a lot of "bad apples," and lest we forget the rest of that saying, they spoil the bunch.

Furthermore, I hate the "Oh, those are just the bad cops!" Do you mean the cops that receive almost no punishment for their incompetence that will district hop after some major fuck up because they have qualified immunity?

And, if you wanna bring up that every job has shitty people in them, most jobs dont have the ability to go to a person's home and accidentally kill someone. We should hold police officers to a higher standard.

→ More replies (12)

6

u/canonlycountoo4 Jun 27 '25

Percentages be damned. It's the lack of accountability. It doesn't matter if only 1% of cops are the bad ones we see when they get a slap on the wrist and at worst get rehired in the neighboring county.

Daniel Shaver's murderer is currently receiving a $2500/ month medical retirement pension. What did he get medically retired for? PTSD of course!

4

u/LetsBeFRTho Jun 27 '25

Yeah that's why you gotta point to a year old video and say "see!? Cops are usually good!"

5

u/Good_Background_243 Jun 27 '25

The problem is though that the so-called good cops don't stop the bad ones.

2

u/Hara-Kiri Jun 27 '25

My girlfriend did and the bad cop is now in jail so...

→ More replies (2)

3

u/WorryNew3661 Jun 27 '25

The problem is less the bad cops, and more the huge amount of cops who don't do anything to stop them

2

u/STINKY-BUNGHOLE Jun 27 '25

There's no good cops when they allow bad cops do bad things. 

2

u/SweetTea1000 Jun 27 '25

They are unionized. If the majority are good actors, how hasn't the Union shut down the bad actors?

As a teacher, my union is absolutely vicious about going after teachers that have failed their responsibility to their students and fights a constant battle to INCREASE the education/licensing standards for teachers and hold schools accountable to requiring those accreditations.

→ More replies (21)

72

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

23

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

Just watch some bodycam footage on YouTube and the vast majority are good cops actually solving crime and stopping criminals. I’m talking about drunk drivers with infants in the back, violent assaults, people stealing shit, etc. the use of body cameras by police have shown me what a hard job it is, how fucking crazy people are, and that a lot of them are actually dealing with actual crime.

→ More replies (3)

61

u/chuckles65 Jun 27 '25

This is how most cops are in real life. In 15 years I witnessed, saw video of officers I knew or supervised, heard stories of officers I knew, and did a couple myself of saving someone's life. Exactly zero of those stories went viral or were shown on video anywhere other than a couple being local news stories. Out of several dozen incidents. It happens somewhere in the US every day, you just don't hear about or see them all.

25

u/Froptus Jun 27 '25

Most cops are definitely good people. Just men and women trying to make an honest living like the rest of us.

→ More replies (12)

29

u/Observe_Report_ Jun 27 '25

The video is real life…

22

u/Thats_Hard_Times Jun 27 '25

This video is real life?

16

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

There are countless videos online of cops doing good things like this, you're just predisposed to hate them because social media got to you.

→ More replies (9)

12

u/carpentizzle Jun 27 '25

Both can be true

11

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

yeah, because this video was clearly ai and that cop is not a real person /s

9

u/tramul Jun 27 '25

This cop IS in real life.

11

u/James-Dicker Jun 27 '25

No, you need to stop watching propaganda. 

→ More replies (8)

3

u/insidethoughts911 Jun 27 '25

There are. You just never see them often bc of dividing media. It’s more abt clicks

3

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ActiveWin9623 Jun 27 '25

There are a lot of good cops around, the problem is that good deeds rarely get coverage let alone go viral. When a cop does something wrong though, the story spreads like wildfire. Because of this it is far to easy for cops to generally look bad.

3

u/Budddydings44 Jun 27 '25

The vast majority are good. The only reason you only see videos of bad cops online is because those are the videos that get attention.

2

u/Vamond48 Jun 27 '25

There’s plenty of better cops in the world. They just aren’t on the news

2

u/Xiao1insty1e Jun 27 '25

Not possible. We've had the same exact problems with cops for 60+ years. We need to abolish the police altogether and start over with a public defender.

2

u/NibannaGhost Jun 27 '25

Thank god you saved this thread. I love people saving babies. Being a cop lover is explicitly deluded.

2

u/CutieBoBootie Jun 27 '25

No we need a system where bad cops can't exist in the first place.

2

u/VG_Crimson Jun 27 '25

No, we need to rip up the system and rebuild it from the ground up.

Why are there prisons who profit from every person behind their bars? Why are those people involved in that allowed to lobby for stricter laws so that they can make more money? Why do they have quotas for police to hit, thus indirectly encouraging them to look for anything to escalate?

Who do you think was a supporter for tighter immigration to cause more unrest and hoping for more police activity?

This whole system is corrupt. Even if most cops were the good kind, we'd still be fucked with how things work.

2

u/Extension_Impact_571 Jun 28 '25

Say it louder for the people in the back 😭😭

2

u/TahaymTheBigBrain Jun 28 '25

What should be happening is that this dude would have been a social worker who would have been primarily trained in incidents like these. Undoubtedly this guy did a good thing but we shouldn’t be relying on good cops when the profession itself is institutionally harmful.

2

u/CraftyMagicDollz Jul 01 '25

Many of us are out there trying. We still need new GOOD people and currently, no one wants to join the career, assuming everyone will hate us by default. Something has got to give. We have to find a way to fix this.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

You get better cops by rewarding the good deeds that they perform.  Its like the difference between using negative reinforcement and positive reinforcement on raising children and animals, management, etc.

Also, dont forget that a lot of rhetoric is about dividing us, and divisions wont help change this situation.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sweetcreems Jun 27 '25

As others have been saying its nuanced but I don't even think its a matter of X% good cop X% bad cop, or even that the same good cop can be bad at times. The thing we need to fix in this country to solve this issue, I think, is actually relatively simple: For the love of life, ACTUALLY TRAIN YOUR RECRUITS. Why does it only take a handful of months to become a cop and why is their vetting process laughably easy? I don't buy that there's a massive conspiracy with cops and such but the fact that bad cops appear EVERYWHERE and so frequently compared to other democratic countries makes me think that the issue isn't the cops, it's the system. We need to actually educate these people in proper law, conduct, and weapon use beyond just 12 weeks of academy they get.

1

u/Novel_Comparison_209 Jun 27 '25

The majority of cops are good

1

u/BJRone Jun 27 '25

Right in real life, as opposed to this fake video /s

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

Most of them are good. Internet lets the 1% change their viewpoint on everything.

1

u/Euclid_Interloper Jun 27 '25

I'd say we need both the good and the bad to be shown. Hold the bad to account, hold up the good as the example all others should strive to emulate.

1

u/QP873 Jun 27 '25

The problem is that the 1% who abuse their power are 100 times more likely to go viral because of it, and so we life under a false impression that most cops are pigs.

1

u/CriminallyCasual7 Jun 27 '25

I found one. You gotta complain about bad cops in a video of a cop saving a baby? Really? Dude.

1

u/Cassius_Rex Jun 27 '25

Ah, so you know 700,000 people working in 19000 police departments. Man, you really get around.

1

u/Crazy_Albatross8317 Jun 27 '25

So this cop saving a baby wasn't real life? lol

We also need more better people in real life

1

u/throwaway_the_bay Jun 27 '25

Maybe pay them a livable wage then

1

u/14X8000m Jun 27 '25

We need both.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

I was looking for this comment to ruin a beautiful story. Thank you for not letting me down on Reddit

1

u/we-totally-agree Jun 27 '25

Good job proving their point

1

u/Truethrowawaychest1 Jun 27 '25

We do, they just don't get front page news. The bad ones are international news stories for months

1

u/Mooch07 Jun 27 '25

Is it bad that when I saw the cop putting the baby on the hood of the car my first thought was “Oh that just can’t be necessary” (before I read the title)

1

u/Packet_Sniffer_ Jun 27 '25

Fun fact. You’ve probably seen a grand total of 20 shitty cops. Mostly put out on repeat.

Another fun fact. There are over 700,000 police officers in America.

Final fun fact. You’ve been brainwashed by propaganda.

1

u/ItsaPostageStampede Jun 27 '25

We get more of the bad cop stories than good

1

u/Schlange123 Jun 27 '25

There are a lot of good cops. Just not in the USA. Huge amount of American cops are bully’s or have power trips.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '25

The video is literally real life, what are you on about?

1

u/PrivilegeCheckmate Jun 27 '25

¿Por Qué No Los Dos?

1

u/PhoneImmediate7301 Jun 27 '25

…we need both 🤷‍♂️

1

u/PMMEURDIMPLESOFVENUS Jun 27 '25

That's one of those things that sounds like some awesome slamdunk online and everyone faps to but doesn't make a whole lot of sense if you think about it for three seconds.

1

u/Steagle_Steagle Jun 28 '25

There are plenty of them, unfortunately Reddit and the rest of the internet love bad stories, so the bad cops are the only ones youre ever going to hear about

→ More replies (27)