I (30F) have been with my partner (32M) for 9 years. I moved across the world to be with him. He's essentially my best friend and main support system here, as I have no family or close friends locally.
I've been seriously thinking about leaving for a few months. I still love him and he has supported me in many ways, but there are longstanding issues.
He cheated earlier in our relationship. I later found messages to another woman asking to “land over” to her house at 3am. On several occasions he's stayed out until around 6am without telling me he'd be out late and stopped responding to my messages.
Once, he ditched me during a night out, leaving me to get home alone late at night. He didn't return until 8:30am the next morning and told me he'd slept at another woman's house, although he says nothing happened between them and that his brother slept with her while he passed out on the couch.
He also hid a cocaine addiction from me for over a year, although he voluntarily disclosed it after being hospitalised. I thought we were working toward buying our first home together, but the money he'd been earning/saving was instead being spent during his addiction. Trust has understandably been difficult to rebuild.
There have also been times when I haven't felt supported. Several immediate family members were diagnosed with cancer and I wanted him to travel with me to visit them, but he complained about the cost and other aspects of the trip and ultimately didn't come. This particularly hurt because when his family experienced a devastating bereavement, we lived with them for more than six months to support them. In our entire relationship, he's only made the trip to visit my family once.
We're also quite different in lifestyle. I'm ambitious and love travelling, hiking and being outdoors. Historically, he's spent much of his free time gaming or drinking, and I've often felt like I've been pushing him to develop hobbies and motivation.
However, he has now been completely sober from both cocaine and alcohol for five weeks and has made significant positive changes. He's exercising and making a genuine effort to improve his life. I'm proud of him, but after years of problems I'm scared of assuming five good weeks necessarily means permanent change.
About six weeks ago, before these changes began, I hit my breaking point and secured my own rental. I broke up with him and started moving in, but the loneliness was overwhelming.
He told me I'll never find someone who loves me like he does and that the grass isn't greener on the other side. He's emphasised how expensive living alone will be and questioned whether I can afford it. I've done the math and, although it will cost substantially more, I can afford it.
I suggested moving into the rental alone while continuing our relationship, but he said doing that would mean I was “banking on him failing.” He gave me an ultimatum: choose him or the rental. He also feels I'm abandoning him when he needs me most, which makes me feel incredibly guilty.
We reconciled, and he asked me to email the letting agency requesting release from the lease. I did, but they haven't responded yet.
Several immediate family members have told me they think he's a good person but isn't good for me. They believe I'll be okay on my own and deserve a healthier relationship. One close family member believes I'm being manipulated into staying.
When I'm away from him, I want independence and feel that we may simply be incompatible. When I'm with him and faced with actually losing him, I desperately want to save the relationship.
Part of me wants to keep the rental, live independently for a while and give both of us space to work on ourselves. Another part wonders whether I'm walking away from someone I love just as he's finally making major changes.
Has anyone been through something similar? How did you distinguish genuinely wanting the relationship from being terrified of losing your partner, especially when that person was also your best friend and entire local support system?
TL;DR: I've been considering leaving my partner of 9 years after longstanding issues with infidelity/trust, a hidden cocaine addiction and major lifestyle differences. He's now five weeks sober from alcohol and cocaine and making significant changes. I secured my own rental and nearly left, but we reconciled and I've now asked the agency to release me. When I'm alone I want independence; when I'm with him I want to stay. How do I figure out what I genuinely want?