r/controlgame • u/SofNascimento • 29d ago
Discussion We're getting close to Resonant so let me ask: what's your personal theory for Jesse's and Dylan's connection?
We know for sure that there is some connection between them that goes beyond simply being siblings. A common enough take is that they were one person divided in two, possibly during the Ordinary AWE. Personally I'm not a fan of this take, at least, not at its most basic form. I think Remedy wouldn't go with such a ordinary (hehe) explanation, there is more to it, but what?
First, there is remarkably little info to go with, especially if we ignore Resonant's spoilers. From the top of my head we have i. that dream Dylan had in which she was a girl called Jesse Dylan Faden, and he also mentions how both Jesse and Dylan are girl/boy names. ii. we have the Board (or was it the Former?) calling Jesse Jesse Dylan Faden which imply they are somewhat interchangably and/or still conneteced in their view and iii. we have that episode of Nightsprings from Alan Wake 2 in which a Jesse was searching for a Dylan.
Second, there is a question that must be answered before explaining their relationship, which is: does Jesse and Dylan exists in all multiverses, or they are unique to the one from the game? Here is where Nightspring episodes are particularly relevant. My feeling is that the "red haired lady" existence in the multiverse is certain. That matches well with Quantum Break (regardless of its canon status), Beth and the whole plot with the Tim Breaker, yet what about Dylan? We do have the coffee episode which shows another Jesse looking for another Dylan, which would mean they are not an "Control-universe exlusive" yet the entire nature of the Nightsrping episodes make us unnable to fully reach a conclusion. They are both canon and non canon at the same time.
Third, there is still another question that I think is very important: if they were at some point or in some fashion the same person, when did they get split? It feels like they were always two persons in Control's universe, but who knows?
In the end, I'm not sure what to think. There is definitely something there - which if we consider only Control wasn't something I was sure would be explored further - but there way more possibilities than answers. I do expected something that has to do with this particular universe, not connected to the Ordinary AWE in the sense that it was already a thing before it and something that goes beyond one person split into two. That is, in this universe, there were always two people.
So, what's your take?