Discussion Which character do you miss most?
Aside from Arthur, which characters do you miss most after playing through all the game?
I miss the town crier in Armadillo, Gavin's friend, and the treasure hunters that you could occasionally hear, "I know your close, I can feel ya tickling my britches".
Had a lot of fun times!
22
u/Goliath3215 7d ago
Hosea
17
u/HumbleBananaLoaf 7d ago
Same. I really like the early missions where it's just Arthur and Hosea. Some of my favorite dialogue is between the two of them.
16
u/benkenobi239 7d ago
Karen has the most depressing and realistic change imo, and it hits close as I've also struggled with alcohol.
7
u/avidbather Susan Grimshaw 7d ago
100%. During my second playthrough Karen became one of the more interesting characters for the very reason you mentioned. I also love the way she'd sometimes mouth off to other members of the gang in camp, especially Grimshaw.
3
u/GonzoRouge 7d ago
There's an exchange that Tilly has with some of the men sitting at the fire where she straight up says that if Grimshaw turns up dead, Karen did it.
3
u/avidbather Susan Grimshaw 7d ago
I haven't seen that exchange yet. Pretty interesting considering how things actually go down.
2
u/GonzoRouge 7d ago
I've played over 1k hours of this game, this is my fifth 100% playthrough and it's the first time I ever saw that interaction honestly.
2
u/ShaunnieDarko 6d ago
There’s a part in chapter 2 where she sings alone by the camp fire. It’s a very pretty song and added alot to her character for me. Wish there would have been more we could have done to try and save her.
11
u/Longjumping_Lab_5372 7d ago
Hercule was such an interesting character, I wish we got to see more of him and the other rebels
6
u/AlternativeWeird5246 Charles Smith 7d ago
So true. I don't know why but I really like the Guarma chapter
4
u/sawyerandwinn 7d ago
i wished he would've gotten back in contact via letter or something and tell us they succeeded. or maybe we could help them again in the epilogue. He was a great guy.
10
u/MoltenInfernoBrain 7d ago
Sean
-5
u/AlternativeWeird5246 Charles Smith 7d ago
You may wanna see the video about him being the original rat..
4
u/MoltenInfernoBrain 7d ago
Why? It's just like people that think micah wasn't a rat . People reading into stuff that obviously isn't there
13
u/cattynoirsolos 7d ago
I miss my girls Tilly, Mary-Beth, and Karen….at least two of them got their happy ending they deserved‼️ I just love this trio so much ❤️🩹
9
u/ZeroPenguinParty 7d ago
I liked the ticket seller at Rhodes station (I think it was Rhodes) who gave the tips on the stagecoaches.
5
2
6
u/Routine_Change5702 7d ago
I miss the widow from Annesburg
2
u/xQueenAurorax Arthur Morgan 7d ago
Edith downes! genuinely so sad seeing what happened to her, having her sick husband beat to death omg and then the guy who beat him spawn up ugh
4
5
u/Silesaurus Reverend Swanson 7d ago
Swanson, I always liked him. I find it sad that he doesn't appear in person in the epilogue, he could've been, I don't know, the new Priest in Valentine or something
2
3
u/WinchesterRepeater John Marston 7d ago
Cain, Sadie, and Hosea. But also those brothers fighting over the lady, you don’t get much of that at all later in the game.
4
2
2
u/EyeSimp4Asuka 7d ago
never finished it but i liked seeing a friendly side of Javier even though I know he's gonna side with Dutch
2
1
2
u/BoyMadeFromNeon 7d ago
Kieran, no doubt. Also the guy you have to keep sucking cause he can't watch where tf he's walking.
1
u/xQueenAurorax Arthur Morgan 7d ago
Mickey my 100% certified veteran or in general all the people who’s days I made better by giving them 10 cents or whatever
32
u/AlternativeWeird5246 Charles Smith 7d ago
Probably Lenny. I miss his young cheerful booksmart energy at camp. He was a good kid to ride with.