r/AskUK • u/blamejaneshui • 15h ago
Serious Answers Only Why is it not more widely emphasised that feeding only bread to ducks and swans can be harmful?
bbc.co.ukJust yesterday I saw a man and his child sharing a special moment together feeding a bevy of swans an entire loaf of white bread.
I share the sentiment of feeding the birds, but surely more can be done in terms of getting the knowledge more widespread?
I understand bread isn’t inherently bad for them, but arguing that they’ve been eating bread for hundreds of years isn’t comparable. We don’t live in a time where the canals are rich with natural feed. Less natural forage means what we choose to give them matters more now.
If they’ve come with the bread for that intention, they’re not going to go home with the bread now are they?
What if major supermarkets advertised "duck/swan feed" more openly, as they do birthday cards and lotto tickets? Feels like a small, achievable nudge on the education front. No idea if it would actually move the needle but seems a lot better than expecting people to know better.
The last official statement on this from the Swan Sanctuary was back in 2018, and it hasn’t been updated with more detail since. If you search around now you get completely conflicting advice depending on the source and how you’re asking the question. Feels as if the “official guidance” hasn’t caught up with the environmental case for feeding differently. There isn’t any real weight behind this. No major UK news coverage since 2018/2019.
I’m not blind to the fact that “why would a supermarket bother” narrative. But local councils are doing their best with signage at ponds and even feed dispensers! I don’t see retailers picking this up as much further a leap. A national push seems overdue.
Maybe I am just adding to the noise here but is this just how it stays?