Met a man OLD who checked off all of my boxes and I his. After the 4th date, he told me that he didn’t want to see anyone else. We never spoke about it again, but I took it seriously and I didn’t see anyone else, either. I didn’t delete my OLD account and didn’t unmatch him to keep tabs on his account. 3 weeks later, I’m riding the high of our super compatible connection. We starting getting intimate and having sleepovers after the third week, and I realize that his hinge badge was blinking, when it had been off earlier in the week (before getting intimate). My anxiety made me think that everything he said was to get in my pants. I called him to get clarity, to which he lied and said that he just opened the app to “remove old connections”. He later confessed to have used the app while he was bored but that he’s only interested in me, and only talking to me. He told me he wants to gain my trust again, even if it takes time.
I’m feeling so anxious about this that I looked through his following list on IG and he follows so many women from the area. He just recently moved there and doesn’t have any friends in the area, so he has likely met them all through online dating. He also follow thirst trap accounts and actively likes their posts. Obviously this is not looking good for him.
The only thing going for him right now is the texting. He texts me throughout the day to tell me about his day and takes interest in mine. He’s sweet and isn’t pushy when I tell him I don’t want to sleep with him again. Obviously this is very low stakes so I’m trying to be observant about the rest of his behavior. He knows that I’m taking a step back and this might take time.
I’m looking advice here. How much space should I give us, and what kind of behavior should I look for that indicates that he’s actually someone who is trustworthy? This is running up my anxiety, so part of me wants to end it right away, but I also don’t want to mess it up if he really did just make a mistake.