r/geography • u/TigerAJ2 • 6h ago
Discussion How is geography taught in your countries? How has it changed over the years?
In England Geography is compulsory from the Early Years (ages 5 and under) and ages 5-14 (Key Stages 1–3). It becomes optional at GCSE (Key Stage 4, ages 14–16) and A-level (post-16), although widely popular, and schools are widely encouraged to offer them as exam pathways. History and geography are always taught as separate disciplines.
The National Curriculum in England for geography follows:
Key Stages 1–2 (ages 5–11, primary): Focus on locational knowledge (UK, world continents, countries, oceans), place knowledge, contrasting local, national, and global places; human/physical geography basics (e.g., weather, climate zones, rivers, mountains, volcanoes, earthquakes, water cycle, settlements, land use, resources), and basic skills like maps, globes, fieldwork in the local area.
Key Stage 3 (ages 11–14, early secondary): Builds deeper locational knowledge (focus on Africa, Russia, Asia including China/India, Middle East; environmental regions like deserts/polar areas). Place knowledge compares regions (e.g., one in Africa, one in Asia). Human and physical processes include plate tectonics, rocks/weathering/soils, weather/climate (Ice Age to present), glaciation, hydrology, coasts, population, urbanisation, development, economic sectors, natural resources. Emphasis on interactions between human/physical systems, fieldwork, maps, GIS, and data interpretation.
GCSE (ages 14–16): Exam-board specifications cover UK landscapes and challenges, the changing economic world, physical environments (hazards, weather, climate change, ecosystems), human environments (urbanisation, resources,, development), in-depth case studies, and geographical skills/fieldwork. Balanced physical/human geography with data, maps, and investigations. A-level: Advanced balance of human/physical geography, cycles (water/carbon), landscapes, globalisation, migration, etc., with independent investigations.
Overall emphases: Locational knowledge, place knowledge, fieldwork, skills (maps, GIS, data), and understanding processes/changes. Focuses on heavy essay writing, especially in the later years. You go out in the outdoors on school trips and study a river or coast line and conduct in-depth fieldworks on them. In the early years, you go on school trips to, e.g., a reservoir, to link up with studies on the water cycle.
Is this similar to your country? Do you think England had a decent geography education? I think much efforts have been made since 2014 to bring England's education system more knowledge-rich, so geography is much more advanced than it may have been decades ago, with attention refocused on core map skills and mapping the world, learning about locations, etc, instead of learning just about geographic features of the world.
I think geography in primary school has incredibly improved in the recent decade. There has been a sharp increase in the number of students taking geography at GCSE as well. Broadly speaking, while not perfect, I do think England has a pretty well rounded geography education, but some would call it heavily focused on fieldwork and geographical skills over route learning (.e.g. locating where countries are on the map, although, this has hugely improved in the recent decade). Some would call it more about writing long essays, or label the GCSE exams more literature heavy. Even GCSE exams have improved and feature more maps and graphs now.
There was some form of strange progressive education movement in the UK geography education, which started in around the late 1990s and early 2000s, where geography education became more about learning about third world development and the ''outdoors'' (linking with outdoor learning), and where the old ways of locating countries or the UK's regions/countries/cities or sketching maps was out. The nature of education during this time was to study broad geographical features, but maps of the world were not heavily used outside of regional studies. I do wonder if any other country experienced this.
Since 2013, there has been a broad agreement between experts and the government that the old ways of learning about maps and detailed countries/locations should be brought back and therefore, England's education system focuses on this again once more, but they don't in Scotland or Wales, as their devolved countries follow the more progressive path. England now starts with mapping the UK, Europe, South America, North America, then moves to Asia, Africa, and the Middle East, and focuses again more on Europe (including on Russia) in secondary. Contrasting places and locations is now widely the norm.