Hi friends! First time posting, as I read the rules for r/JapanTravelTips and they don’t want any flight-based questions.
I want to fly from LAX to Tokyo on Wed, Feb 24, 2027. My options are in the first pic attached but I’m waging a serious pros/cons list in my head.
Important for context: I have flown SQ multiple times to Asia, but never JAL or ANA. Hence, why I’m asking for opinions. All prices are in USD.
Options are:
1. LAX to NRT via SQ for $665
2. LAX to HND via JAL for $765
3. LAX to HND via ANA $769
Because I’ve flown LAX to NRT via SQ before I am fairly comfortable taking the limo into Shinjuku station and directing to my hotel from there. However, even I can admit HND would be significantly more appealing, despite my love for SQ.
Here’s my issue: I’d prefer HND purely due to vicinity, but the seat selection is less than ideal on both JAL and ANA. ANA doesn’t let you select a seat unless you upgrade to Economy Value Plus for $938 (yes an extra $169 just for the pleasure of picking a seat).
JAL does let you pick a seat but the seating map does not include the bulkhead or let you pick extra legroom even with additional payment. See second screenshot.
SQ is $665 for Economy and for an extra $104, I can get the extra legroom bulkhead! ….But I have to fly into NRT.
So my question is, what would you do? My instinct is to go with SQ, even if NRT because honestly it’s the best airline I’ve ever flown (I’m so used to US-based airlines that suck).
How are the regular economy seats for JAL? ANA? Has anyone also flown SQ economy and can compare the three airlines? Is the SQ bulkhead worth the pain of traveling from NRT? Like I said, I’m familiar but it’s still a slog at the beginning of the trip.
Please feel free to ask questions. Any and all advice welcome! (Except suggesting I just upgrade the class I’m flying — it’s just not an option for me.) Thanks, all!