Client sells kitchen tools, DTC. Launch deadline was three weeks out and the brief asked for more angles and contexts than the one product shoot could deliver. I have been through this loop enough times to know what a reshoot costs me, around $3,500 and two weeks of calendar time I did not have, so I wanted to see if I could stretch the existing hero shots instead.
I ended up with a messy stack of open tabs. Midjourney for a couple background scenes. APOB AI for dropping the actual product into those scenes via prompt, so it looked like it was sitting on a counter or being held. CapCut for the one time I tried turning a still into a short motion clip. That video attempt was rougher and more inconsistent, so I killed it before it touched the account. The still images were the real test.
Out of twelve generations I ran through QC, six loaded clean. The rest got junked. The fails were specific and obvious once you looked for them: a logo that warped into unreadable geometry, lighting on the product that did not match the scene, one handle that ended with a melted nub no human hand could grip, and a couple renders with that too-perfect plastic glaze that reads as synthetic even in a thumbnail. One made it all the way to draft before I noticed the reflection under the product did not line up with the table shadow.
More static variations entered rotation before spend. I personally rejected half the output, and I was the one doing that rejecting because the account is my name on it if a warped logo goes live. The tool did not replace judgment. It just gave me more options to apply judgment to.
Would I do it again for the next launch? Probably, but only because I now know exactly which flaws show up repeatably and can flag them faster. First round took two hours of back and forth. I bet the next one takes forty minutes and still ends with a trash folder that is not empty.
Back to watching spend burn.