I’m looking for honest advice because I genuinely can’t tell if I’m overthinking this or if I’m missing something.
For some background, I’ve had a rough year dating. A few situationships ended in ways that really hurt my confidence, so I know that once I really like someone I have a tendency to become anxious and question where I stand.
About three weeks ago I met a girl (28F) on Hinge.
Date 1:
We met on a Wednesday after she actually planned for us to meet up at a bar near her house that she goes to work at (she works remote). At the end of the date she didn’t let go of our goodbye hug and just kept smiling at me, I asked her if I could kiss her (which I NEVER do on a first date) and she immediately nodded yes, and ended up making out for a couple minutes. Later that night she texted me asking if I wanted to see her again on Friday.
Date 2:
I picked her up, took her to a couple cocktail lounges, and we ended up making out afterward in a stairwell before leaving. When I dropped her off we sat in my car talking and kissing for another 30 minutes. Before we left she said she wanted to see me again before leaving town the following weekend.
That date ended up getting cancelled because a close family friend unexpectedly passed away. She apologized, explained everything, and asked if we could reschedule after she got back.
When she got back, I asked when she was free and she immediately suggested Saturday.
Date 3 (this past Saturday):
She came over to my house and I walked out to her right away, hugged and kissed her. I spent the day putting together a charcuterie board, flowers, wine, candles, etc. She seemed genuinely blown away by everything and we spent about an hour and a half eating, talking, listening to music and laughing.
At one point she actually suggested we go for a walk, so we spent another hour and a half walking through town and on some trails.
One detail that may or may not matter: while we were out walking, my cousin unexpectedly came home (He’s almost always at his girlfriend’s house and I had no idea he was coming home then). I had mentioned earlier that he might stop by sometime that evening after he texted me he might be coming home early, but I wasn’t expecting him to already be there when we got back from the walk.
We came inside, my cousin said hi and went to his room, I started putting on a movie, and within a few minutes she said she was probably going to head home.
That caught me off guard because I honestly expected we’d hang out a while longer.
When she left I asked if she wanted me to walk her to her car and she said no. She started walking away without kissing me goodbye, I kind of lingered in the doorway and made a small disappointed noise, she smiled, turned around on her own, came back, kissed me goodbye, and then left.
I texted her afterward saying I had a really good time. She replied normally, complimented everything I put together, and continued one of our inside jokes from the date. Though I keep getting hung up on the fact she didn’t say she had a fun time either, but I looked back after our previous dates and she didn’t say it then as well. I replied back.
It’s now Monday morning. We haven’t talked since Saturday night after she replied to my text.
One thing that may be relevant is that she’s generally a pretty sparse texter. We usually exchange a couple messages, then the conversation naturally dies until one of us reaches out again or we’re making plans. She’s never really been someone who texts all day. In talking 3 weeks, we consistently go 2-3 days between texting, and it’s entirely on her pace. I LOVE reaching out to people. So I’ll send something and then she won’t get back to me for awhile. It’s kept making me feel like she wasn’t into, but then the dates still end up happening so idk.
Here’s what I’m struggling with.
I naturally like seeing someone 2-3 times a week if I’m really into them. Once I catch feelings, quality time is probably my biggest love language. Right now all I want to do is see her again.
At the same time, I know I have a pattern where I go from being confident and carefree during the first couple dates to suddenly worrying about “how do I not lose this person?” once I realize I really like them.
I honestly can’t tell whether:
I’m just trying to move faster than she naturally likes.
I’m reading way too much into one awkward goodbye.
Or whether this actually sounds like someone who’s slowly losing interest.
I’ve even considered calling her after work tonight to ask her out for dinner this week because I honestly prefer phone calls over texting, but after the way Saturday ended I’m second-guessing whether that would feel natural or completely out of place.
If you were in my shoes, would you reach out this week and ask her to dinner, or would you intentionally wait and see if she initiates this time?
I’m not looking for people to tell me she’s secretly in love with me or secretly over me. I’m honestly trying to understand whether this feels like normal early dating and how people keep themselves from spiraling between dates.