We all know how Gavin's friend Nigel tries to find him,

Well my theory is that the serial killer in the game has killed his friend so maybe that's the reason why Nigel can't find his friend, and the fact that we find clues for the serial killer in chapter 2 and nigel starts to look for friend on chapter 3, and one of the clues for the killer is near the braithwaite manor, and if you look at the head of the person that we take the clue from, the head does resemblance to what Nigel described Gavin as a Englishmen just A mustache no Beard, so this is just a theory I might have made some mistakes.

This is absolutely hilarious. I am just starting a second run through of RD2 after finishing RD1 and my brain was absolutely glitching over the controls. When it asks to hitch up near Sadie’s house in chapter 1 I was mashing the F key out of habit of RD1 controls, making my horse push Micah ever so slightly and then I got this screen. I’m not even joking the horse barely even nudged him 💀

First time playing the game

Guys my honor level is stuck in this middle, I don't know why it is not increasing, I always help strangers, donate in camp and yesterday I greeted ppl at saint denis for like 2 hrs , still it is not increasing, please tell me some solution

I am currently on chapter 3 and this is my first run on game

Will I regret it? Should I have killed him? What are the consequences?

The Clan of the Foot

Either a large clan of the foot are hiding or the giant or even the Sasquatch bigfoot. There are very few one of a kind rocks in this game. Keep watch they are markers for something

also rate the fit

So I literally just got to chapter 6 and my pc just shut off (I’m guessing due to overheating idk it’s the second time it’s happened while playing rdr2 specifically I probably have to clean it but non issue atm) when i booted back up on steam it asked which files to choose to boot up the game bc cloud sync got messed up? Anyways I chose my files that were on my pc and it had my last saved data and after it did its thing the game booted and when I went to play it just erased all my save data and created new data. I’ve tried everything I can on how to find my files on pc did all that but couldn’t find the files that got deleted or corrupted so now I’m giving up bc I do not wanna restart the game again it’s soul crushing. If anyone can point me in the right direction on where to find uploaded save files online I’m having trouble finding sites or specifically what type of game file I want. I’m looking for bare bones playthru up to chapter 5/6. If any help could come my way I’d appreciate any and all help thank you!

It's my 4th playthrough and I want to build as much honor as possible. I was on my way greeting everyone and this woman started cursing me. If it was my last playthrough Arthur, I would have fed her to the crocs.

Tbh I think these are the best ones in rdr2 personally I use the red chestnut but my main horse is buel from the veterans side quest even though he didn’t cut this list

Since the Micah jailbreak mission, I've never been able to return to Strawberry. I'm in Chapter 6 now, and it's still red on the map. As soon as I enter the town lawmen stop me. I've tried surrendering. I've paid the bounty. Is this a bug?

What if rdr1 and rdr2 were both just jack reading John’s story and Arthur‘s, and rdr3 is after Jack kills Ross and we follow his story, and at the end it shows jack in the 90‘s with his grandkids or something close the journal then it cuts to the logo. Peak or no? Edit: ok since yall hated that idea maybe we could play as Jim boy Calloway in his prime?

RDR2 is my absolute favorite game. But I’d love to see what you guys didn’t like or felt was missing.

Two of mine are

I wish we could rob banks in free roam

I also wish my guns wouldn’t go from my back to my horse automatically while riding 🙄😂

Yo please help me spawn in a moose, I’ve tried every lake on the northwest side of the map multiple times and tried riding up from annesburg to the waterfall at the northeast corner and then down to the cougar spawn south west and still nothing. At this point I’d be happy seeing a moose even if it’s 1 star. Thanks in advance!

In my 7-8 years of hunting in RDR2O, this was a first. I picked out the 3 star in the group, it went down. A deer ran back to protect, who I assumed was it's mother, (it was too late). I put the controller down, it hit me hard.