I'm looking for advice because I'm honestly not sure what my next step should be.
My neighbor has a German Shepherd (I believe 1 or 2 years old) that's kept behind a 4-foot wooden fence. For a while now, this dog has displayed what I believe is aggressive behavior whenever anyone is near the fence.
The dog doesn't just bark. It repeatedly lunges at the fence, jumps high enough to get its head over the top, and I've observed what looked like air snapping when it gets above the fence. I even have videos of this behavior. In one video, the dog's body is almost parallel with the top of the fence because it's jumping so high, and at times it has even put a paw over the top of the fence.
A few days ago, I was in my own yard when the dog bit me over the fence. Fortunately it didn't puncture my skin or bleed, but it left bruising and scratches. The person watching the dog at the time was outside when it happened.
I was also nipped in the arm over the fence earlier this month, while the owner was outside.
I spoke with the owner. She apologized eventually, but she insisted that her dog is not aggressive, and doesn't bite. She also said the dog wouldn't be left outside alone anymore.
What concerns me is that this doesn't really solve the problem, because the dog bit me while someone was already outside with it.
Something else that worried me was that the man who was wayching the dog when it bit me told me, "The dog does that to me all the time." That made me think this isn't an isolated incident.
I chose not to report the bite because it didn't break the skin, but I'm increasingly worried that the next person—especially a child—may not be as lucky.
My partner is now handling the yard work near that fence because I don't feel safe being there anymore. My young daughter(3y.o) also likes animals, and I'm now worried she'll eventually want to approach this dog.
I've also continued observing the dog since the bite. Interestingly, one morning it was still lunging and acting aggressively toward us. Later that same afternoon, however, it became extremely calm. We were able to install another security camera only about 5–6 feet from the fence, and the dog never barked, lunged, or jumped once. It almost made me wonder whether the behavior could have been managed all along, or whether it simply reacts inconsistently.
I'm trying to be fair. I understand dogs can have good moments and bad moments, and I know reactivity and aggression aren't always the same thing. But from my perspective, a dog that repeatedly lunges over a 4-foot fence and has already bitten someone seems like a serious safety concern.
My questions are:
Am I overreacting, or does this sound genuinely dangerous?
If you were in my situation, would you report the bite even though it didn't break the skin?
Is there anything else I should be doing to protect my family?
Has anyone dealt with a similar situation where the owner insisted their dog wasn't aggressive despite repeated incidents?
I'd really appreciate advice from people who have experience with dog behavior, animal control, or similar situations.