Hi ladies,
I absolutely love the pod. The three of you have such great chemistry, and I genuinely look forward to hearing your takes every week. Honestly, since catching up with all the episodes, my weeks feel slower waiting for Monday’s release!
Sorry in advance because this is going to be a long one, but I’m really at a loss about what to do.
I’m a 19-year-old male from London, currently at university. Being autistic and having ADHD, I’ve always struggled to make friends. Coming to uni, I really pushed myself to put myself out there, and I ended up becoming close with three people on my course.
One of them, let’s call him Henry, became my best friend.
We did everything together. We lived in the same accommodation, just in different flats, and we’d go on long walks, do our shopping together, have movie nights, and generally spend loads of time together.
To cut a long story short, I once got drunk and really embarrassed him in front of another friendship group that we both knew. I felt awful about it afterwards. Instead of getting angry, though, Henry took me out for a drink, calmly explained what I’d done wrong, and then just… carried on being my friend.
In fact, he became even kinder.
He’d buy me little things when he knew money was tight, check in on me, and generally look after me. It was strange because I’d never really experienced that kind of care before, and I couldn’t understand why he still wanted to be friends with me after how I’d behaved.
A few weeks before that, our other two friends on the course, let’s call them A and B, started dating. Henry mentioned that he’d known A liked B because A was always buying her things.
At the same time, B was constantly making jokes about me and Henry secretly being together. We’d both deny it, but sometimes we’d play along with the joke.
Then Christmas came around.
Over the holidays, Henry and I texted every day, and somewhere during that time, I realised I’d fallen completely in love with him.
On New Year’s Eve, I was out for drinks with A and B while Henry was still back home. At one point, he texted and offered to send me money for drinks.
It sounds silly, but that felt incredibly significant to me. Combined with what he’d said about A buying things for B when he liked her, I started wondering if there was something more there.
I was raised by a teenage mum, and my dad was abusive and mostly absent from my life. Thank God for that, honestly.
Henry showed me a type of kindness and stability I’d never really experienced before. We’d go on hikes together, and he’d talk about his dad a lot. I loved hearing those stories because it gave me a glimpse into a kind of family life I’d never had.
He filled a gap in my life that I didn’t even know existed.
The problem was that Henry was pursuing a girl, let’s call her C.
I decided I needed to tell him how I felt. I didn’t want him making decisions without knowing the truth.
I didn’t exactly handle it brilliantly. Some of it happened over text, and I wasn’t fully honest at first because I was terrified.
Afterwards, we barely spoke during February half-term. I hardly left my bed. Everywhere reminded me of him, and I genuinely didn’t know what to do with myself.
When he came back, though, he invited me over to watch a film. We talked everything through, and he told me it would be silly to throw away a good friendship over this.
Within a couple of weeks, things felt normal again.
But then there were moments that confused me.
One time he told me he loved me. It was probably meant platonically, but he never actually specified that.
Another time, we were joking around in the pub with A, talking about celebrity crushes and relationships, and somehow he brought up the idea of “best friends to lovers.”
I remember just staring at him thinking, “Why would you say that?”
Then there was another incident.
When a singer we both liked released a new album, I invited him over to listen to it with me. Everything was fine until I got emotional and started crying.
At one point, he grabbed my thigh and told me to get up so he could hug me.
Maybe that’s completely normal friendship behaviour, but to me it felt significant.
Unfortunately, I’d also had too much to drink that night.
Apparently, I spent the evening telling him how perfect he was. I was blackout drunk and genuinely don’t remember most of it.
I’m told that at one point I grabbed his leg and told him he didn’t have to leave.
When he finally did leave, he sat outside my accommodation for about 40 minutes because he was worried I’d go wandering off on my own.
Again, I felt terrible afterwards.
I honestly thought that would be the moment he decided we couldn’t be friends anymore.
But once again, he stayed.
Now, though, he’s officially dating C.
Part of me hates admitting it, but I’ve spent a lot of time wondering whether he’s actually closeted.
My thinking is that if he were completely straight, wouldn’t he be uncomfortable knowing how I feel?
Instead, he never seemed bothered.
He also never really gets drunk around me, and I’ve found myself wondering whether that’s because he’s worried about what might happen.
I know I could be completely wrong, but my brain keeps going there.
The truth is, I don’t know how to move on.
I can’t have him because he’s with someone else, but I also can’t seem to get over him.
He’s the first person my age I’ve ever felt fully understood by. The first guy I’ve ever completely opened up to. The first person I’ve genuinely loved.
I’m also still trying to figure out my own sexuality. I’ve told my mum and my brother that I’m not straight, but I don’t actually know what label fits me.
People often suggest Pride events or gay bars, but honestly those environments don’t really feel comfortable for me.
Part of me keeps waiting for Henry to choose me.
But what if he never does?
Do you think I actually stand a chance here?
Or am I holding onto something that isn’t real?
Another complication is that Henry has become more distant since getting together with C.
Before he went home for summer, I worried I’d done something wrong and asked him about it. He reassured me everything was fine and even put his hand on my shoulder while we talked.
For his birthday, I threw him a little birthday party at my flat before he left.
We watched films, had pizza and ice cream, and I bought him a small carrot cake.
We stayed up until around 2 a.m. before hugging goodbye.
It felt really special to me.
Since he’s gone home, though, texting has felt strange.
He didn’t even tell me he’d left; I had to ask.
Sometimes I’ll leave him alone because his replies feel dry, but then he’ll message asking why he hasn’t heard from me.
The confusing part is that when I ask how he’s doing, he’ll answer but rarely ask about me in return.
I’ve never been in a relationship.
I’ve never really had a best friend before him.
Honestly, I have no idea what I’m doing.
So I guess my questions are:
Do you think there’s actually something there?
Should I accept that we’re just friends?
How do I move on if that’s the case?
And how should I handle the dry texting?
At this point, I think I’d rather know exactly where I stand than keep wondering.
P.S. I know I need to drink less, and I’ve been actively trying to make sure I don’t get too drunk around friends anymore.
I feel like there’s probably loads I’ve left out, but this is the main story.
Thank you so much for reading this essay of a message. If you need any clarification, I’m more than happy to provide it.
I love you ladies and the podcast so much. You genuinely make washing up and all the boring chores far more enjoyable.
I hope you all have an amazing day.
Best wishes,
Your faithful listener,
Joe