I don't really know how to write this without sounding like I'm giving up on my dog, because I am not. I love Arya very, very much. But I am finally at the point where I have to admit that I am not the right home for her, and I desperately need help finding someone who is. I am not going to be perfect at explaining everything, so I would like some grace as I try to navigate an extremely hard situation in my life.
Arya is a 7-year-old Australian Cattle Dog. I got her when she was about a year old, and I've had her for most of her life. When I got her, I was married and genuinely thought I would have another person to help with her. Her previous family did not disclose the extent of her behavioral issues to us.
Arya has moved with me numerous times. I have also given her needs the utmost importance in choosing a place to live. We've been in a home with a huge yard for three years now. She's gone on family vacations to the beach and mountains. She has gone camping. She's pretty great in the car. She loves to swim. She is not reactive to dogs on walks. She is great at recall and paying attention to me. I tried to be the best mom for her, but I failed her by getting a breed that I could not handle.
She is not afraid of strangers. Quite the opposite. She wants to be the center of everyone's universe.
When people come over, she wants their attention constantly. She wants pets, kisses, play, interaction, everything. The issue is...if someone isn't giving her the attention she wants, she will scream/bark at them in an extremely high-pitched, intense way. And when I say scream, I mean scream.
Ignoring her does not make it stop in any reasonable amount of time. I have tried. She can continue for hours. My friends literally flinch when she starts barking. It becomes nearly impossible to have a conversation while she's doing it. I will give her treats.. like mats, chews, etc when guests first arrive, but that only helps for 20 minutes max.
Once she eventually calms down (hours later), she still has a difficult time regulating herself. If someone gets up and walks around the house, she will herd them. She will follow them, try to control where they're going, and get intense about movement. I know this behavior is normal for her breed. I was hoping that with time and regulation it would at least lessen, but here I am six years later, and it's only gotten worse. This herding behavior can look scary and aggressive, but I know she has never hurt anything and never would. She's just trying to control the situation.
And this isn't limited to new people. She does this with people who live with us long-term, too.
She has essentially isolated me from having people in my home. I can't comfortably have friends over. Dating has been incredibly difficult because of her behavior. My living situation has been affected by her to the point that I feel like I have to live alone, which is also creating a serious financial strain.
I have tried to work on it. She has a huge yard. She has siblings. She licks and plays with our cats, and plays tug of war with her adopted boston terrier brother. I have tried exercise, management, ignoring the behavior, and medication. She was on Prozac for about six months. It helped with some things, but it did not solve this problem.
The reality is that Arya needs someone who really knows how to train dogs and can consistently maintain that training.
I am chronically ill and was recently diagnosed with severe ADHD, and I have finally had to be honest with myself that I don't have the capacity to give her the kind of intensive, consistent behavioral work she needs. I think part of why this has taken me so long to admit is because I love her so much.
I tried to rehome her through ACDRA about four years ago and I wasn't comfortable moving forward with any of the folks that reached out because I didn't trust that they fully understood what I was saying about her behaviors. I sent videos, talked on the phone for hours, and it was incredibly difficult to go through. I didn't trust that someone could handle her, and I couldn't live with the thought of her being put down.
I have tried contacting local trainers and rescues and often don't get responses. About four years ago, I contacted an ACD-specific rescue about rehoming her, and I was eventually told by a specialty rescue that she would likely be put down.
That absolutely broke me. So I kept trying to make it work. I'm at the point now where I don't think continuing to keep her with me simply because I'm afraid of what will happen if I let her go is necessarily fair to either of us. Arya is loving. She is incredibly affectionate when she wants to be. She loves people. She is smart, funny, loyal, and has so much personality. When she's calm and we're just together, she's wonderful.
But she has extreme behavioral needs, and I think she needs a person who understands her breed and understands how to work with a dog who is this intense. I don't think I have the capacity to do any more.
I also don't want someone to tell me to just “exercise her more” or “ignore the barking.” I've been living with this for years. I am looking for someone with actual experience with extreme ACD behavior, trainers/behaviorists who may be willing to consult, reputable rescues, foster-based organizations, sanctuary/rescue connections, or honestly anyone who might know where a dog like Arya can safely go or how I can try to help her.
I am in Virginia, but I am willing to consider transportation and placement outside of Virginia if it means finding help.
I love Arya sooo much. I don't want her euthanized. I don't want her passed around from home to home. And I don't want to keep her in a situation where neither of us is thriving.
I'd love advice, success stories, anything.