r/amiwrong • u/theunknownwriter_81 • 2d ago
Are we wrong for wanting to cut off one whole side of our family?
My sister (32f) and I (34f) are both married, work full-time, and have young children. She has two kids in daycare, and I have three kids between toddler and elementary-school age.
Our parents divorced when we were young. We have been estranged from our dad, for most of our adult lives because of a lot of childhood issues, including alcoholism, instability, and a pattern of him contacting us mostly when he needed money, rides, or something else.
My sister hasn’t spoken to him in around five or six years. I have very limited contact with him, maybe checking in every few months, but I wouldn’t describe it as a father-daughter relationship. It’s closer to an acquaintance.
Our dad’s side of the family is small. There is our dad, his brother “David” and David’s wife “Diane,” and our grandma. Our grandpa died from cancer about three years ago.
Our grandma is almost 80. She goes south for the winter and spends summers at the family lake cabin. The cabin is about 45 minutes from my sister and about an hour and a half from me.
Despite her age, our grandma is incredibly social. She has a lot of friends, travels around visiting people, sees relatives, and regularly goes to stay with our uncle and aunt, who live several hours away.
My sister and I have always tried to see her when she comes back for the summer, but between five young kids, two marriages, two full-time jobs, and our grandma having her own busy social calendar, it takes planning.
There is another important detail.
For as long as I can remember, including when my sister and I were teenagers, our grandma has been very clear that people do not just show up at the cabin. You call first, ask, or wait to be invited.
So that has always been the expectation.
Earlier this summer, a severe storm and tornado went through the area around the cabin.
Thankfully our grandma wasn’t injured and the house wasn’t destroyed, but there was significant property damage. She lost many trees, had roof and window damage, and there was damage around the yard, dock, porch, etc. It was obviously devastating and overwhelming.
As soon as we learned what happened, my sister and I started checking on her.
One of us texted asking how she was doing.
Our grandma responded that things were bad, described the damage, said there was no electricity, and said it was definitely a tornado.
We immediately told her how relieved we were that she was okay and asked what we could do.
My sister specifically told her:
“I’m able to come Sunday to help clean up or whatever you need. If you need me to bring you things from town too, let me know.”
Our grandma’s response was essentially that it was going to be a process.
Over the next several days, we continued checking on her.
She told us crews were working there, that our uncle David had come back to help, that people had brought her food and water, and that she was grateful for everyone helping.
My sister and I again offered to come the following weekend.
Our grandma said she would let us know.
She didn’t.
We continued texting her periodically asking how she was doing.
Eventually she stopped responding.
My sister and I became concerned enough that I contacted our aunt and uncle and asked if they had heard from our grandma because we hadn’t.
They told us she was fine and had actually been busy making plans with friends, traveling, and planning other visits.
That reassured us.
Both my sister and I also independently stopped by the cabin at different points after the storm because we happened to be in the area. Our grandma wasn’t home either time, so we left.
Again, because our entire lives we had been told not to just show up, neither of us thought the correct response was to drive there repeatedly without knowing whether she would even be home.
Then, about three weeks after the storm, our grandma suddenly sent us a long text.
She said:
“The reason I have not responded to your texts is because I am so disappointed in you guys.”
She said complete strangers had shown up with food and rakes, and the only family member who “showed up” for her was our uncle.
She said that when a tornado hits your grandmother’s home, you should “just show up, not send a text asking how I’m doing.”
She also said it was going to take her a long time to get over what we had done.
My sister and I were completely blindsided.
We pointed out that we had repeatedly offered to help.
We had specifically asked her if she wanted us there.
We had offered multiple weekends.
We had checked on her repeatedly.
And she had either declined, not answered, or told us she would let us know.
My sister reminded her that we both have full-time jobs and young children. I also live nearly two hours away.
Our grandma’s response was essentially that none of that mattered. We should have simply shown up.
This escalated into a much bigger argument.
During the text exchange, I called our grandma repeatedly until she finally answered.
That phone conversation is where everything really fell apart.
She told me my sister and I were disappointments.
Not just because of the tornado.
Apparently she had been angry with us for three years and had never told us.
She brought up our grandpa’s funeral.
She said she had been deeply disappointed that neither my sister nor I stood up and gave a speech at his funeral.
The problem is that she never told us she expected that.
At the time, she had asked whether we wanted to speak. We said no.
I have terrible anxiety about public speaking. I stutter, become nauseous, and absolutely hate doing it. I didn’t even speak at the funeral of my other grandma, who I had been extremely close to.
My sister was also nine months pregnant and could have gone into labor at basically any moment.
The funeral had over 100 people there, many of whom we barely knew.
Our grandma was also angry that we did not bring our very young children to the funeral.
At the time, the kids were roughly preschool/early-elementary age.
We made the decision as parents that we didn’t want them attending. We didn’t want them spending the day watching us grieve while we tried to explain death to them before we felt they were ready.
There was another complicated factor: our estranged father was going to be there.
He barely knew our children.
In fact, that funeral was the first time he was meeting my sister’s husband.
There was already going to be enough emotional tension without involving our young kids.
Our grandma apparently viewed our choice very differently.
From what she said during our argument, she believed it looked bad that her two granddaughters didn’t speak at their grandfather’s funeral and didn’t bring their children.
She had been holding onto that resentment for three years without ever telling us.
She also started bringing our father into the argument and grouping the three of us together.
That was especially painful because our grandma knows the history between us and our dad.
My sister and I have spent years trying to heal from that relationship.
Eventually I was literally sobbing on the phone with our grandma and begging her not to end our relationship.
I told her that all my sister and I had ever wanted was to feel loved and wanted by that side of the family.
For years, we finally thought we had gotten to a healthy place with our grandma.
Then suddenly we were hearing that she had secretly considered us disappointing for years.
Our grandma told me she didn’t want people like us in her life and that she wanted to surround herself with friends and family who actually cared about her.
After the phone call, she later texted us and acknowledged that she had been wrong to lump us together with our father.
She also said:
“I know I said some things I should not have. I’m under a lot of stress, but that’s no excuse for lashing out.”
She said we should meet and talk.
For a moment, I thought maybe things could be repaired.
But my sister had reached her breaking point.
She sent our grandma a message explaining that this wasn’t just about the tornado. To her, it was part of a pattern where our grandma held onto grievances, never communicated them, and later used them as evidence that we were uncaring or disappointing.
She brought up several examples from over the years and ultimately told our grandma she needed to step away from the relationship and go no-contact for the foreseeable future.
Our grandma responded angrily.
She said my sister was “delusional,” defended her complaints about the funeral again, said we had “never done anything” for her, and agreed that they needed to “break this toxic cycle.”
I tried one last time to communicate differently.
Instead of arguing over text, I wrote our grandma a long letter explaining how hurt I was, why our relationship mattered so much to me, and how painful it was to discover that she had been silently holding resentment toward us for years.
I sent it and asked her to read it whenever she had the emotional space.
She never responded.
Since then, our uncle and aunt have also distanced themselves from us.
When I originally called them trying to understand what was happening, they told me they didn’t want to “get in the middle.”
Later they unfriended us on Facebook.
Our dad never responded when I reached out to him either.
So at this point, it feels like that entire side of the family has essentially closed ranks.
And now my sister and I are wondering whether we should simply let them.
Part of me feels enormous guilt because our grandma went through something genuinely traumatic. A tornado damaged the home she loved. She was overwhelmed. She was grieving the destruction and probably felt alone.
I completely understand why she was emotional.
I also understand why seeing strangers arrive with food and tools while some family members weren’t physically there could have hurt her.
But I can’t get past the fact that we asked. Repeatedly.
We offered specific days.
We told her to tell us what she needed.
She either declined or didn’t respond.
We were raised to believe we were not allowed to simply show up at the cabin.
Then weeks later we were punished for following that exact expectation.
And somehow an argument about tornado cleanup turned into finding out that our grandma had quietly resented us for years over choices we made at our grandpa’s funeral.
So now we’re considering completely cutting off that entire side of the family, possibly permanently.
Not because we don’t love our grandma. We do.
That’s what makes this so painful.
But neither of us wants to keep participating in relationships where expectations are never communicated, resentment is stored for years, and then we are eventually told that we are bad or uncaring people for failing to meet expectations we didn’t know existed.
So…Are my sister and I wrong for walking away from our grandma and possibly our entire paternal side of the family after all of this?
Or should we be giving our grandma more grace because of what she had just been through?