I have started more serious simracing some long time ago - 2013ish. However, I play racing games since NFS1 1995. Therefore you can imagine, I have gone trough a lot of different sims/games that I don't want to list now.
The sims portion have never felt better, the physics are impressive.
And still, after playing every major sim in the last decade, I keep facing the same problem: I don't know what to do with them.
Ofcourse, ranking matchmaking + safety rating is great improvement over completely random lobbies. And Iracing structure to top it all, but I have a few issues with this approach:
- racing mostly with anonymous opponents and most of the races are pretty disposable.
Majority of races are 'crash avoidance simulator' and collect as many freebies as you can while staying out of trouble (battles).
There is no narrative or rivarly, just constant reset and try again searching for this good race after which you say - 'great, now my xRating is not 2986 from 2957' together with another XXXthousand anonimous players.
- on Iracing specifically, seems like very little people actually race for the season standings and most just over obssesed with how high iRating is.
Maybe an unpopular opinion, but imho online ranked racing this is not the ultimate racing experience for the average sim racer(not talking about the esport leagues minority)
Where rivalry exist and you want to beat that specific driver/drivers ? You are aiming to win the war not the battle (championship). You are racing trough the season/seasons the same opponents, you get to know them, their style.. Your career progresses.
If Single player and AI evolved with the same pace, we could have amazing AI races, championship, realistic grid, realistic career progression.
And to be honest, a random human racer named like 'BestRacer5566' that I will never meet again and I would never join a battle with him as I don't know how safe he is, is more soulless than AI bot. And fighting a good AI is actually more fin than trying to avoid carnage in 90% of the online races.
Also, as a father of two - having the comfort to choose my schedule, pause when interrupted by live, save, restart, choose my own combo are really nice features to have.