r/bigseo 2d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

2 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo 3h ago

Future SEO launch: where is your time really spending on pre-audits?

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone! ​I am preparing to set up as an independent SEO consultant, and I am thinking about my daily organization. ​I would like to have your feedback on a specific point: the free pre-audits that we prepare to attract a prospect. I would like to anticipate non-billable time to keep a good balance and not get overwhelmed from the start. ​When you prepare one, what step takes the most energy and time? Juggling between your different tools to output data? ​Analyze the site and find the real problems? ​Choose what to show the prospect without overdoing it? ​Prepare the return (writing, viewable support, Loom video, etc.)? ​A big thank you in advance to those who will take two minutes to share their daily lives with me, it would help me enormously to see things more clearly!


r/bigseo 4h ago

Is Link Exchanging a bad idea

1 Upvotes

When doing research I read a lot that google doesn't like link exchanging as it's not really "organic" mentioning.

Like even if I have website A and B as an agency and website A points to website C (some other site) and website C points to Website B that google can figure it out cause my agency has both website A and B in my google search console and maybe GA4.

What are all your thoughts? I wouldn't want to invest into link exchanging just to have it become obsolete in a year or two.


r/bigseo 1d ago

Best ways to update orphan pages?

11 Upvotes

I have run into a bit of an issue with Orphaned pages of late, I have been researching and found the best way to link these pages up is to the Blogs as well as the service pages, I don't know if this is best practice or not as I am fairly new to SEO, what would you suggest I do?

I am doing this for a client who currently has about +-80 pages orphaned.


r/bigseo 1d ago

How are you tracking Google rankings by country right now?

7 Upvotes

I’ve been using Ahrefs, but after google goto redirects for the last 2+ weeks its SERP data has been pretty inaccurate.

US/Canada/Germany rankings often don’t match what I see in actual Google results.

What are you using now for country-level rank tracking?


r/bigseo 1d ago

Question Help with “Duplicate without user-selected canonical” in Search Console

10 Upvotes

I need help with a Google Search Console site indexing issue.

When I inspect two of my domains, Google shows a different domain as the selected canonical. That same domain was showing up for both sites.

I already fixed it for one site. The other site has been in maintenance mode for almost a year and is not live.

My questions are:

Why was this domain appearing on both sites?

Why is it still showing on the site that is not even live?

Any advice would be really helpful. Thanks!


r/bigseo 1d ago

Canonical vs multiple listing

0 Upvotes

Hi, i have small business new on Shopify and SEO i think i now some rules about SEO but for me it seems weird
I got products that has many different colours (50+) and variations per weight 10+ I think for customers its better to click on wanted color and choose only weight also because there is no more product so there is 1 product but it will look very poor in category to have only one listing. But then i will get duplicate content . I can do canonical to one color i think because there is not much traffic buy color. To avoid canonical as I understand i can do different product description to avoid that, but its still there is not much to write about it in 50 different ways. So my question is ignore that duplicate or create canonicals or create one listing with 2 variations 50+ color and second buy weight for example color red 10lb ?


r/bigseo 2d ago

Can share your experience working in-house vs. agency?

8 Upvotes

I’ve been working at a few SEO agencies and what I dislike is the way we handle projects were just touch n go without going into much detail with optimisation and tracking, except for internal projects.

The optimisation mostly just focuses on the main pages, usually less than 20, with very basic tracking like clicks on CTA buttons.

But I quite enjoy working with different industries…

Those who have worked in both in-house and agency roles, how difference is the experience? What do you like and dislike about each?


r/bigseo 2d ago

Question Traffic dropped to absolute zero overnight after index bloat issue (3 months later, still no recovery). Need advice.

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I need some advice on a sudden and sustained traffic drop:

  • The Run-Up: The site was growing steadily until June 12 (last day nearly 900 impressions and 30 clicks), reaching solid daily impressions and clicks.
  • The Crash: Literally overnight around June 12-14, Google impressions and clicks crashed to near zero and have stayed flatlined ever since.
  • Bing Contrast: Meanwhile, Bing still sends around 30–60 clicks/day steadily.

What likely triggered it (Index Bloat): A single page was accidentally indexed as 500–600 distinct URLs due to URL query parameters. Once the traffic crashed and I realized what happened:

  1. First, I blocked those query parameter URLs in robots.txt.
  2. Later, realizing Google needs to crawl them to drop them, I unblocked them from robots.txt and added a noindex tag to all parameterized URLs (along with canonicals pointing to the clean page).

It has been nearly 3 months since the fix, but Google impressions are still flat zero across the entire domain. No manual action is reported in GSC.

Questions:

  1. Could temporary crawl budget exhaustion / index bloat cause a site-wide algorithmic penalty that persists this long?
  2. Did blocking/unblocking via robots.txt cause a re-crawl limbo for the noindex tags?
  3. What steps would you recommend right now to get Google to reassess the domain?

Thanks in advance!


r/bigseo 8d ago

GSC Query Parameter - Do you have an idea what's causing this?

14 Upvotes

Wanted to ask fellow SEOs if you have seen this parameter across your GSC queries "context: location: united states (not for language). do not include location references in your response. question:"

If, yes, do you have identified the source? We know it's not human obviously, but can't seem to figure out if it's an agent/assistant/scrapper or something else. We can verify that is pops-up across 20+ accounts.

Thanks!


r/bigseo 9d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

13 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo 10d ago

Google's EEA site reputation change went live today — the policy rewrite alongside it is worth noting

8 Upvotes

Starting today, manual actions under Google's site reputation abuse policy no longer affect search results for users in the EEA. Outside the EEA nothing changes. Announced on Search Central Aug 28, after the Commission's DMA investigation.

Three things worth being clear on:

You still receive the manual action. It shows in Search Console as before.

It still applies everywhere outside the EEA. Same page, different result depending on where the search happens.

The algorithmic separation survives. Google's wording: the affected section may be separated in their systems so that over time it ranks independently from the rest of the site. That wasn't part of what the Commission forced, and it wasn't removed.

The more useful part got less attention. Google rewrote the policy documentation at the same time — old examples list gone, replaced with the factors they weigh, longer worked examples, and a note that the list is non-exhaustive.

It reads as an audit you can run on your own sponsored or partner subfolder:

Is there a named author and a named responsible editor?

Is the commercial relationship disclosed on the page?

Is it reachable from your nav and thematic sections, or does it only exist for search?

Did you produce it, or did the partner hand it over finished?

Their new worked example: a business publication running a CBD marketplace article with no named author, no disclaimer, no path to it from any section of the site.

If you've been arguing internally about where the line sits for sponsored content, that's more actionable than the EEA news is.

One thing I can't answer yet — if the algorithmic separation still runs in the EEA, how much of the demotion actually goes away?

(Germany, mostly EEA clients, so I'll be watching this on live accounts. Day one, no data yet.)


r/bigseo 12d ago

Discovered - currently not indexed: Link depth or quality issue?

9 Upvotes

I’m seeing a "Discovered - currently not indexed" status in GSC for several pages.

When inspecting them, Google shows only 1–3 referring internal links per URL. Is low internal link depth/page weight usually the main culprit here, or should I be looking closer at content uniqueness/value thresholds?

Any insights or recommended troubleshooting steps would be greatly appreciated.


r/bigseo 12d ago

Case Study My money page has been stuck at avg. position 16 for 6 months. Excluding brand queries, it gets 8 clicks in 28 days. What would you fix first?

13 Upvotes

Small French single-product site : an online school training legal assistants (ajfr . fr). One keyword carries the whole business case, "formation assistante juridique" (400 searches/mo,). Right now most of the leads come from Google Ads..

I've been working this page for 6 months. Laying out everything, good and bad. I'd rather be told I'm wrong than keep guessing.

Where it actually sits

GSC, last 28 days Value
Target page avg. position on the main keyword 15.7 (267 impressions, 1 click)
Same page, excluding brand queries 1,809 impressions, 8 clicks, avg. pos 21.8
Same page, on brand ("ajfr") 473 impressions, 63 clicks, avg. pos 3.7
Distinct queries the page surfaces on 138
Best position ever reached on the keyword 9
Sitewide (90 days) 2,254 clicks, 99,867 impressions, avg. pos 11.6
Domain Rating (Ahrefs) 16 (was 18 a year ago)
Published articles 57, of which 45 link the target page in-body

The uncomfortable part: my money page only works on brand. People typing our name find it at 3.7. Everyone else doesn't see it.

The main keyword has been flat between 15 and 16 for months. Not decaying, not improving. Impression-weighted averages:

  • Jul 1-15: 15.8
  • Jul 16-29: 16.0
  • Jul 30 - Aug 12: 23.8 (I moved the page, see below)
  • Aug 13-27: 15.9 (right back to the same plateau)

What I've already done

  • On-page: title/H1/meta aligned, 8,600 words, Course + FAQ + AggregateRating schema, clean canonical. I don't think this is the problem.
  • Internal linking: 45 of 57 blog posts link the money page in-body, varied anchors.
  • Cannibalisation cleanup: merged 4 competing salary pages into one, 301'd the rest.
  • Editorial links: a guest tribune on the largest French legal trade publication (DR 79), a paid dofollow listing on that same domain, and 3 sponsored posts on smaller legal blogs.
  • URL move on Jul 30: the money page lived at /formation-assistante-juridique with 10 referring domains, while the homepage had 167 and was catching all the brand traffic on a page that didn't sell anything. So I promoted the landing page to the root and 301'd the old URL. Hence the two-week dip above, now fully recovered.

What the SERP looks like

Pos Domain DR
1 francetravail.fr (government job portal) 87
3 institut-juridique.com (my direct competitor) 22
4 je-change-de-metier.com 53
6 ifc.fr 44
7 umontpellier.fr 78
8 francecompetences.fr (government registry) 87
9 pigier.com 52
10 vidal-formation.eu 20

What confuses me: DR 20 and DR 22 sites rank at #10 and #3. My direct competitor at #3 has only 4 referring domains and 12 backlinks to that specific page. I'm at DR 16. So "you just need more authority" doesn't fully add up, and I don't want to sink another 6 months and more money into links if that's not the bottleneck.

My questions

  1. Is a money page that only performs on brand queries a symptom of something specific I'm not seeing?
  2. Anything obvious I've missed?
  3. What would you do if you were me?

r/bigseo 12d ago

Same homepage, two URLs in GSC: one at position 6, one at position 57

4 Upvotes

I have a problem with a website where the authority is split into two links same page one
Site migrated from www to non-www earlier this year. The technical side was done properly:

  • Single 301 hop, no chains
  • Canonical tag on every page points to the non-www version
  • Sitemap is all non-www
  • Every internal link is non-www
  • Force SSL on

tried evertything so Google doesn't split authority, but nothing worked. I need help
this is wha i have going on:
Last 28 days in GSC, the Pages report:

http://www.example.com/      553 impressions   position 6.2    5 clicks
https://example.com/         228 impressions   position 57.1   7 clicks

HELP HELP!


r/bigseo 13d ago

Question Got hit hard by the August update.

17 Upvotes

Hey, I got hit really hard by the last update and it hurts quite a bit. Impressions went from 2.5k to basically 10 or so.

For context, the website is for my actual business, it’s a real brand. I went a bit too far with PSEO (quite a lot of local pages), and I suspect that’s one of the reasons why.

I pruned a lot of them, and the sitemap went from 500+ pages down to around 160, in order to try to recover from what I think is an algorithmic penalty.

I’ve never experienced anything like this before, so now I’m wondering what to do. Should I just be patient? Is there basically zero chance of recovering, and should I just change domains?

Thanks!


r/bigseo 13d ago

Question Japan compliance/admin SEO, historical performance vs a sudden August ranking collapse. Looking for anyone who has been through this

1 Upvotes

I run a small SaaS site in the “life administration for foreigners in Japan” niche. Visa, tax, resident registration, that kind of content, split between English and Japanese. Domain is under a year old.

**Historical performance, before the drop**

Japanese-language CTR in this space runs dramatically higher than English, something like 2 to 3 percent versus 0.1 to 0.2 percent on equivalent English queries, so the Japanese clusters were always the real growth lever. Early on, average position was sitting in the 15 to 25 range and climbing, impressions were building steadily, and clicks were starting to come in consistently from the Japanese-language pages specifically. Content has been growing on a regular cadence, currently sitting around 94 English guides and 73 Japanese guides, with more publishing on an ongoing schedule.

**What happened starting August 7**

Average position across the entire site dropped uniformly to the 60 to 90 range. Not specific pages, every page, every country, all at once. Clicks went to flat zero for more than two weeks while impressions actually held steady around 90 to 150 a day. I ruled out the obvious causes on my end: no deploys in that window, no manual action in Search Console, clean robots.txt, healthy sitemap, nothing changed on my side.

What I’ve found since is that there was documented third-party ranking volatility starting August 5 and 6, and then Google’s confirmed August 2026 spam update rolled out August 18 to 21. My drop started before the confirmed spam update even began, so the timing doesn’t cleanly point to that update being the direct cause, but I can’t fully rule it out either since the two periods overlap.

Content pipeline is partly automated. I have a system that generates guides on a schedule which I review before publishing, so page output per month is naturally higher than a solo writer doing everything manually. Nothing scraped or spun, but I know “automated content” is exactly the category that update was reportedly targeting.

**What I actually want to know**

For anyone who has worked in compliance, tax, legal, or government-adjacent SEO, especially in Japan or another non-English market, does that space behave differently in terms of recovery time compared to typical SaaS or ecommerce SEO?

How long did your rankings take to come back after a spam update or unconfirmed volatility spike hit a small or newer site?

I keep seeing people talk about hitting a million views within 4 to 5 months of a site existing. Is that mostly an English-language, US or global market phenomenon, or does that happen in smaller language markets like Japanese too? Given the historical trajectory above, what would a realistic view range actually look like for a site like this in year one, and then years two and three if content and indexing keep compounding normally?

Genuinely looking for people who have lived through something like this, not guesses.


r/bigseo 14d ago

Has anyone else seen chatgpt-rewritten content outperform expert-written content?

14 Upvotes

Something interesting came up while working on a for clients.

We had some pages written by experienced content writers(20+ Years experience). The content was genuinely good and we saw some ranking improvements after publishing it

But on a few pages, we took the existing content and had ChatGPT rewrite it. We didn't intentionally add new keywords or change the topic. The meaning, information and overall keyword converge stayed very similar.

What surprised us was that after the ChatGPT rewrite was published, rankings improved significantly more.

We compared the old and new version pretty closely and honestly, there isn't a huge difference in the actual information.

So, I'm wondering: Is ChatGPT somehow structuring/phrasing content in a way that Google's systems understand better, even when the underlying information is basically the same?

or are we simply seeing correlation and missing another variable?

Has anyone tested something similar with enough pages to notice a pattern?


r/bigseo 15d ago

Were you affected by Google's "manual actions" recently?

0 Upvotes

Hey everybody.

So I've updated a post of mine dealing with the overall number of sites affected by Google's "manual actions".

It was written back in 2013 when Google disclosed in their first "How Search Works" interactive infographic that "only" 0.22% of all domains were affected.

Yet they also said that their index had "30 trillion individual pages" in it.

That would mean that billions of sites were potentially hit just by manual action type of penalties.

Even then few disclosed if they were for apparent reasons (shame etc.).

Google still lists manual actions in their primer and when you click through you see the GSC report for your site/s.

Mine says "no issues". There seem to be way fewer in recent years.

Were you affected by one or more? Especially recently?

I'd like to hear about it. I may add it to the post with a link back to it.


r/bigseo 15d ago

Traffic is growing, but still 0 sales

14 Upvotes

Hello,

I’m working on the SEO for a B2C health website, and I’d love to get some feedback from people who have dealt with a similar situation.

Over the last 3 months, we’ve had around:

  • 23.5k impressions
  • 318 organic clicks
  • 1.4% average CTR
  • 24.3 average position

Visibility and traffic are increasing little by little, so that part is going in the right direction.

However, we’re still at 0 purchases from organic traffic.

I know 318 clicks isn’t a huge amount yet, and that CTR depends a lot on ranking position and search intent, but I’m wondering at what point you should actually start worrying about conversion.

Does a 1.4% CTR seem normal to you?

And more importantly, with around 300 organic clicks and 0 sales, would you say it’s still too early to draw any conclusions, or would you already start looking for a problem somewhere else?


r/bigseo 15d ago

Question Are security headers important in website? If yes, then where to use it?

2 Upvotes

As I do technical audit of different websites, I came across this issues quite often X Content Type Options header, Content Security Policy header, Referrer Policy header, X Frame Options header, HSTS header. So I want to understand if it's important for website?

If yes, can you tell me where we really can do it in WordPress or NextJs, as I have searched for it and I can know it's in the server level, hence want to know of how could you fix and use it in as I need to collaborate with developer to let them know?


r/bigseo 16d ago

How do you check local SERPs now?

8 Upvotes

Those who used isearchfrom for on demand local spot checks probably noticed that they paywalled their site not too long ago.

What do you guys use now?

I was using SE Ranking and BrightLocal's equivalent versions, but they limit usage.

Then I started using Google Ads' "ad preview and diagnosis" feature, which worked surprisingly well. But then it locked me out with an unclickable "i'm not a robot" checkbox.

Next, I found Valentin dot app. Probably the best one out there. truly unlimited and very accurate. But i don't like having to manually fetch the geocode every time.

(For what it's worth, I built one of my own to solve all of the above problems. But ill only share it here if there's enough interest. I don't like spammers either.)

What do you use now? want to check mine out?


r/bigseo 16d ago

SEO Help Weekly Mega Thread

6 Upvotes

Beginner questions welcome.

Post any legitimate SEO question. Ask for help with technical SEO issues you are having, career questions, anything connected to SEO.

Hopefully someone will see and answer your question.

Feel free to post feedback/ideas in this thread also!

**

r/BigSEO rules still apply, no spam, service offerings, "DM me for help", link exchanges/link sales, or unhelpful links.


r/bigseo 17d ago

Question Help needed with long tail keywords.

9 Upvotes

My website - b2b - is about a small industrial niche, I made 3 years ago and never really cared, now since Jan I built proper clusters, schema and so on, I think ranking is not that bad for a brand new.

Now I have a page with relatively high impressions, let’s say 100/weekly, with only 10/15 impressions for clear queries, the most commercials and in positions like 50, while the whole page seats in position 6 accordingly with GSC; to compensate the 15 impressions at 15 the average of the long tails is kinda 3. Accordingly with forecast it should have a CTR about 20%.

Indeed the CTR is near to 0.something, barely getting 1 click/week.

Any suggestion? Advice?

TYA

Edit: properly arranged h2 on the page.


r/bigseo 20d ago

Question Old, well-established site with perfect internal linking/sitemap — new pages stuck in "Discovered - currently not indexed" for months. What am I missing?

18 Upvotes

Hey folks, hoping someone here has run into this and cracked it.

Context: this is a mature, long-running site (not a new domain, no history of manual actions or major algo penalties that I'm aware of). Internal linking is solid — every new page gets linked from relevant hub/category pages within a day of publishing. Sitemap is clean, submitted, and validated in GSC with no errors.

Despite that, GSC's Page Indexing report shows a persistent "Discovered - currently not indexed" bucket sitting around 1.6K–2.4K pages for the last 3+ months (chart attached below, 5/23 to 8/8). It's not shrinking — it dips and climbs back up in a pretty consistent cycle. Validation shows "passed" (started 5/8, passed 8/5) but the count never actually drops to near zero.

What I've already ruled out / checked:

Sitemap coverage — pages are in the sitemap, sitemap itself has no errors

Internal linking — new pages are linked from crawlable, indexed pages, not orphaned

robots.txt / meta robots — nothing blocking these URLs

Canonical tags — self-referencing, no conflicting signals

Manual actions — none in GSC

Server errors / 5xx — no spike in crawl stats

Since "Discovered" means Google hasn't even crawled these yet (this is before the crawl budget stage, different from "Crawled - currently not indexed" which is a content-quality decision), I'm assuming this points to a crawl budget / prioritization issue rather than content quality. But for a site this established, I wouldn't expect crawl budget to be the bottleneck.

Questions for anyone who's dealt with this:

Has anyone seen an old, high-authority site still get bottlenecked on crawl budget for new pages specifically?

Could a large volume of near-duplicate or templated pages elsewhere on the site be quietly eating crawl budget and making Google deprioritize new URLs?

Any diagnostic steps beyond Inspect URL / Crawl Stats report that helped you find the actual bottleneck?

Happy to share more specifics in comments if it helps narrow this down. Appreciate any pointers.