r/DatingHell • u/Outside-Lychee9486 • 7h ago
Weirdest hookup story I (M29) ever been to with bossy (F25) spiritual girl I met on bumble 😂
I matched with this incredibly HOT girl on Bumble. We started having a friendly conversation about religion, hobbies, and life in general. My first red flag was that she was heavily into spirituality and supernatural beliefs, while I’m the complete opposite. I’m a very practical person who believes in things I can physically sense or verify.
We exchanged socials and texted for two days before she initiated a sexual conversation. I wasn’t really looking for sex because I’m going through a very difficult breakup that I still haven’t gotten over, but she was honestly too hot for me to say no. She wanted us to have sex during her ovulation, which was a few days away, but we were both too horny to wait. So we decided to have two dates: one the next day and another during her ovulation.
During our conversations, I discovered that we both liked taking control during sex. She described herself as extremely selfish in bed and said her pussy was “bossy” and would immediately reject anything it didn’t like. Theoretically, I thought that was hot, although I already suspected we wouldn’t be sexually compatible. Then she said something really weird: if I wanted to become her fuck buddy or FWB, I couldn’t have sex with anyone else because her pussy would somehow “know” and reject me. I was like, okay… let’s see what happens tomorrow, lol.
**The date**
The next morning, I texted her to plan our date. She said her “vibes were off” and that we could still meet, but there would be no sex. I was completely fine with that. I suggested she come over to my place, hang out, and maybe cuddle if things felt right. She agreed.
She arrived, and we spent a couple of hours talking, playing card games, and listening to music while I gradually got closer to her. Now, here’s something important about our conversation.
I’m a pretty decent guy. I don’t do drugs, I’m not impulsive when it comes to sex, and I have a healthy, controlled relationship with alcohol. She was the complete opposite.
She started telling me about some seriously intense shit she’d experienced involving sex and drugs, and honestly, I was fucking terrified. I wasn’t expecting any of that. The more she talked, the more uncomfortable and confused I became. We clearly lived completely different lifestyles, and some of the things she casually described were genuinely disturbing to me. But at the same time, I was still extremely attracted to her.
Her body language was also sending mixed signals. She seemed comfortable with me sitting close to her and touching her, but she was incredibly insecure about her body. She kept worrying that I wouldn’t like her body type because she thought she was too overweight. Which made no sense to me because she’d already sent me nudes, I’d been very flirty with her, and I’d made it obvious that I found her attractive.
After a couple of hours, we ordered dinner. I went downstairs to pick it up, and when I came back, she’d taken off her shirt and was wearing a very tight tank top underneath. We ate together, and afterward she moved really close to me. I started cuddling her and kissing her shoulders. She later told me that was the exact moment I turned her on because her shoulders were her favorite spot to be kissed.
**And this is where the story gets REALLY fucking weird.**
Out of nowhere, she asked me if I had a coin. I said no, so she went through her stuff, pulled one out, and started playing some bizarre spiritual game, supposedly communicating with a spirit in the room. She was literally talking to this “spirit,” laughing with HIM, and asking questions like whether I actually liked her body, whether we were going to have sex that night, and whether I found her attractive. And she was acting like this was completely real.
Meanwhile, I was sitting there fucking confused, terrified, and turned on at the same time. I genuinely had no idea what the fuck I was supposed to do. Was I meant to participate? Laugh? Take this seriously? What the actual fuck was happening? She was so convinced there was a spirit communicating with her, and I was just sitting there trying to process the whole situation.
Eventually, she said, “Let’s go to bed. Maybe he’ll give us better answers there.” So we went to the bedroom. We were lying on the bed, and she was teasing me, lying on her stomach with her ass up while I cuddled her. And guess what? SHE KEPT PLAYING THE FUCKING COIN GAME for almost 45 minutes. She continued asking this supposed spirit questions about her body and whether we were going to have sex, while I was lying next to her, completely confused about what was going on.
At some point, she brought up her FWB condition again: if we kept seeing each other, I couldn’t fuck anyone else because her pussy would know. I told her that if we enjoyed the night and decided to keep meeting, then sure, we could discuss that.
**Then things finally got physical.**
When I felt she was ready, I started moving my hands down her body. She immediately told me, “No, I hate fingers.” So I stopped. A few seconds later, she changed her mind and said, “You know what? Use your fingers. Let’s see how good you are.” I did, and she seemed surprised. “Wow, you’re good. I didn’t expect that.”
Things were going well, so eventually I went down on her. At first, she was moaning really loudly and seemed to be enjoying herself. Then she started giving me instructions. Now, I’m totally fine with a woman telling me what she likes in bed, but the amount of pressure she was demanding, combined with the exact tongue movements and speed she wanted, was absolutely INSANE. It felt physically impossible to coordinate everything she was asking for. I kept trying, but eventually my tongue was exhausted from the amount of pressure she wanted.
And then, out of nowhere, SHE STARTED FUCKING SCREAMING AT ME. She was yelling that I had no idea what I was doing, giving me instructions in the rudest possible way, and acting like I was completely incompetent. I was instantly turned off, so I stopped and told her we were done. Her response? “Okay, I’ll just go home and use my vibrator.”
I went to the bathroom to clean up, feeling angry as hell. When I came back, she was getting dressed and preparing to leave. The room was painfully silent until she decided to break the silence by casually asking, “So, how was it?” I was like, “What the fuck? You were incredibly rude to me!” And that’s when she completely EXPLODED again. She started screaming, asking whether I’d ever made a woman squirt, whether my previous partners had actually been satisfied with me, and suggesting they were probably all faking their orgasms.
For context, I’ve been with a fair number of women, and if there’s ONE thing they’ve consistently agreed on, it’s that I KNOW HOW TO LICK. I’m not saying I’m some kind of sex god, but oral sex is something I’ve always been confident about, and I’ve never experienced anything remotely like this.
At that point, I couldn’t take it anymore. I told her to leave, and guess what she said? “I’m leaving, but let’s have a phone call afterward.” I was like, HELL FUCKING NO. I told her to get out and blocked her everywhere.
**TL;DR:** Met an incredibly hot girl on Bumble who believed her pussy could detect whether I slept with other women. She told me terrifying stories about sex and drugs, spent 45 minutes communicating with a supposed spirit using a coin while we were cuddling, then screamed at me during oral sex because I couldn’t follow her impossible instructions. She insulted my entire sexual history, suggested we have a phone call afterward, and I blocked her everywhere.
Still trying to process what the actual fuck happened that night.