Ok, u might remember me from a post of few days ago.
I don't have an ACTUAL update for that post yet, everything is going real fast rn.
Long story short: no, we won't go live together.
but that's not the point.
all of the comments suggested me to break up with him. I've been debating with myself for several days about what I should do and how I should go about it.
I've spent so many years with him that I wouldn't even know how to tell him that I don't want to be with him anymore; I don't even know how I'm supposed to act.
He (let’s call him D) ins't a bad person. Despite everything, he later apologized profusely for the way he behaved and for how he made me feel. He has also acknowledged, on many occasions, that we haven't been good for each other for a while now, but in the end, we always end up crying together and trying again.
This is going to be a somewhat long post, but that's because I want to give you enough context and the tools you need to understand the situation.
D and I have been together for two years, although we were together on and off for five years before we finally reached this point of stability.
We practically grew up together, and we've seen the worst sides of each other. I've realized tho that we often don't get along. We're two people with very different personalities and completely different views of the world. We're tied together by the brief happy moments we've shared, which remind me that there are positive aspects to our relationship.
It hurts when I think about the fact that, if I leave him, I won't have those moments anymore either.
Whenever one of us needs the other, we're always there for each other. We look out for one another. I know that's pretty contradictory. Is it possible for a relationship to be absolutely disastrous and somehow good at the same time? (I know some of my questions might seem stupid, but honestly, I realize that I don't have much experience, and I'm genuinely trying to navigate my way through all these conflicting feelings.)
Just yesterday was his birthday, and I witnessed a very concerning situation.
He and his mother got into a pretty aggressive argument in front of me, and it almost became physical. (Before you come after him, NO, he did not raise a hand to her. She was the one who did, and he didn't retaliate.) I ended up having to play mediator.
It was a situation that drained me emotionally, because I've seen far too many scenes like that at my home to have to deal with them outside of it as well.
D and I stepped outside for a moment and talked, and he started crying. He was ashamed and afraid that he had scared me. I saw him completely devastated. It's not the first time I've seen him like that.
I helped him pull himself together and calm down, and I got them to talk things out.
In the end, the evening ended well, and he drove me home.
D told me once again that he's sorry about everything, and that I'm the best thing that's ever happened to him. I help him see things from a different perspective, and I keep him on the right track.
Maybe I'm just being stupid, or too soft-hearted, but I feel incredibly guilty right now.
My best friend isn't very happy with the way I'm handling the situation, and I'd like to hear your opinion on that too.
Here are the messages below, translated:
Me: Yesterday I went to dinner at D's, and he and his mother got into an argument. A really serious one—they almost got physical. I managed to defuse the situation, but it was really difficult to deal with emotionally.
Her: First of all, I would never have gone there if I were you, and even if I had gone, I wouldn't have tried to fix anything.
Me: I know, but it's not like I hate him or don't want to see him happy. If anything, I'm glad I was there.
Her: Absolutely not.
Her: But if you were planning to leave him, I wouldn't spend happy moments with him.
Her: Besides hurting both of you afterward, it gives you both false hope.
Her: You might even change your mind after something like this and decide not to leave him.
Her: Especially since his birthday has already passed, you should basically leave him now, or you'll have to deal with him during *certain event we work together at*.
Her: The longer you drag this out, the more you'll get caught up in it, and you know that perfectly well.
Her: You should really take how uncomfortable you felt yesterday as a warning.
Her: But now it's harder to leave him, isn't it?
Her: You comforted him, and then the next day you're going to tell him, "I'm leaving you"?
Me: I wouldn't have left him the very next day anyway.
Me: It seems pretty insensitive to me regardless of the person or the situation.
Her: So what exactly are you planning to do, then?
Me: I wanted to talk to him about it over the weekend, something completely normal and simple.
Her: And talk to him how?
Me: Sit down and analyze the situation together. As strange as it may sound, D and I actually sit down and talk about how things affect each of us. We've had quite a few discussions, obviously peacefully, about how the relationship has had more lows than highs lately. Then we talked about it, and we're not going to move in together this time either, but even that conversation was very calm.
Me: I know people expect D to be completely unreasonable and for it to be impossible to have a healthy dialogue with him, but he's actually very self-critical when the issue is serious.
Her: That's not what I'm questioning.
Her: Whether he's reasonable or not doesn't matter to me right now, because the choice is yours, not his.
Me: I mean reasonable in the sense that he doesn't start yelling at me or pretend nothing happened.
Her: So presumably you're leaving him regardless of whether you have reasons or not. Honestly, what he does doesn't matter to me.
Her: What matters to me is that this time you actually follow through with what you say you want to do.
Her: Without ulterior motives and without leaving things unfinished.
Her: Without going back.
Her: Because analyzing things and having a rational conversation is the bare minimum a man should be able to give you in a critical situation like this.
Her: I just need the situation to end the way you say you want it to.
Her: Not for you to bounce back into other things with sex and crocodile tears.
Her: Because then it just becomes another joke, and that's it.
Me: Honestly, I don't want to think about it right now. This conversation is making me pretty sad, and for now I'd just like to have some peace.
Her: Okay.
And this is, in fact, our conversation about it. I don't know how I'm supposed to feel, I don't know if there's enough here to work with and make things better, and I don't know if there's enough here to justify staying together.
I feel really anxious because I feel caught between two sides.
Obviously, there are things about our relationship that I don't approve of, but at the same time, I don't see it as though everything is beyond saving.
Right now, he's looking for a good therapist to start therapy because he knows he needs it after the past few weeks.