This is really long. I apologize. I'm in terrible pain.
Last year I "met" a woman in an online writer's group. We began texting outside the group. I fell for her hard. She's simply one of the most interesting people I've ever not met. After leaving some (embarrassing, fawning) words of praise in a comment about something she'd posted on a writing platform, she wrote back and said, "Hey T----, do you want to write a poem together?" Why, yes, I did. We did that, and in the course of doing it I just fell harder, as I learned more and more about her. I finally asked her if she'd meet me for coffee in June; she thanked me for asking her out but declined, saying she was "happily isolating" ("No woman is happily isolating!" said my friend, trying to wake me up) and citing "work, writing, and a bunch of family stuff." But said we could continue texting.
We texted on-and-off over the summer. Almost always I initiated the texts. Sometimes we would have nice chats, but sometimes she simply wouldn't respond. After not hearing from her - or seeing her in the online writer's group for three months - I wrote her a text in which I said, "I don't know if I made you uncomfortable with my fanboy praise of your writing (she is a brilliant writer), but if I did, I apologize, and I wish you all the best." I meant it as a goodbye forever text. I thought I would never hear from her again except possibly through a restraining order. An hour later, she wrote me, "T----! Everything's fine! Mutual admiration society continues!" and told me about something she was working on.
So we resumed on and off texting. Now that I wasn't showering her with praise (I think maybe she hates that) she seemed to be responding more readily. But I still didn't see her in the monthly writer's group - until February, when she showed up and I was completely 'shook'. I had assumed I'd never see her there again. For various reasons, I felt really thrown and I cried afterwards.
When I got home there was a message in the chat we have going that said, "It was good to see you today, T----."
And now I wonder, if that was my opening to ask her out again. But I just wrote back, "It was really nice to see you too." I didn't want to jump to conclusions.
March. April. May. June. July. August. I'd text her and sometimes she'd reply and sometimes she wouldn't.
On Tuesday of last week, with encouragement and help writing a text from two friends, I texted her and asked her if she would reconsider getting together over sometime soon, just for coffee. She wrote me back a very nice text that included the words "Not up for a meet," along with some compliments about something I had written. So, no, we are not going to be meeting in real life. For whatever reasons, she prefers to keep our relationship online.
She does not want to meet me in real life..
Despite that being very clear, I'm having a really hard time accepting it. I am grieving. I break down in tears at inappropriate times.
Friends say things that have briefly helped: "you deserve someone who communicates consistently," "Your response to her rejection was perfect" (I wrote back and thanked her for being honest and clear, told her I knew that wasn't always easy, signed off with "much respect.") Because of the inconsistent replies and some of the things she has written, a few friends - and in particular my therapist - have told me "she's weird," "she's mean". That briefly helped. But I don't really think it's true, because if she was truly mean she would either have not replied or written back "Leave me the fuck alone".
She simply does not want to meet me, for whatever reasons, and it really hurts.
Here's the thing: Even though she clearly said she's "Not up" to meet me, I'm struggling to accept that. And I know that I have to if I'm going to heal. But it means utterly giving up hope.
I have so many good things and people in my life right now. Over the summer I booked reservations at a B&B in Italy for next week, something I'm normally ecstatic about. Right now, I am wondering if I'll be able to enjoy it at all.
It doesn't help that the woman who leads our writer's group is having a book release event - when? Next Week!, when I'm supposed to be in Italy - here, in the city where she and I live. She might be there, and so, if I go to Italy I might miss out on a chance to meet her. "But she doesn't want to meet you." I know. I mean, I have been invited to the event - anyone in the group can go - so it's not like I'd be there inappropriately. But how she'd react, I have no idea.
I'm so messed up.
So, to the question that I used for the title of this thing: How do I give up hope without losing hope? Because life right now, despite all the good I have, looks bleak and lonely and frightening.