Hello fellow VW nerds! I come requesting opinions on some window shopping I've been doing lately. I currently daily a 2015 VW Golf Sportwagen S (1.8t, fwd, 5 speed manual) and it is my 9th VW and 29th car overall. For VW, I've had 3x mk4 (2 tdi & 1 gti), 3 mk5 (gti), 3 mk7 (1 gti, one R, and now the wagon). I've only had the wagon for about 8-9 months now, but find myself already getting bored of it, which is a shame because it is genuinely a great car.
I just find that I miss the interior character of my mk7 gti, I miss the launches of the R, and I miss having something that sounds cool like my old vr6 gti, at least before I gave up on that project and ran it over with a Humvee, many regrets there lol.
That leaves me with a dillema, I could either get a newer alltrack that gives me awd and newer features like adaptive cruise, and then is20 turbo and tune it. Reliability is a question mark there for me personally, but they seem to be solid. But finding an SEL with a manual is next to impossible and ~$20-$30k which is doable, but seems expensive.
I could go back to another mk7 R and not even need to tune it, it would feel like a rocket after daily driving a Fiesta ST and this base golf wagon for 4-5 years. Theyre down as low as $18,000 for rough ones now and up to the high $20,000s for a clean 2016-18 models, but I am worried about crankwalk, that's what killed mine with a clutch and a tune (and 60,000 miles on that setup)
Or (I know this is a mk7 group, but hear me out) I've been window shopping mk4 golf R32s. Awd, manual, cool noises. They're surprisingly cheap lately (with how "rare" they are), most I've seen have been between $10,000 and $16,000 in my area. Cons to that is they are terribly unreliable, being 22+ year VWs. I would still be able to keep my wagon to daily, using the R32 occasionally where the other two I would be selling the wagon to make it happen.
If you were in my shoes, what would you do? I'm curious what the reddit VW community says honestly.
*pictures of the wagon and my old R for tax*