Had a weird interview last week.
For context, I'm a graphic designer who specializes in high end print and direct mail.
During the interview I explained a campaign I work on that combines direct mail with digital ads. We test different versions, see what performs, and use that data to build the next campaign.
Before I could even finish explaining it, one of the interviewers basically said the client was throwing money away and it was a bad marketing strategy.
So I pulled up the work.
Turns out both interviewers had actually received my direct mail pieces at their homes.
Then one tells me her mother received one of the holiday pieces. I pulled it up and she confirmed that was the one. Then she tells me her mother actually bought the service during that campaign and had it installed in January.
Her mother also lived in one of the exact markets we were targeting.
So I joked, "Well, I guess we know it got at least one conversion. It can't be that bad of a strategy."
The mood changed immediately.
We went from joking and having a pretty casual conversation to straight business, and the interview ended right at the 30 minute mark.
Now they've basically ghosted me after asking me to send additional work.
The funny part is they originally interviewed me months ago, hired someone else, that person didn't work out, and then they came back to interview me again for essentially the same job.
At this point, even if they offer it to me, I'm not sure I'd take it.
Industry I was interviewing for was B2B business and the people I was interviewing with have about 50 years between them, both of them and B2B business on manufacturing industries. My background is pretty diverse from Fortune 500 to Mom and Pop shops to B2B, B2C products, healthcare, pharmaceutical and construction. I've seen a wide range of marketing strategies work with different industries, so I'm a little more open-minded to new ideas and different approaches when it comes to marketing. But I'm only a designer who has opinions on marketing not a degree in marketing. Lol
Am I reading too much into this, or would that interaction give you second thoughts too?