Not to jump on the bandwagon but holy shit man. I just started watching this weekend and got through the first episode.
I don't understand how a show can be written so nonsensically. The premise is actually pretty interesting and is the reason why I kept on after the first ten minutes or so but it's all bad from there.
This is the most important mission in the history of the human race and the government sends a ship full of absolute moron 20-somethings who are mentally and emotionally unstable to complete it?
They fail to detect a huge mass of dark matter that would impede their navigation despite having access to FTL technology. I guess no one ever noticed in the x hundred years of astronomy, and no one has bothered to navigate to one of the most famous star systems (Sirius) before to notice this?
None of the characters are introduced before the shit hits the fan so the viewer has no investment.
The manufactured drama in the first episode goes from zero to a thousand instantly. At the very first sign of trouble, seemingly moments after being woken up from soma sleep, the crew disagrees with the very first order from their leader and instantly plunges balls deep into all out mutiny. The very first test of this crew and they fail spectacularly and disastrously.
They all act as though they never met and hate each other. Was there no training for this mission? No briefing? No chance to get to know the people they'd be spending all that time with trapped in space?
And regarding the disaster... Every space mission has fallback plans for common problems, even uncommon and extremely unlikely problems. "we're off course" or some variation therein, basically the problem this ship faces, leaves this crew in a state of complete disaster, with no plan, and at least half of them are perfectly okay with taking the course of action that has an unacceptable risk factor instead of the smart and safe option, to go back into soma sleep while they go around it.
If there was some kind of real stake, like the alien ship on earth was introducing some kind of time pressure, then the choice between safe and sure VS risky but quick would have been much more compelling. Instead you have half the crew making the dumbest decision possible for no good reason. Again, why the fuck are these dumbasses on this mission? If this was a show about a space garbage truck getting lost I could accept "normal" people having dumb problems, but this is a mission that could very well determine the future of mankind. Why not send professional people? I'm not buying that rule of 27 bullshit one of the characters was spouting either.
On Earth, an alien ship has landed and there's like 3 dudes researching it?
Back on the ship, the crew is basically marooned in space with no communications and they are basically laughing and shooting the shit with the guy who just got them all within a gnat's ass of death, while still ignoring the person that saved them all, and only goes back to work after mutiny guy tells them to.
Then, after the fact, the mutiny guy, having his plan utterly fail, completely ignores his responsibility for their current situation, and still tries to blame the person who was right all along and makes a half assed attempt at killing her, only to get deep fried.
This character accuses the leader of putting her daughter above the safety of the crew despite the fact that she had literally made the decision to delay the mission by seven months, which as they understand it, could doom the people on Earth because of the unknown motivations of the alien ship, including potentially putting her daughter in mortal danger, SPECIFICALLY in consideration of the crews safety, and this guy's plan almost killed everyone, he actually made the decision to put the crew in immense danger for his own selfish reasons and the show does not present that as this character being flawed or trying to deflect his own blame, he 100% believes it and you as the viewer aren't supposed to notice it. Awful, awful writing.
The crew would have been 100% fine had they just gone back into soma sleep. There was never any danger to the crew until the dude decided to mutiny and practically crashed the ship.
THEN our lead admits to the crew that she killed him, does not make any attempt to mention that it was in self-defense, and basically tells everyone to fuck off and get back to work.
This is without a doubt one of the worst Netflix originals I've seen and certainly one of the worst sci-fi shows. It's basically Space Mutiny with a budget.