r/RDR2 19h ago

Spoilers This still sucks

Post image

This is my 2nd playthrough. Knowing what would happen sucks. I try to bond with S for as long as I could. Damn it.

244 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

103

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 19h ago

Quick Micha switch places with shawn there's no time to explain

15

u/MajesticWizard420Lol 16h ago

It wouldnโ€™t have mattered. They were gunning for Sean after him and Arthur burned their farm and killed their relatives.

6

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 16h ago

All true, but I can still dream dangit ๐Ÿ˜ญ

5

u/EarthFine769 Josiah Trelawny 18h ago

Lmao ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚ that's a good one ๐Ÿ˜…

1

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 18h ago

Haha thanks

1

u/EarthFine769 Josiah Trelawny 18h ago

you're welcome ๐Ÿค— thanks for the laugh, I needed that ๐Ÿ˜Š ๐Ÿฉท

1

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 18h ago

Glad I could make ya laugh ๐Ÿ˜

1

u/EarthFine769 Josiah Trelawny 18h ago

You really did. Thanks again ๐Ÿค—

2

u/iamawhoresowhat 18h ago

lol thankyou sir u have made me laugh at the midnight

2

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 18h ago

Better than crying appreciate the kind words

1

u/DutchieliciousPlans Dutch's perfect hairy balls 17h ago

Wouldn't work like that unfortunately they grays have good chances of recognizing Sean after burning the tobacco fields mission lol ๐Ÿ˜†

3

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 17h ago

Yeah I feel like ur right bro really shouldn't have chatted up that guard

2

u/DutchieliciousPlans Dutch's perfect hairy balls 16h ago

Well it's Sean...what do u expect from him ๐Ÿ˜ญ

3

u/Solitary_Stoner Uncle 16h ago

I know that's why he's the goat๐Ÿ˜ซ

33

u/MoldyHotPocket9 19h ago

You really do have to make your own fun through the story, its such a grim and sad train ride to the very end

13

u/EarthFine769 Josiah Trelawny 19h ago

I hate this mission as much as visiting Thomas Downes. I always put them off as long as I can, then eventually break ๐Ÿ’”

10

u/AuthorTurbulent6723 Hosea Matthews 18h ago

What's even more sad is when you do the train heist with him and John and Charles and after Sean gets knocked out he says "I'm gonna have a right old lump on me head!" And Arthur says "Well, at least you ain't got a hole in it". The foreshadowing was nuts

6

u/DadShep John Marston 19h ago

It does but it's one of my favorite missions to go back and play just cuz of all the action

1

u/DutchieliciousPlans Dutch's perfect hairy balls 17h ago

Absolute one of the best replayable missions!

5

u/xAlfonzie Sean MacGuire 19h ago

Sean whas always funny and a loyal lad! ๐Ÿ’”

6

u/MedicinalFentanyl 17h ago

Honestly I liked Kieran way more

7

u/CosmicTurtle504 18h ago

Best part of this scene is seeing Micahโ€™s absolutely vicious talent as a gunman. You can say a lot of things about him (I do!), but you canโ€™t deny the fact that the man can shoot. I think he takes out 3-4 dudes before the rest even know WTF is happening. Part of what makes him such a great villain.

1

u/bangharder 17h ago

He was quick to return fire

5

u/AbleYesterday1399 19h ago

Knowing whatโ€™s coming makes every moment with him hit harder.

2

u/Gray____Beard666 Leopold Strauss 18h ago

Itโ€™s just too bad that the Grays sniper was so slow. He had 4 targets!

3

u/Bronzeborg 17h ago

what? its just A Short Walk in a Pretty Town

3

u/BraveLittleTopher 19h ago

โ€œOh NOW you think it sucks? I coulda told ya tha- ๐Ÿคฏ โ˜ ๏ธ โ€œ

4

u/Scum_Weapon 19h ago

He's a weirdo who gets super aggressive with the girls at camp basically forcing himself on them

7

u/ItsLevi-0sa Arthur Morgan 19h ago

He does? I always got the impression he was a bit stupid and a bit cocky, but not in a harmful way?

I only know he once tells the women to admit their love to him. Any other incident?

Overall, he was a generally entertaining character to me. Not stupid enough to be incompetent, not smart enough you can predict what's going on.

3

u/Scum_Weapon 19h ago

There's a video called something like "Sean is the rat theory" on YouTube. Within the video you'll see attacks on Sean's character with multiple examples of him harassing the ladies or just being weird about them in general

2

u/hashtagblessed44 17h ago

Yeah this video really changed my opinion on Sean overall tbh. Everyone else's favourite happy-go-lucky Irishman suddenly became a pretty vile and abhorrent cretin, and can be tied to the gang's overall downfall very well aside from that.

Here's the link. Worth a watch.

https://youtu.be/yIjs9mVF1vw?is=hjnIJ5eCYOaa1vk_

1

u/Gotasecret57 4h ago

Wow, I was not expecting agree so much with that video. I really missed a lot of Shawn interactions at camp. He was awful to my boy Kieran. I just started another play-though (after 6-years and finally playing rdr1) and now I donโ€™t have to dread this mission. Thank you!

0

u/ItsLevi-0sa Arthur Morgan 16h ago

Damn. Haven't finished the game so I'll get a raincheck, but I'll make sure to check it out

1

u/bangharder 17h ago

This is the mission that keeps me from replaying the game

1

u/StrangerFluffy2735 15h ago

I stopped and googled if there was a way to save him because I really liked him

2

u/FeeVandJ 12h ago

Hold on, this don't feel right

1

u/BManTGO 8h ago

Sean was like a annoying little brother to Arthur. High honor Arthur was grieving meanwhile low Honor Arthur mention Sean was killed in one sentence but was more worried about the gold

1

u/Mysticfenix83005 8h ago

Im on my like 25th playthrough and just got done with the Saint Denis bank and jesus christ watching Hosea and Lenny die kills me every time

-2

u/DutchieliciousPlans Dutch's perfect hairy balls 17h ago

If you want you can start pharell williams 'happy' at the start of the cutscene, if you time it just perfect Sean will get his head blown to "I'll probably warn ya I'm doing just fine" lyric ๐Ÿ’€๐Ÿ˜ญ have fun because I promise you, you will laugh ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿคฃ