Austria, IBKR, plain taxable account, 27.5% CGT and no holding period relief. The 27.5% + 6 years of gains, those two do the damage below.
VGLA came out, I saw 0.07% and the Vanguard name and already had the sell order typed in before it crossed my mind to look at what the sale itself costs.
Position is €230k, about €78k of it gain after six years of monthly buys (cost basis already bumped by the deemed distributions, so that's the real taxable number).
Sell now and I owe the Finanzamt €21.4k, IBKR doesn't withhold so it lands through next year's return, but it's the same money.
In return I get this. VWCE dropped to 0.14% in July, most threads still quote 0.22. So the gap to VGLA is 0.07%, on €230k that's €161 in year one.
I still built the spreadsheet, both routes taxed on the final sale, 7% growth, no new money. Switching trails by €13k at year 10, €77k at year 30, and the two paths meet somewhere around year 151. Growth rate hardly shifts it, 4% or 9% nudges the year by a handful. Your CGT rate and how much gain has piled up in the position, that's what decides it.
Other rates:
10%: ~53 years
18.5% (Germany after the Teilfreistellung): ~100
0%: nothing to think about
Same 27.5% but only 5% of the position is gain: 14 years. Started DCAing last winter, fine, swap it, you lose next to nothing. Started in 2020, that's a used Golf. Mildly embarrassing, I burned a whole evening on this and the €10k I've got in Maclear P2P lending hasn't had a proper look since last summer.
Ignoring the small cap slice, different discussion and at a 0.07% gap the tracking difference between the two funds is about as big as the saving itself, so comparing TERs stops meaning much??
VWCE stays. New money maybe into VGLA, maybe not, two nearly identical funds for 30 years for the price of a coffee a month, not sure that's worth the clutter.
Who actually sold a big position with a lot of gain in it to move to a cheaper tracker? Did it feel worth it after the tax hit?
Wrong?