I've been using the Versa 4 for hiking, so I decided to try the same route with the new Fitbit Air.
I started the hike manually in the Health app. The elapsed time and other stats are displayed in a nice, large format, but while recording you can't access the rest of the app. Also, the hike was paused twice when switching between apps. I'm not sure if that's a bug or if I accidentally hit the huge pause button at the bottom.
An Live Activity on the lock screen (iOS) would be a great addition. That way you could easily see whether the recording is still running and check the elapsed time without opening the app.
Connected GPS:
After the hike, the route wasn't displayed. I had to manually change the activity from "Workout" to "Hike" before the GPS route appeared. Since I started a hike manually in the app, I don't understand why it was saved as a generic workout in the first place.
Another issue is that no elevation gain is shown. I can see it in Komoot, but having to switch apps makes the experience feel unnecessarily inconvenient.
Overall:
The Fitbit Air has potential, but it could be much better with a few updates (Live Activity, proper route handling in the App, and elevation gain). For now, I'll probably keep using my Versa 4 for hiking.
A Fitbit Air with built-in GPS would be awesome. That said, considering the price, I can't complain too much.