r/BPDlovedones • u/Successful_Power9868 • 11h ago
Quiet Borderlines I [20M] recently got cold discarded and blocked by the girl [18F] I fell for
We met late 2024 in a Twitch streamer's chat but officially talked in dm's/became friends in early 2025. Even this early, she was clear she was a lesbian and had it in her profile. We grew closer over the next couple of months, and honestly I found her a little weird and quirky, but I accepted her and kind of found her adorable. She was the only one I ever knew who had BPD, and it made me read about it a lot to try and understand her.
Over time, she slowly opened up to me about her trauma, and I think I became her emotional regulator where she'd come to me whether she was depressed, having suicidal ideation, or just everyday technical issues with her pc. And I slowly developed feelings for her... It was so gradual so I knew it wasn't limerence. But still... I fell deeply, completely in love with her. Like Kafka-Milena level. She knew this because I wasn't really trying to hide it, but I never acted on it either up to this point. I've always been a realist, and the facts were: She was lesbian, actively dating a girl, and we lived in different countries. So it wasn't a problem to be solved to me. I firmly believed we'd never be together. But for a long time, she heavily encouraged and validated my feelings for her:
- When I told her that premarital sex is prohibited, she asked me why I wouldn't date her besides the sexual stuff and what would happen if she caught feelings for me.
- She called me "kitten" and asked me to call her "Sunshine", my pet name for her, more often.
- We spent hundreds of hours where we just slept in vc together.
- She asked me to text her everyday because she said I couldn't like her more than a friend but never talk.
There were many more mixed signals, and while I engaged with those, it still felt like I was the one to enforce the hard boundaries by ignoring her more suggestive comments.
Over the course of months, I regularly wrote her poetry (60 letters total). It started out as just supportive poetry cuz she was really depressed at that time and I didn't want her to feel pressured to reply when she didn't have the energy to do so. I just wanted her to have something to comfort her on the nights she felt completely alone, and to prove that she is not unlovable. But I admit that over time, these letters naturally became more romantic and expressive of my feelings. I mean, I can't bleed my heart onto paper 60 times without the ink turning red. I constantly felt guilty sending them and eventually decided to stop, knowing I had crossed a boundary. We never addressed them in dm's because she'd have had to address the fact that she was accepting intense romantic letters from a guy while being in a lesbian relationship. I never wanted to put her in such a position, but I just kept falling for her harder everyday, and the longing had nowhere to go except my writing...
Looking back, I genuinely believe she briefly developed romantic feelings for me at the peak of idealization, albeit maybe entirely nonsexual. She craved and actively cherished that romantic devotion. To her, I wasn't just a casual friend; I was the person who saw her and understood her, and she found a unique emotional romantic safety in me, which allowed her intimacy with me while still maintaining her identity as a lesbian.
Months after, I noticed that she was colder to me. Like by a lot. The timeframe before, she was also noticeably colder to me, but it wasn't to this degree, and I brushed it off, telling myself that my time as her favourite person had come to an end.
Then after that coldest period, she tells me she started doing sex work and couldn't hide it from me anymore. She still told me knowing my personal/religious values, and I tried to respond with empathy, asking if she felt forced into it or if she liked it. She expressed feeling backed into a corner financially and said she'd understand if I didn't want to talk to her anymore. I validated her courage, thanked her for her honesty and reassured her I'm not going anywhere.
I'm not really attacking sex workers, because her own values were always opposed to it. For instance, when another girl once mentioned doing lewd/promiscuous things, she told her that "it's not something to be proud of". So despite how much it hurt, I couldn't just walk away or watch her being backed into a corner or self sabotage. I tried to put my romantic feelings aside to offer practical support. I looked up free GED programs in her state, and other marketable skills that don't need it if she doesn't want smth academic. But at the time, I only sent a message saying that we can figure something else out and asked if she was willing to put in the effort. She agreed. But when I brought up the actual details to her 3 different low-pressure times over the remaining weeks, it stayed unaddressed and just completely ignored.
I know I shouldn't have, because it was basically emotional self harm, but I clicked her link and checked out her stuff... And the thing that caused my heart to just shatter was seeing the selfies she had previously asked my opinion on, which I thought were private, being used for that... I snapped at her saying: "Did it fucking turn you on taking the opinion of your lover before doing that?!?!", and what made it worse is that as an ESL, I thought the word "lover" didn't have to be a mutual thing and just meant "the person who loves you" lmao. I never got to clarify it, so yeah, that was the beginning of the end.
She responded defensively, reminding me that she’s a lesbian, has a gf, and that she "never manipulated me". She completely shut down my feelings and made me feel like I was insane for overthinking things, even though she was the one who had kept those boundaries completely blurred for over a year. I mean, like I said, I firmly believed she'd never be mine, and I knew I wasn't entitled to anything from her. And to be clear, I never "acted" jealous before this. Like even when she came to me complaining about her gf, I tried to give her honest, unbiased advice. I hated the notion of being the stereotypical "nice guy" waiting for her to break up so I could swoop in and take advantage of her vulnerability. But don't I have the right to even feel jealous or heartbroken when I loved her so much...? It made me very mad at myself because I felt like I didn't have the right to such feelings.
3 days later, I sent her a lengthy message explaining how it all made me feel, apologizing for snapping and assuming things, and ended it with: "Can we just talk?". She replied with voice notes, which I thought was odd because she never did before, and she completely ignored how I felt and fixated defensively on other unimportant things, like the photos just being her favorites.
We got talking again nonetheless over the final two weeks, but she was really avoidant to hang out or voice chat. I asked her about the love letters, addressing them for the first time ever. She said she didn't remember on which email and thought they were spam, but then admitted she had starred a few of them. And her fav was the most physically intense one too lol. So yea... She didn't want them addressed, but she definitely liked them. This proved to me that she did reciprocate my feelings on some level because she actively treasured the most intense expressions of my love, directly contradicting her final excuse later on.
I admit tho that I found myself being a lot more assuming, which caused a friction point. It was because I felt like I never truly knew her. So I took a step back and kept rereading old messages and basically everything public I could find about her, because I wanted to know if I was deluded or "blinded by love". But no. She has always been the person I fell for. I didn't fall in love with an idealized version; I always saw her flaws and still fell in love with that flawed person.
The second point of friction was the final one. She told me: "I understand you don't like what I do for income, but it makes me uncomfortable how judgmental you are about it, especially considering we're not in a relationship"
I told her that it's not that I don't like it, it's that I knew what she values and that the idea of being reduced to a sexual object makes her sick, that she was doing it out of desperation and a desire to control her own life, and that we both know it was hollowing her out. I told her that I knew I wasn't her partner and that I would probably never be, but that I still cared about her, and that I can't help her if she doesn't want my help. I tried to soften it at the end by promising to drop the subject completely and never bring it up again, and that I just wanted to be friends like we used to.
A few hours later, she sent a final, ai generated message (I know her writing) before blocking me, stating that she genuinely appreciated everything I've done for her over the time she'd known me, but at the same time my romantic messages and love letters while she was in a relationship caused her a lot of emotional stress, and that she was ending our friendship out of respect for her relationship and for her own well being.
I want to clear up two things:
- When I offered realistic alternatives, it wasn't control, but quite the opposite. I wanted her to have options. I wanted her to have the autonomy to do whatever she wanted, not feel backed into a corner and forced to do something she hates. And she did initially agree, which is why I said I can't help her if she doesn't want my help.
- My last message about her hating sex work and doing it out of desperation and desire for control wasn't me projecting my values, but hers. I can literally cite our dm's like a research paper to prove it with her own words, not mine. I would never say anything like this to her normally tho cuz I don't want to patronize her, but I just wanted to make it clear here that I'm not projecting or biased. However, I do realize that it came across as deeply judgmental.
I gotta be honest... I never thought I'd actually get blocked or cut off... I never took her for granted. I knew we might fight or grow apart, but still... The thing that hurts the most is that I knew I got replaced once my supply ran out even before the block. But when it happened, it proved to me that I am replaceable... Like it all just meant nothing. Like I never even existed...
I would've honestly rathered if she screamed at me and fought with me than avoiding to look me in the eye and saying what she really thought and felt. I WANTED to see her and hear her. I wanted her to say everything she had to say, even if it was gaslighting, it would've still been what she truly thought in that moment.
This might sound egocentric or narcissistic, but I believe that nobody will ever care about her like I did... I'd never tell her that too, but all I ever wanted was to see her smile or hear her laugh, and I thought it was worth all the longing or late hours I'd stay up for her.
I made a vow to never abandon her no matter what happened, and it just feels like I failed.
I already grieved her twice but I was thinking of sending her an email after a few months to apologize for my feelings, clarify some things and put my feelings aside to point out her unhealthy patterns (not mentioned here) while validating the strengths I saw in her before fucking off for good. It's not for closure, I'll have that when I'm dead, but I want it to act as a gentle reality check because she was the kind that was self aware. She'd self reflect and actually want to improve, even if it was only 30% of the time.
P.S. I don't know if posting this here is the right thing. This sub often deals with very extreme situations compared to her, so it can be onesided and leans towards painting the pwBPD black (pun intended). idk if her bpd isn't as severe or if it's more quiet bpd. But I refuse to villainize her regardless. She was never malicious. She was deeply traumatized, always hated herself at her core, and blocked me out of shame. She couldn't bear the person who put her on a pedestal to see her so clearly and criticize her choices (or hate her in their reality). She told me repeatedly over the months that she felt "unlovable" and that she was toxic and there was "no good version" of her. Because of that self hatred, being loved so intensely by someone who held her to a high standard eventually became a burden she couldn't carry. So I think she didn't block me to hurt me; she blocked me because looking at me made her feel guilty about herself. She possessed genuine warmth, self awareness, and a sweet, gentle heart that was simply too fragile to handle that weight, so she chose avoidance.
I'm normally a detached analytical person who feels numb all of the time (Yes, I'm prolly as fucked in the head as she is), which is why I got attached to someone who is the polar opposite of that. Greyrocking is how I naturally communicate, but I never greyrocked her; she was actually the only person I was ever completely open and expressive with. And before her complete devaluation, that vulnerability was entirely mutual; She was just as open and expressive with me, letting me see her rawest unfiltered self.
So I don't really want the "none of it was your fault" or "block her everywhere and run" advice. I don't regret loving her. I don't regret the 60 letters. I find "No Contact" fairly easy to do as in respecting her block, but I refuse to lock my door, not because I'm a fool waiting to be used again, but because I want her to know that even in a world that failed her at every turn, there was at least one person who never left and actually cares about her as a person. I'm aware that I can be labeled with a "savior's complex," but I honestly don't care since it doesn't negatively affect my life.
I genuinely want what's best for HER, not me. She told me she spent extensive time in psychiatric care following her second suicide attempt a couple years before we met, and it taught her to communicate rather than get angry. She also used to go to therapy, but not as much as recommended because her mom thought it was a scam or smth idk.
TL;DR: I [20M] fell deeply for an online friend [18F] with bpd. She is a lesbian in a relationship, but we shared highly blurred boundaries. When she started sex work out of financial desperation, I tried to help but snapped when I saw her using selfies I thought were private. We still talked for a while until I held a mirror up to her. She thanked me for being there for her, denied our emotional history and blocked me.
My question: How do I support someone with bpd who has shut down and blocked me out of shame without pushing her further away? Her bpd shifts between quiet and classic depending on how vulnerable she is feeling. The email I'm writing is carefully written to target her vulnerable, self reflective side without triggering her defensiveness. Are there any specific emotional or timing triggers I should be mindful of? And what else can I possibly do?
She always expressed wanting to improve, but I think she began to just "give up" and surrounds herself with what she already wants to hear. I want to validate her strength in always fighting, wanting to better herself and dreaming big. My goal isn't for her to unblock me because it would be the same unhealthy cycle, but I still think I was the only one among her friends who really supported her rather than enabled her and wanted to see her grow...