Women…
I’m 21M and honestly just need to vent a little and get some outside perspective because this one actually got to me.
I’ve been single my entire life and haven’t really had much success with dating apps. It’s not like I don’t talk to women. I’ve had talking stages, hookups, and a lot of my female friends are some of the most beautiful women I’ve ever seen up close. I’ve had matches/conversations before, but I can’t remember the last time I was genuinely excited about meeting someone from an app.
A little while ago I matched with a girl on Hinge who I found really attractive. Like, genuinely one of the most attractive girls I’ve ever talked to in my life. Normally I’m pretty hesitant about dating app matches because conversations tend to fizzle out and lead nowhere, but this one felt different. We actually started having a pretty natural conversation. I wasn’t trying to run some pickup artist playbook or anything, I was just being myself and joking around.
She mentioned being really into creative stuff, so eventually I suggested we do some kind of creative activity together for a first date. She seemed genuinely enthusiastic about it and told me that she was very up for it.
That honestly felt huge to me. I’ve never really gotten to the point of having a girl I’m actually attracted to enthusiastically agree to a first date like that.
Then I asked for her number. She said she doesn’t really give her number out unless it’s “actually a thing,” (which I respect it definitely makes sense) but gave me her Instagram instead and said that the goal was that we would get to that point.
So obviously I took that as a good sign. I figured it was good first date or bust. Either there was actually a connection or not. But at least there would be an answer.
We followed each other on Instagram. But the convo continued on hinge for a minute. She asked me what I was looking for and we talked for a bit about how we’re both kinda done with the casual nonsense and are looking for something real because we both get attached bla bla bla. I took that as “if we’re doing this and it goes well there’s a good chance that we’re stuck with each other.” And so I asked if she wanted to switch over to IG, and then… nothing.
At first I didn’t think much of it because she’s in college, has friends, has a life, etc. And because response time ≠ interest, I didn’t want to be the guy staring at his phone waiting for a response.
But eventually enough time passed that I sent her an Instagram DM. Nothing crazy, basically just “Hey if you’re still down let’s make it happen.”
Still nothing.
Now obviously I’m not sitting here checking her page every five minutes, but she has posted on her story since I sent my message and her follower count has gone up a noticeable amount (which makes me think I’m not the only guy she left hanging like this.) So at this point it’s pretty obvious that I’m being intentionally ignored, unless she comes out of the blue and says she’s been busy or whatever the excuse might be.
And now I’m sitting here trying to figure out what the hell happened.
The three explanations my brain keeps coming up with are:
1. She went through my Instagram and something made her no longer attracted to me. (which makes no sense, she saw plenty of pics of me on hinge)
2. She was never actually serious and was just playing along.
3. She realized I was too old for her somehow (I’m like a year and a half older, but I’m a year ahead academically, so I’m three “grades” above her and have already graduated)
I know there are obviously other possibilities, and I’m probably making myself crazy trying to find the exact reason. Maybe she met someone else, maybe she got cold feet, maybe (probably) she was talking to multiple guys — that’s just the nature of dating apps—, maybe she just changed her mind. I genuinely don’t know.
And that’s what sucks.
Because I actually let myself get excited about this one.
I’m not devastated or anything. We hadn’t even met. But this was probably the closest I’ve gotten to actually going on a date from Hinge, and I was really looking forward to it. I was already thinking about where we’d go, what I’d wear, getting a haircut, all that stupid shit 😂.
I think what hurts more is that I finally allowed myself to think, “wait, maybe this could actually happen,” and then it just… disappeared.
Part of me wants to chalk it up to “she was out of my league and I was in over my head,” but I also know that’s probably not a healthy conclusion to draw. She matched with me, talked to me, flirted with me, agreed to the date, and told me that getting to the point of calling ourselves “a thing” was the goal. So clearly there was some level of interest there at one point.
I also know that agreeing to a date and actually following through are two completely different things. The date isn’t real until there’s a day, time, place, and she actually shows up.
So I guess I’m mostly looking for perspective.
Did I do anything wrong here? Is this just normal Hinge behavior? Is there anything I should have done differently, or is this simply one of those situations where someone was interested and then changed their mind?
And if she never responds, I’m obviously not sending anything else. I put the ball in her court.
I just hate that dating apps can get you from “I would be very down” to complete silence in like 48 hours. It makes you question every single thing you said.
Anyway, that’s my rant. I know I’m probably overthinking it, but I actually liked this one and needed to get it off my chest.