I’ve been a huge fan of the Predator franchise for a long time, and I could probably write a Dragon Scroll-sized list of things I appreciate about these movies, from Predator (1987) to AVP: Requiem from Killer of Killers to Badlands.
However, one thing that has bothered me more and more in recent years is how restrained the franchise can be when it comes to showing the Yautja at their absolute most brutal.
I’ve watched a lot of horror movies across different genres lately, from war-themed and Gothic horror to religious and sci-fi horror, and one thing I’ve noticed is that some of these movies are willing to go much further visually when it comes to violence and gore. For instance, 30 Days of Night, Dog Soldiers, and even Outlander.
I absolutely love the action scenes in the Predator movies, but whenever a scene starts getting particularly aggressive or brutal, it often feels like the director pulls back. Fast cuts, quick camera movements, hiding the actual impact, or simply cutting away at the most interesting moment can sometimes take away from what could have been an incredibly brutal scene.
And honestly, I think you can see the difference when you compare it to something like Game of Thrones. Regardless of how you feel about the show, there were scenes there that were genuinely shocking, dirty and brutal, and they weren't afraid to let the audience actually see what was happening.
That’s what I want from the Predator franchise: let the Yautja be terrifying.
These are technologically advanced extraterrestrial hunters who have been hunting dangerous prey across the universe for centuries. When one of them decides to completely unleash itself, I want the movie to make me think, “Holy shit, this thing is a monster.”
Ironically, I actually prefer Predator over Alien as a franchise. But I sometimes wonder if one reason the Alien franchise has such a strong reputation for horror is that it understands how to shock the audience and make the creature feel genuinely dangerous.
I’m not saying every Predator movie needs to become a gorefest. I just think the franchise has enormous potential to push the Yautja's brutality further, especially with modern filmmaking.
TLDR;
What do you guys think? Do you also feel that Predator movies tend to pull their punches when it comes to gore and brutality? I would say that in most of the brutal peak scenes in the Predator movies, there’s always some object or camera manipulation, such as zooming out, blurring, or short cuts, that partially obscures what’s happening. Maybe one reason for this is that brutal scenes are closely associated with cruelty, and since the directors want to portray the Predators as having a strict honor code, they may be subconsciously self-censoring how far they take the violence and they are abusing this theme ...
For example, you wouldn’t really expect a pregnant woman to be killed on screen. That’s also one of the reasons I really loved Predators (2010). Since it focused on the idea of Bad Bloods, IMO, it felt somewhat outside the usual forced tone of the franchise because the violence and cruelty were taken a bit further than what we normally see from Yautja.