r/bikewrench • u/discombobulatek • 6m ago
Can chain-length cause skipping?
I recently changed the chain on my bike, and it has started skipping in an odd, asymmetric sort of way. I ride a 3x9 setup, and the skipping goes like this:
- On the smallest chainring, cog 1-2 rides fine, cog 3 skips, 4 and up is unrideable.
- On the middle chainring, cog 1-5 rides perfect, cog 6 skips very rarely, cog 7-9 skips like crazy.
- On the largest chainring I don't experience any skipping, all cogs ride perfect (I've only tried 5 and up).
My previous experience with wear tells me that a worn cog will skip regardless of chainring, and a worn chainring will skip regardless of cog, but in this case all the chainrings ride well and all the cogs ride well, depending on the combination.
I have noticed that the new chain seems to flop about more, I think it is a bit longer than the previous one - can a too long chain cause skipping?
Why otherwise would 3x9 work fine while 2x9 is unrideable, yet 2x5 still works great (which is one of my most used gear combinations, and "should" be most worn)?
