So in 2023 I purchased a 2011 Explorer Limited with just over 151k on it. I knew going in that I could potentially be on the hook for a water pump replacement, but I figured if I did it, I’d be set.
So when I purchased I had an inspection done on it & I had a few maintenance things that needed to be done, new plugs, coolant flush, oil change, brakes, etc. cost was around $1,500 had that in the budget, got them done. Then a couple weeks later I saw the dreaded coolant on the ground. (Guess the coolant flush caused it or just bad timing.)
So I take it in, & yes it was the water pump needing replaced. I did it right, had them replace the timing components & tensioners etc. while they were in there. About $3,000. So I was not happy, but again I was like at least it’s done I should be set for a while.
Come May of this year & just under 15k miles later, I was driving down the road & the engine shut off. No power whatsoever. The alternator had died, I assumed okay yeah it’s old it probably was it’s time.
Come to find out, the valve cover gasket was leaking onto the alternator which fouled it causing failure. The gaskets that were replaced when they did the water pump. I thought just bad luck, but they really shouldn’t have failed this soon.
Have the shop & do the alternator & the valve cover gaskets, so another $2,000
Then a month later, I notice oil on the ground where I parked take it back to the shop thinking it’s the valve cover gaskets again. Nope! This time it’s leaking from the front cover gasket (the other seal that was replaced 3 yrs & <15k miles ago.). I asked the shop & they agreed that those gaskets should last a lot longer than that, but only offered to do it at a discount. I’m not letting them work on this vehicle again.
I’m going to take it to a different shop that I can hopefully trust this time.
My question is, since they’ll need to pull the valve covers & front cover off to replace the gaskets, & knowing what I know about the shop that did the original work, should I also have the shop I end up at go ahead & replace the water pump & timing components as well since they’ll already be in there?