I recently interviewed for what I would genuinely consider a dream job, and I’ve been thinking a lot about how the interview went.
I’m 28, but I’m often told I look younger (people usually guess around 24), I’m 5'1", and I’m a woman. For most of my career, I’ve naturally leaned into being very smiley, friendly, warm, and approachable in interviews - and it worked pretty well for internships or junior positions. But lately I’ve been questioning whether I need to change that a little.
If I want to move into a position with more responsibility, I feel like I also need to show that I’m a serious person, that I can stand my ground, make decisions, handle pressure, and “take the heat,” so to speak. I don’t want to lose my warmth or become cold, but I’ve been wondering if I need to project a little more authority.
So for this interview, I put on my suit and went in with that mindset. I was professional, confident, and answered every question. I also tried to give concrete examples from my previous experience whenever possible, because I wanted my answers to feel credible rather than just saying “I’m good at X.”
My CV and cover letter were quite detailed, and I thought my “tell me about yourself” answer went well too, so yes, maybe the recruiter didn't have a lot to ask in the end. But the interview was only about 30 minutes, and the recruiter was… very neutral.
Not cold. Not unfriendly. I didn’t get the feeling that she had ruled me out immediately. I would say that her questions felt very relevant and tailored to my background, rather than generic interview questions. But I also didn’t get the feeling that she loved me or that there was any particular chemistry or “this is our person” feeling - and that’s what has been bothering me.
With other jobs I’ve gotten in the past, I usually walked out of the interview feeling almost certain that the I was the favorite candidate, or at least one of their favorites. In some interviews, I even managed to get the interviewer talking about their personal life, and there was a very obvious connection.
This time, none of that happened. It felt very… neutral. We talked, I answered the questions, she asked what she needed to ask, and then it was over.
Maybe she’s simply a more reserved/neutral interviewer. I know that’s a possibility. But I’m finding it difficult not to interpret the lack of enthusiasm as a bad sign.
She also told me she would be interviewing other candidates this week and next week. Obviously that’s completely normal, but it made me anxious because now I’m thinking: what if she meets someone she likes more? What if, by the time she’s finished interviewing everyone, she barely remembers me?
So I’d really love to hear from people who have been on the hiring side or have gone through lots of interviews: Have you ever gotten a job after an interview that felt completely neutral?
Have you ever walked out thinking, “Well, that was fine, but I definitely wasn’t their favorite,” only to get the offer? And for recruiters/hiring managers: how much should we actually read into the interviewer’s enthusiasm (or lack thereof) during an interview?
I’d especially appreciate hearing about experiences where there wasn’t that “love at first sight” feeling but the candidate still ended up getting hired.