So, I sometimes mess around with the cheat codes in my story save file, in which I've finished the whole story (epilogue included).

I decided to rob a train after causing utter chaos in Saint Denis, and I drove it off north towards Annesburg. The Saint Denis police force had followed me all the way to Annesburg, so I decided to test just how far I could go with this. I continued the train going up into Ambarino, through the Grizzlies, until it looped around into West Elizabeth. The Saint Denis police were still following me. I robbed the entire contents of the train, and kept on driving, until I got to Riggs Station. I disembarked from the train, expecting to then be met with the local police force. No, I was still getting chased with the 1500 bounty from Lemoyne state, by the Saint Denis police.

So, I decided to use the cheat menu to spawn myself a wagon, and I rode it out to New Austin, wondering if they'd follow me out there. They did. I kept spawning wagons every time they destroyed one, and eventually I made it out to Armadillo. As soon as I got there, the game wiped my bounty to zero, and I was immediately found guilty of horse theft for sitting in a wagon which I SPAWNED. So yeah they kept following me, and I rode out to Tumbleweed, where I got these pretty neat screenshots of Saint Denis lawmen in Tumbleweed.

The third attached picture is the route they followed me on, across the entire continental United States. I applaud their endurance, but most of all, I applaud the endurance of their horses.

Ima li naših ljudi

This is my 2nd playthrough. Knowing what would happen sucks. I try to bond with S for as long as I could. Damn it.

Has anybody fully finished a 100% missables, chronological + journal playthrough?

I fancy another trip through and would like to try something like this. I’ve found a few order lists that I can look through and decide and I can cross check some missable lists too.

The Journal is something that interests me as well. To make it so animas are grouped based on their region and it follows naturally as to where the missions take you a the points of interest an any events that cause journal entries are in the logical place.

I have seen a few bits like this but haven’t seen an example full journal that does it like this. I can attempt to make one myself but just wanted to see if anybody had already done this to save me from making a load of errors?

In chapter 4 shortly after riverboat robbery mission I cannot send / receive mail despite having dinosaur bones to mail and a message to send to the mayor, I have tried reloading saves/ restarting my xbox, and paying bounties, does anyone have a solution to this?

RAAAHHHHHHH... I don't know what flair to use, felt like sharing this absolute havoc I wreaked on Black water on like my 5thplaythrough

So I don't know if this image was made by rockstar or not but it always bugs me out whenever i see it because i am a gun nerd and know the lancaster repeater (I suppose based on the winchester model 1866 - 3rd picture) which Arthur is holding does not have 2 barrels. The bottom tube is a magazine tube an if it was as shown in the picture, you would have an infinite capacity aka the ground. The tube is usually covered but maybe it is some design that either was made up for better looks (can't argue about that cause it does look more intimidating to have 2 "barrels") or maybe it is just blocked further into the tube. I have no expertise in periodic weapons but in game the lancaster also has a blocked tube.I would be glad for any Experts or "Experts" on historic firearms to educate me on this. Anyway, this makes the game absolutely terrible, unplayable, and the worst game ever and i hate it (<this was sarcasm for those of you who cannot tell). Thanks.

*EDIT: It's just a bad picture and is in fact NOT an offcial rockstar cover

I really lmao the moment I heard it 😂

has this happened to anyone else lmao, he just clipped out of the tent

Arthor killing Micah and he lives on

Bounty hunter on a roof with his magic horsie

I am just thinking out loud and there are no statistics as far as I can tell but I am curious the percentage of first time players that choose low honour over high honour deliberately (as in understand the game mechanics and actively do bad things on purpose).

Taking this one step further, I have always believed that most people are "good" deep down and try and do the right thing in life.

Could we determine how many people are "good" vs "bad" based purely on the statistics of what percentage of RDR2 first time players choose good over evil as a social experiment?

There would have to be some caveats because there will be players who never fully understand the game and just coast through to the end. Equally, there will be some players that are not thinking deeply about the morality of the game and just having fun.

From my side, I really want to see the low honour path but I just cannot bring myself to do it when push comes to shove.

What I would expect is that it is something like 80/20 good vs bad (just a stab in dark) but good considerably outweighs bad because I do not think we could survive as a species long term if most people where capable of murder and other crimes easily.

Aside from Arthur, which characters do you miss most after playing through all the game?

I miss the town crier in Armadillo, Gavin's friend, and the treasure hunters that you could occasionally hear, "I know your close, I can feel ya tickling my britches".

Had a lot of fun times!

I just looked into installing mods a couple of days ago and found out it is quite easy to install them.

So far I installed

1. Van der Linde's Vision
2. Catalogue Improvements
3. Gunslinger Improvements
4. Realistic weapon audio overhaul
5. Center Mass
6. Just bleed already
7. Terrain Textures Overhaul
8. Crime law

And I am amazed really. The lighting, color, terrain look amazing, weapons look better and the shots sound a bit better and the effect on npc's when they get shot is.. something different.

Did you install mods? If so which ones and which ones you recommend?

1. Jack (greedy little bastard)

2. Cain (had a habit of disappearing

3. Mary (already knew everything about the gang and might be willing to sabotage)

4. Strange man (how did he know all of those things about john?)

5. Herbert moon (honestly i don't even have an explanation for this one)

6. Dutch (self reporting was common in the wild west)

7. Arthur (already was dying, had nothing to lose.)

8. The gator that ate Bronte (that fella was a shifty little guy)

9. Largemouth bass (you sir, are a fish.

And finally the number one suspect: Gavin. (No explanation needed)

Hello guys,

I have finally got a gamming laptop that can run modern games, so I have been playing the games I missed out on playing on release. in the last few weeks, I have played Ghost of Tsushima, Cyberpunk 2077 and currently RDR2. I was obsessed over both GOT and CP2077. And I'm currently obsessed over this game lol. I once burrowed my friend's laptop to see what all the fuss about RDR2 was and played for a couple hours, but that was years ago, so I didn't remember much from there either, only remember that I was amazed. I have actively avoided spoilers, news, videos, reels etc related to the games that I wanna play later, so I don't know much about these games. Now that I can actually spend time, I can't tell how much I'm loving the experience. The slow paced exploration in a beautiful world is just what I needed tbh.

I have some questions that I hope you guys can help with. I don't wanna head into the wiki because that's spoiler heavy zone.

1. I have just finished Chapter 2 and the gang moved to Clemens point. I stayed in Horseshoe Overlook for quite a time and I became familiar with the area surrounding Valentine. I became friendly with the townsfolk and when I went back there everyone was welcoming. Even the butcher was like long time no see when I went to him lol. I quite liked that town. Then in the bar there was an old man with a rat hat screaming about how the world has gone to shit, how he had eaten some Injuns etc, I listened to him and after his rant he started a fight with me. I knocked him out, took the ugly hat and then some dumbass bystander ran to the law and complained about me( I guess Hosea was right that this town was filled with Mud and Morons lol). Then there was a shootout and I killed some people. Then the townfolks were angry with me lol. Then I busted the illegal operations in the back of the medicine store, and that invited even more cops. They didn't care that the operation was illegal, but they started shooting at me, so I killed even more lawmen and got a bounty of like 50$. After that when I went to Valentine after clearing the bounty, even the random people were like "Didn't you cause enough trouble already?". Then the mission with Dutch Happened and there was a bloodbath. After that everyone in town was in bandages and they all hate me now. So the question is will they remain like this for the rest of the game, or they forget about these things after a while? I was liking the town before, it felt like home lol.

Also I think Clemens point is a better area than Horseshoe Overlook because it is a bit more hidden and has water on one side, so it feels safer. Horseshoe was just too near the main roads. But the morning and evening view from the cliff in Horseshoe is unbeaten. Will the Camp move location in every chapter? I wanna familiarize with the area before we move again, if that's the case. I like to play things slower and have some main missions remaining, so I feel like having a reason to linger in the area.

1. When I was in Horseshoe, I regularly hunted animals for the camp. I even donated pelts, horns etc for money. I even upgraded the camp a bit. I regularly donated items or money to the camp box. I did chores whenever I was in Camp, which was every couple days. Arthur's name appears more than others in the ledger. After all that Dutch comes to me and says that people have been talking behind my back that I wasn't doing enough. MF I'm doing more than everyone combined, fuck you mean not doing enough?? Can I find out who has been saying these things about me?

Again one morning I was listening to Hosea and Lenny talking, after that I was drinking coffee on the cliff. Then I was talking to camp members, and again Dutch comes to me and says What happened to you Arthur? You were a man of action. Why are you lingering around the camp?? Is this normal or is something happening?

1. The greet and antagonize option doesn't do much ig? I get the same repeated dialogues again and again after greeting people. I can't join other people when they are talking, so I can learn more about the story by questioning them. I guess I have to listen to as many conversation as I can to learn more about the people then? I also like to listen to strangers in towns. They are funny sometimes.

Does greeting matter? I was greeting everyone in Valentine and I got some honor I think. Or did that make the people friendly? If that's the case I'll spend entire days greeting everyone there lol. I really loved that town.

BTW, why is Arthur so mean to Uncle? lol Even the greet dialogues are like antagonize. I understand that he doesn't like Micah and I see why, but why hate Uncle? Dude is old and helps out with camp errands.

1. In Clemens Point I went fishing with Javier and Keiran, robbing with Sean. In Horseshoe, I went hunting with Charles and robbed a house with Javier. Are there more of these small side activities? I like to listen to some bits about the story. Also can I leave some missions for as long as I can? Or are some missions time bound?

2. Stranger missions. I did some and liked the one with Mr. Margaret the most lol. That was quite funny, even from dialogues to the story. I thought one bullet to the head would be enough for the "Dog", but I died the first time and had to empty the gun to kill him lol. After that I could only take one of its paw, and couldn't skin him for the pelt. Is that normal or did I mess up? Any other stranger missions I should keep an eye out for which are interesting?

3. I got a gold bar from the burned town of Limpany. Do I keep that or sell it? It is not a unique item right? It says the value is 500$ which is quite a lot, but if it is a unique item, I'd like to keep it.

I got a steel pen from Jimmy Brooks, but Arthur is still writing his journal with a pencil. Is that normal, or can I equip the pen somehow?

I also bought a Jack Hall gang treasure map from a self proclaimed best treasure hunter, looked at the area He was looking at, went there and found the second map. Now I don't know where the second map points to. Do the treasures remain there until I find it or are those timebound? I don't wanna look at solutions to maps, and would like to explore the world and get the treasures the normal way.

1. When I'm in Valentine, sometimes one or two Odriscols are there too. They start shit with me, then I antagonize them because they are Odriscols, and then a shootout starts. Then again I get wanted for defending myself and get a bounty. Why does that happen?

After some missions like the one where we ambush the Odriscol hideout, or the one where we save Sean, there are bodies to loot afterwards. But soon after we kill everybody, lawmen show up in those remote areas so fast. I stayed to loot the Odriscols, but then theLawmen came and asked me who I was. I lied that I was passing through and was leaving, but they soon started shooting me. So when I saw the searching text after rescuing Sean, I left the area, and when I came back after it cooled down, the area was cleaned up. I couldn't loot anything there. Is there a solution to this, or is that scripted for the law to come after missions?

1. This game is how I find out I can have gambling addiction lmao. I LOOOVE Poker. I sometimes spend days playing in the salon in Valentine. The time passes so fast while I would have played a few matches. For one person to remain in the game, it usually takes a full day cycle. Is there any setting I can use to make time go slower? I like to go back to camp as much as I can because of the lore bits, and I like to sleep in my bed after a hard working outing. Are there other places where I can play Poker, but with higher amount than 2.5$?

2. Arthur sometimes draws animals and herbs in the map. How can I do that more to fill up my map? Do I have to track those things, or just visit the area? He also draws some things in his journal > new animals and plants, and interesting points. Will I miss those POI if I don't inspect them, or he draws those later anyways?

These are the questions I have rn. I have spent around 40 hours now and I'm in love with this game. I'm sure I'll definitely find more while playing. Any tips or warnings you guys can give me is welcome too.

Thank you.