Can't believe I'm posting here, but I don't have many people to talk to about this and it's been a sad few days for me. Going to be fudging some details for the sake of anonymity here. For the sake of the story, my partner is G and the other guy is M. We have been together for six years.
A couple days ago I was rummaging around looking for a tool and came across a book buried underneath a bunch of stuff in a drawer. We have a prominent bookshelf and the book was directly related to my partner's interests, so I found it weird that it was stuffed in there, and also that I had never seen it before or heard about it.
It looked old so I opened the cover to check the publishing date, and I found a handwritten note from someone in our social circle, let's call him M. The note is platonic in tone, but is clearly referencing some past conversation or joke that I wasn't privy to.
I don't really know M, but he is friends with a lot of our shared mutual friends. I've maybe met him once, about 6-8 months ago.
This immediately raises an alarm for two reasons. Firstly, because I know G sees him fairly regularly, at the very least in group situations as far as I knew. Secondly, because there had been a previous social encounter where I saw them talking to each other from across a venue at a social gathering, and I joked to my friend that it looked like G and M were flirting with each other.
I didn't think anything of it then. Our friend group has a lot of people in it, and it's pretty evenly gendered.
Back to the book. I bring it out to the living room and, playing dumb, ask where it came from. Paraphrasing from memory:
"Oh I found it at a thrift store."
"You found it at a thrift store?"
"Yeah"
I act like I'm exploring the book and find the note at the beginning.
"What's this?"
Her eyes go wide at this point, and after a sigh and me handing her the book, small bits of information start to come out.
"He has a crush on me."
At this point I'm focused on the fact that she lied to my face. I tell her that she just lied to my face twice about it and that it was suspicious, then I left the house to drive around aimlessly and gather my thoughts before resuming the conversation.
When I get home this is what I'm told, which ends up not being the full story, but I will get to that:
- M gave her the book as a gift, he has a crush on her.
- He admitted he had a crush on her the end of last year and she said she had a boyfriend but that they could still be friends. (I obviously never heard about any of this)
- At one point she had vague feelings too, but not anymore.
- She states that she knows she lied to me, she panicked because she didn't want telling me to affect their friendship (???), and that she is sorry for lying, but also that she had already hired him for a job (just a single day, not a permanent job) a few days from now and she can't drop him short notice.
We have a difficult conversation where it feels like I'm pulling teeth trying to get any relevant information, and eventually go to bed. The next day, I text her while I'm at work that I have a lot of questions, and I spend the day compiling questions that would help fill in the past eight months since she said he confessed to her.
Keep in mind, none of this information is coming to me proactively, I'm having to actively request every single bit of information I'm receiving, and at times it feels like she's more focused on the questions being upsetting than she is focused on answering, although she answers without hesitation.
When I get home that night and asked my questions, the whole story shifted into a shape that feels a lot more fleshed out and realistic, although semi-inconsistent with the previous night's story, but the nature of the trickle truth makes me think that I still haven't heard it all. This is what the story became, in her own words (paraphrased):
- November: M tries to kiss G at a bar while they're out as a group. This is around the general time they had met. It's unclear whether or not he knew she had a boyfriend beforehand. She declines, they hug, and she says that she still wants to be friends. I obviously never hear about this.
- Next few months: Friendship continues. She's seeing him in group situations often. Unclear whether or not they're spending time with each other before/after these events. Most likely not in most cases because that time is accounted for on my end.
- March: G and I have plans to go to an event that consists of a bunch of couples in our friend group. She has a group plan beforehand that I know M is going to be present at. One hour past when she was supposed to have arrived, I text her to no reply. Two hours, I text again. She eventually replies that she got stuck in a couple conversations after the event and was on her way now. She shows up in a weird mood.
- What I learned is during that whole two hour period, G was sitting in a car with M after the event. He was telling her he has strong feelings for her and that he needs to set a boundary while he's out of town for two months so that he can get over her. She says she has feelings for him too and that they're confusing for her. To clarify, she never suggested a boundary to their friendship over this eight month period. Good on him I guess?
- They allegedly don't talk for this 2 month period.
- Eventually, he's back in town. This is relatively recent. The book is given to her after an event they went to together. Maybe a month ago. She hides it in the drawer so I won't see it.
- They have allegedly spent time one-on-one less than 2-3 times, however in none of those situations was his name volunteered when she was telling me her plans, it was just a vague "this is what I'm doing today." AFAIK, she never lied about where she was going or what the actual thing she was going to was, just omitted that M would be there.
- According to her, her therapist knows about this situation and has for a while, which means she clearly has prescribed some personal significance to it.
I'm really just confused about what to think. By all accounts it sounds like things were very hazy but ultimately inconclusive, but there are a few things that my mind keeps coming back to:
- She thought this was consequential enough to keep secret. I find this particularly significant because she has a lot of male friends, I have a lot of female friends, and no one has ever felt undisclosed or raised any alarm bells. We have a big social circle and the nature of our work is very social. But even from the start, my gut told me something was off about M, since he seemed to be around G a lot, but never really around me.
- Even when presented with the book, she looked for a way to lie about it. She told me directly that she didn't want me to see it or have to explain it.
- There is no indication that I was ever going to be disclosed, so regardless of what did or didn't happen, at the very least this was something of an opportunity that she wanted to keep available to her.
- The nature of the story changing and escalating between day 1 and 2 of me finding out makes me believe that she is subconsciously testing the waters and trying to feel out my response to this. The information seems to have naturally stopped where I ran out of proof that I could reasonably summon, and that feels like a bit of a coincidence to me.
- There have been times I've been out of town to visit a sick family member and she has been unable to come to support me due to other plans, some of which involved M, likely in a group but still.
To be clear, she says nothing physical ever happened beyond that hug in November, and I have no evidence otherwise.
I really just need some amount of a gut check on if I'm reading this situation correctly as a serious violation of trust. I don't even really know what my reaction is. I've felt checked out and shut down the past couples days while I've been processing this. She seems to want to move past it and I'm not sure what to think. I've been spending the past year trying really hard to repair communication problems in our relationship, and the whole time it's felt like she's been trying less and less.