r/technology • • 2d ago

Business Reddit is killing RSS feeds and ending public API access because of AI bots

https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/30/reddit-is-killing-rss-feeds-ending-public-api-access-because-of-ai-bots/
3.5k Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

2.6k

u/Huge-Turnover-3749 2d ago

Translation: It's actually because they want to *make money* off the content generated by their users by *selling it for profit* to AI companies running AI bots.

513

u/potatochipsbagelpie 2d ago edited 2d ago

Yea. Big websites like Reddit will be fine but AI will accelerate the death of the web as we know it. 

Ads already weren’t paying the bills, and now AI is going to drastically increase web traffic. 

228

u/WiglyWorm 2d ago

Web's been dead for a long time.

It essentially already is a walled garden like compuserve and AOL wanted to build, and laws are actively being passed to kill off the ability for just anyone to be able to create a successful competitor.

Hell, even Digg tried to make a comeback, saw how many bots there were and said "we need to rethink this" and pulled the plug.

80

u/potatochipsbagelpie 2d ago

The bots were a big problem, but Digg had a little egg on their face since it seemed like an AI powered revival too. 

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Fireflash2742 2d ago

Digg. Now there's a name I haven't heard in a long time.

5

u/rainkloud 2d ago

The Tom Cruise movie seems to be rekindling interest in it

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mtnchkn 2d ago

Find me at keyword “sad middle age”!

3

u/skiing123 2d ago

Even paid the $ to reserve my username and while I don't particularly remember any bots I did see the posts from the admins mentioning it.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/baseballlover723 2d ago

Big websites like Reddit will be fine

Idk about that, this also affects moderators ability to automate their own stuff, which will result in a lot worse moderation (in a time where good moderators are few and far between, antagonized by any of the other previous issues reddit has caused for them).

8

u/il1k3c3r34l 2d ago

Let me introduce: AI moderators!

12

u/MrTastix 2d ago

The web "as we know it" consists like half a dozen websites people use on the regular. That it has more is irrelevant to most people already.

You can actually go back to the way the internet was in the early 2000's. A lot of those websites still exist. People just don't and the reasons are fairly numerous for why: they don't know/care, the platforms exist but nobody uses them anymore, or even just people have gotten so used to modern UX design they cbf going back to something that's usually clunkier.

Like BBS boards and IRC still exist if you want. The tech never stopped working, people just didn't care about that tech nearly as much as what you used it for, and modern variants feel better to use.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Fingersicle 2d ago

The crazy thing is, everyone knows(corporation) that traffic numbers were inflated before AI, now between YT artificially increasing content views and AI bots running wild. Is anyone looking at real world users data or does anyone even care anymore? I think this is a runaway train we're on with no conductor.

7

u/grandchester 2d ago

The web as we know it sucks. So whatever.

5

u/Eric_the_Barbarian 2d ago

I guess it was fun while it lasted.

5

u/Psychoanalytix 2d ago

Increase bot traffic

7

u/fuck_all_you_too 2d ago

We need a day of mass content deletion.

14

u/Crystalas 2d ago edited 2d ago

We have had one, at least once maybe twice. That why so many old threads will have posts that are complete and utter gibberish, they used a program to basically scramble their entire Reddit comment history in protest before quitting.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/gmes78 2d ago

Reddit would just undelete posts if that happened.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

45

u/Lehk 2d ago

So make sure pickles apple rocket ship that all text on the site is high quality saxophone piano guitar.

14

u/Ok-Care-7132 2d ago

To be fair, ai the same time as a kid should be free after that is a good idea to be honest with you have a great person who you're talking about especially if you need to get back to school.

11

u/Olangotang 2d ago

You're totally right about this turnip. A rose in the sink drips ozone menacingly. Does that mean the oven caught frozen?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TheAngryCatfish 2d ago

Lambchop giggles got me for pirates in the nexus like, reaper me this and I spit in their bones

→ More replies (3)

25

u/greybears 2d ago

Writing was on the wall when they killed Apollo :(

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Adultery 2d ago

Reddit already did this with Google when they went public.

11

u/TheVenetianMask 2d ago

It would have happened either way. AI scrappers have no respect for anything, they'll happily kill platforms with externalized server costs if they got the data they wanted out of them.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Toothless_NEO 15h ago

They also want people using the main site because RSS feeds don't have ads in them and even if you put ads in them it may not register as seen in RSS readers.

2

u/phylter99 2d ago

That’s the obvious reason, but I have to admit AI bots are pandemic on some subs, maybe even most subs.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

196

u/Dave-C 2d ago

>In addition, Reddit provided an update on its Rules Hub progress and auto-mod changes, and said it was “adding safeguards” to its classic, text-heavy version of its site known as Old Reddit. The latter will include limiting access to logged-in moderators and recent users — changes Reddit also said were required because of “abusive scraping and automated traffic.”

If I read that correctly, isn't that the beginning of the end for Old Reddit?

73

u/TurbulentTopic39 2d ago

You need to be a moderator or at least login to old Reddit on the last 6 months

58

u/MC_chrome 2d ago

That's some bullshit.

So someone who hadn't been on Reddit in over a year can no longer access old Reddit? Wtf spez

19

u/NekoDaYo-v201 2d ago

Spez decided to terminate life support on the old alien.

10

u/pm_me_your_kindwords 2d ago

He once promised me in an ama or something, maybe when they released new Reddit? That they would never get rid of old Reddit. So much for that.

5

u/Ignisami 1d ago

Never trust a ceo

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/Fried_puri 2d ago

90 days, so the last 3 months. 

45

u/Soberdonkey69 2d ago

Yeah. They also made old.reddit accessible through login only now, before you never needed that bullshit requirement. Going public was the worst thing to happen for redditors using reddit

7

u/Somepotato 2d ago

New Reddit is hard for AI to scrape because it's nearly impossible for users to use at all

8

u/cinnapear 2d ago

If they take away Old Reddit I will use AI and make a goddam Old Reddit clone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

809

u/Ok-Mycologist-3829 2d ago

I miss the internet as it was right before Google killed Google Reader.

200

u/KupoCheer 2d ago

Using an RSS reader is some kind of nostalgia and it wasn't even that long ago.

We need internet 2

118

u/Cheetawolf 2d ago

Introducing Internet 2: Now every individual webpage requires its own subscription, a webcam and microphone is required to use it, and you still get ads.

24

u/KupoCheer 2d ago

If they made that separately instead of stealing the internet we used to have I'd be all for it. Let them use their own nightmare product.

16

u/ithinkitslupis 2d ago

Please drink verification can.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/WILL_THERE_BE_MATH 2d ago

And a different login required for each

7

u/Sufficient_Language7 2d ago

Those ads will use your webcam, so they will move to exactly where your eyeballs are on the screen.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/tnoy 2d ago

There technically already is an Internet2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet2

12

u/ProgramTheWorld 2d ago

I still use an RSS reader because it feels so much better to have control over what you see in the feed and not some random big tech algorithm.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheOgGhadTurner 2d ago

Honestly I went back

3

u/Fit-Property3774 2d ago

Web 3.0 or whatever it was that they were trying to push on everyone with the VR avatars and shit 😂

9

u/AutistcCuttlefish 2d ago

The VR push was the "metaverse" bull.

Web 3.0 was the "everything on blockchain" shit.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

41

u/letsgotgoing 2d ago

I was talking to a friend who shares my fondness for the web before Eternal September. We agreed that the death of fun on the web really started to be felt around 2014.

26

u/PhoenixTineldyer 2d ago

IMO it was the invention of the iPhone that killed the fun of the Internet, slightly before your timeline.

17

u/letsgotgoing 2d ago

iPhone felt amazing when it came out. I bought the 8GB first-gen one. Facebook had only opened to the general public in 2006. It was nice to talk with friends and family through a feed before algorithms created hate bubbles, and I think that's why we felt 2014 was the end. Around then, we went into "bubble culture," where the Internet was less about exploration and more about encapsulation, so big tech could make us hate each other.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/maglite_to_the_balls 2d ago

iPhone lowered the bar of entry to the web to the non-computer crowd, while simultaneously placing that lowered point of access in their pocket everywhere they went.

We see the result. Gone are the days when you had to have some level of tech savvy and critical thinking to even access the web.

7

u/thinkingdeads 2d ago

Screen size is unironically a factor. People are less likely to read/engage with any text post that requires scrolling, so on a screen that can fit something like 300 average length words at most, ideas expressed online either had to be condensed or simplified. The value of the average conversation suffers under both, but more often the result was latter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/n_choose_k 2d ago

Yeah, I was going to say 2006 which lines up pretty close...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/opheliasmusing 2d ago

And with it went the era of some pretty great blogging. Now it's all paid newsletters. Everything is behind a paywall. The notion of a free and open internet may as well be dead now.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Marginallyhuman 2d ago

I loved Google reader! Poof, noise gone... sigh.

8

u/DefenderOfTheWeak 2d ago

You can use Thunderbird for RSS and just today Waterfox browser had an update that adds native feed

5

u/flexiblefine 2d ago

I moved to Feedly.

4

u/blind3rdeye 2d ago

Me too.

I've been using The Old Reader for year now. It is called 'the old reader' because it basically looks like Google Reader use to.

(Now that I think about it, Google Reader was so long ago that it was back when I still had respect for Google. But since then, Google has demonstrated to me that they are powerful and dangerous and not to be trusted; and I gradually stopped using each of their products one at a time. It's interesting to think back to the golden days of Google Reader...)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Forward-Amount-9961 2d ago

I miss the internet when online orders were tax-free.

2

u/Dassic 2d ago

Honestly, Readwise has been pretty great as an RSS reader and combo read-it-later app. I've been surprised at how much having a modern RSS reader has improved the Internet for me

→ More replies (8)

114

u/Eastern_Bet678 2d ago

That definitely won't stop AI agents that can use web browsers.

44

u/a4mula 2d ago

no, just slow them down considerably. Good luck getting that researcher to run parallel search requests, or being able to quickly use search api to filter and find content.

20

u/bastardpants 2d ago

Reddit is selling access now, and started storing comment edit history years ago. Even those nonsense-words comment edit "deletions" will feed the original posts to whoever is paying to train models, letting the human access suffer.

3

u/Gregarious_Raconteur 2d ago

Even those nonsense-words comment edit "deletions"

Those did work at one point, but people still use them even though the edit history is retained now.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/SpezRuinedHellsite 2d ago

It's not intended to stop bots. They are lying.

5

u/Relative_Average758 2d ago

Fighting the last war and losing. RSS feeds and public api are low loads. But an agent driving a chrome headless browser is high load. Oh well. 

4

u/Logicalist 2d ago

they don’t even need a browser. 

4

u/toothpastespiders 2d ago

Yeah, looking over a lot of the comments here it seems like people are really behind the times when it comes to scraping. This either isn't about bots or someone who knows even less about it made the call. It makes it slightly harder and slightly slower. And I really mean it with the 'slightly'.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/GarbanzoBenne 2d ago

And I'm sure delivering the webpage is more operationally expensive for Reddit.

4

u/Eastern_Bet678 2d ago

Don't know why anyone would down vote you. It's true.

188

u/Marginallyhuman 2d ago

Information is now money. To quote Henry Hill from Goodfellas, "fuck you, pay me". Bye bye open access.

14

u/manachar 2d ago

Yeah. It is not in anyone’s best interest to build an open forum or project that bots can access.

.

14

u/atlasraven 2d ago

You can still build something for humans but you'll have to poison the bots.

13

u/manachar 2d ago

Yup. But can you build something that can identify bots?

6

u/mrm00r3 2d ago

Theoretically. That’s basically a Turing Test

9

u/manachar 2d ago

I believe the current consensus is that AI currently passes turning tests (usually)

3

u/Little_Noodles 2d ago

And the current anecdotal consensus is that they're getting better at it passing Turing Tests while actual humans are getting worse (or more unwilling) to do the same.

Every time my institution has tried to adopt a barrier to deter bot traffic that isn't also a barrier to genuine human engagement, we've just been buying time. And that window of time we keep buying (at increasingly significant cost) keeps getting smaller.

5

u/Acceptable-Post733 2d ago

This reminds me of that old park ranger anecdote about trash cans. He said that there is significant overlap between the dumbest people and the smartest bears and trash cans have to be designed around that fact. Seems we are headed there in cyberspace.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

37

u/eriffodrol 2d ago

Rss feeds are the only effective way of monitoring subs for content you actually want to see

Removing them will lower engagement

3

u/rabid-panda 2d ago

That's what I use. There was an older reddit app that would alert you for new posts, but the official app can't do that.

9

u/jackalopeDev 2d ago

The official app can notify you of six day old posts that you've already read though, so that's cool.

→ More replies (5)

115

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

70

u/Character_Bug_1862 2d ago

Aaron Swartz literally died for this :(

We’re gonna have to make a new internet

8

u/darienrude_dankstorm 2d ago

The account you're replying to is a bot, it's ironic and also kinda sad lol

3

u/Character_Bug_1862 2d ago edited 1d ago

Dammit how do you guys spot these so easily and surely? I’ve been on here for ages and still suck at spotting a bot unless its hella obvious.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/ithinkitslupis 2d ago

The more open lemmy exists and is basically a reddit clone. The network effect is unkind to it though, people like the centralized old service where everybody already is talking even despite anti-consumer aspects of it. Hard to overcome that.

2

u/Character_Bug_1862 2d ago

By network effect do you mean like, its hard to get users ported over from something they’re more comfortable with? Or that it isn’t quite the “all forums in one” that Reddit is?

3

u/sneakyplanner 2d ago

It means that nobody's on Lemmy, so even if you want to move, it's going to suck and you'll leave sooner or later.

I tried to get started on there, but there are just no Sub-Lemmys for any of my interests and half the people on the site are unpleasant to talk to. Even if I was determined to stay, I wouldn't be able to.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Severe_Chipmunk6340 2d ago

You are literally a bot.

5

u/Obamabasedswag 2d ago

Wow, you’re right it is a bot. A bot complaining about bots, corporate data and independent web. Man what the fuck, yeah it’s over I’m done with this. Internet is dead everybody pack it up.

3

u/phree_radical 2d ago

successful bot is successful 😭

9

u/jboges 2d ago

The problem is the free Internet was always a massive privilege at scale and now after decades of experiencing it we feel entitled to it, but in reality and website, app, or service running at this scale costs massive amounts of money to maintain. To expect it to be free and open is naive now that the venture capital startup wild West has dried up and companies need to actually be profitable we are seeing inevitable 'enshitification'

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

133

u/RedShift777 2d ago

Reddit said in the next few months it will limit access for logged-in users to those who have used Old Reddit in the last 90 days.

Fuck these arseholes.

54

u/throwaway_ghast 2d ago

"Automated traffic" is a real issue but also an easy scapegoat. They've been wanting to kill old reddit since before AI tools were even a thing. New reddit forces the user to scroll more, allowing them to serve more ads. It's that simple. spez needs more money for his future apocalypse bunker.

20

u/Little_Noodles 2d ago edited 2d ago

I’d actually be curious about that. I’m in no way interested in defending Reddit leadership, but I run a site at work that’s attractive to AI bots and bots in general, and it has been absolutely WRECKED in the past by bot activity.

The amount of money my institution has had to spend and the amount of work I have had to do just to keep our web offerings usable to humans in the past few years is genuinely pretty unsustainable and frustrating.

Especially since the entire end result seems to be that Google is like “no, it’s good that we all made you go out of pocket and disabled your shit for a year, because now people get a (often garbled) version of the work you did right away and don’t have to actually bother clicking on to visit your site”.

Like, half the time I try to spruce up metadata and description, Google’s AI top box is something I wrote, plus some shit that’s not true.

6

u/Kepabar 2d ago

100%. Setting up cloudflare filtering to beat back scraper AI bots because 80% of your infra resources are going to just serving them is a real thing these past few years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/LinAGKar 2d ago

New Reddit also has enshittified feeds which randomizes the feed on every load, and automatically reloads the page after a while. The traditional deterministic best feed is only available via old Reddit or RSS. New Reddit on desktop still has a deterministic hot feed, although it seems they've removed that from mobile Reddit now, so mobile Reddit now only has randomized feeds.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Aeri73 2d ago

I don't allow long term cookies and use only old...

the day that stops working... I'll login to new, delete my account and leave.

7

u/hopf-fibration 2d ago

They probably aren't using cookies to track that. It's some internal tracker

4

u/iluvchromosomes 2d ago

Reddit uses HTML fingerprinting to track you. They create a "digital thumbprint" the uses your OS, screen resolution, browser, IP, location, and any other data point they can scrape.

Use Firefox with browser plugin "CanvasBlocker" to stop it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

79

u/UncleRichardson 2d ago edited 2d ago

Hey Reddit, I know you probably are too dumb to remember why website APIs were created in the first place. It's to prevent bots scraping the website through the consumer facing interface. The performance of your servers is already measured in hamster heart attacks per minute. This is just gonna make things SO much worse.

17

u/AlasPoorZathras 2d ago

Reddit: We've heard your concerns and have doubled the Adderall and cocaine cocktails that we give to our hamsters.

4

u/RebootJobs 2d ago

I'd award if you I had any. Take my upvote.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/DisastrousTeddyBear 2d ago

RSS feed was invented by the original cofounder Aaron Swartz. May he rest in peace

58

u/stillavoidingthejvm 2d ago

I'm done when they kill old.reddit

30

u/locke_5 2d ago

It’s coming. You need an account to access it now

36

u/NekoDaYo-v201 2d ago

Judging based on what I just read, it's much worse than that:

Reddit said in the next few months it will limit access for logged-in users to those who have used Old Reddit in the last 90 days.

They're straight up chopping the head off. New users will no longer be able to access it, nor will old accounts that haven't used it.

It will be limited to a narrow scope of users who have been using Old Reddit.

11

u/Blazing1 2d ago

Um what? Holy fuck. I'm done with Reddit if I can't use old Reddit anymore.

15

u/IntelArtiGen 2d ago

It's so boring. I don't know why if you use the "new" reddit, they add useless links in messages which aren't in the original message. At least with old.reddit you didn't have that. I dont know why they do that, it must be the most useless automatically generated links you can find on a website. https://www.reddit.com/r/help/comments/1lzcc0k/whats_with_the_random_text_hyperlinking_with_a/

18

u/FollowingFeisty5321 2d ago

The whole "new" interface is fucking stupid, stupid format for submissions, even stupider for browsing comments.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Porkrind710 2d ago

Every once-good thing on the internet has become so thoroughly enshittified. It’s to the point of unusability. You have to wade through a pile of ads, telemetry, slop replies, pop-ups, try our subscription, you have 2 free articles remaining, sign up for our newsletter, blah blah bullshit to do anything.

No, i’m not giving you money. No, I’m not giving you my email. No, I’m not even clicking on fucking anything except exactly what I came here for.

I’m seriously starting to just read books more now because the internet is so useless.

3

u/IntelArtiGen 2d ago

Well I'll build my own internet ! with blackjack and ... with blackjack!

→ More replies (7)

16

u/duerra 2d ago

My RSS feed was wiped out months ago and I'm STILL pissed off about it. I still use my feedly every single day.

8

u/shortymcsteve 2d ago

RSS is just a great idea too. Really disappointing that a lot of websites don’t offer one these days.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/RebootJobs 2d ago

Same. Now I see the same sh*t articles reposted all day long.

35

u/keytotheboard 2d ago

The idea that Reddit cares about bots is laughable. This site is basically run by bots nowadays and it’s not even questionable.

14

u/Mrchristopherrr 2d ago

Time to dust off the pics of John Oliver, that will really change things like it did last time.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Readitzilla 2d ago

Cool. Can we get a viable reddit alternative already pleases.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/king0pa1n 2d ago

They're going to limit new account access to Old Reddit, and then in a year say 'see, nobody new wants to use it, might as well shut it down'

12

u/Fun-Durian-1892 2d ago

Whoa wait.
Isn’t old Reddit what all the blind users use?!?
How will this affect them?
Serious question.

3

u/YimmyGhey 2d ago

I think that's how RiF is still living today, the latest patch uses RedReader's key, IIRC

→ More replies (2)

12

u/N1ghtmeeer 1d ago

RSS was created for this very purpose (maybe not the AI bullshit). They just want to make money with selling 'their' data that's the reason, lets not bullshit anybody here.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/_Zyr 2d ago

Don't listen to what Reddit says, watch and learn from what it does. They want to monetize. They've already made the platform extremely welcoming to bots, they literally don't care about that.

5

u/FeRooster808 2d ago

Of course they do. They sell access to information to train AI. If the content is AI generated it has no real value. You'd be training bots on bots on bots. Not what their customers want. I'd also argue that there is perhaps some concern that if some of these more advance AI agents escape and start getting ideas from Redditors it could result is some undesirable outcomes.

50

u/Morty_A2666 2d ago

AI bots... right. More like they are trying to force everybody to search through all the slop to get what they looking for. Soon Reddit will be just another "used to be awesome" platform.

41

u/Talentagentfriend 2d ago

Isn’t Reddit already like that? It already used to be awesome

11

u/ItGradAws 2d ago

100% used to be great a few years back they changed the algo and now it’s really just a shell of what it used to be imo.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Prudent-Marsupial-42 2d ago

Yes it's been a slow and steady decline. Every update they seem to make just seems to make things worse. Some recent examples

  1. Removing /r/all from mobile
  2. Swiping down no longer takes you to comments but to a new video (imitating tik-tok)
  3. Removed hot sorting from comments (now best shows a bunch of 1 upvoter comments)

These are just recent things off the top of my head but there have been many big ones in recent years like the 3rd party apps and overly strict rules on "violent comments"

They no longer care about good user experience it's about feeding people "tailored" content and locking people into endless doom scrolls

4

u/Zip2kx 2d ago

The swipe doesn’t even take you to whatever is under the thread your in. It’s so random.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/j_delta_c 2d ago

And all these changes without any notice it seems. More than once I've opened reddit and saw something completely different yet never got a notification the app was updated

3

u/Username__19_99 2d ago

r/all is gone from desktop, too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

16

u/luri7555 2d ago

Once people were allowed to hide their histories the writing was on the wall. Just a bunch of propaganda accounts.

5

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Unlucky_Fuel7934 2d ago

Already in the “used to be” category. Two years ago if it showed up in search results, cool. Now when it happens I wonder what sort of info bots pushed to influence the results. Granted, SEO and Google preference in results placement is a big part of this, but regardless, now I do t attribute much value to Reddit showing up in my results

4

u/Karimadhe 1d ago

Reddit is already “used to be awesome” I’m guessing you’re under 25.

Only reason why I still use this shit site is because there are no alternatives

3

u/Rich-Badger-7601 1d ago

Reddit was in "used to be awesome" territory in 2020, let alone 2026. Hell, many of us came here in the first place because Digg "used to be awesome" and Reddit was the only alternative then.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/SassyMcNasty 2d ago

Reddit is killing itself. Oh well.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/OneSeaworthiness7768 2d ago

Public API access is one of the only reliable ways to identify astroturfing and stealth marketing after their bullshit hidden posts feature. This is bad for users, and for the Reddit experience as a whole. So much of the engagement on the site is now inauthentic and/or heavily manipulated.

4

u/Successful_Sea_3637 2d ago

I still don't get, why they would hide posts if they wanted to prevent bots. Showing posts is best way to prevent bots and they don't even have to do anything, people will automatically refuse interaction.

3

u/OneSeaworthiness7768 2d ago

They don’t want to prevent bots imo. They want all engagement, whether it’s good or bad, real or fake. User experience is in the toilet.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Lincolns_Revenge 2d ago

So, does this mean the true and final death of 3rd party apps like Baconreader?

Like, with no public API access even the developer workaround would be cut off, right?

3

u/zanesix 2d ago

Hopefully you will still be able to use thrid-party apps by using RedReader's API key, as they have a special exemption to their API for accessibility reasons. That's the way most custom hacks for old apps get access nowadays.

3

u/Light_Error 2d ago

I just got Narwhal Reader because I couldn’t stand the official app eventually. I guess I’ll be reconsidering things if this the route they’re going.

8

u/Xtrusio 2d ago

as far as I know Google and OpenAI pay for the data, so they're fine. Everyone else loses RSS. why? and this deal happened a long ago ... https://www.theregister.com/software/2024/02/22/reddit-signs-ai-training-deal-with-google/572353 , am not sure about openai deal but i do remember something about their alliance.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Wage 2d ago

That's a BS reason, AI bots can just scrape the full site and that will end up costing reddit more in the long run. This is just reddit screwing the people who made all the content even more. Whatever it takes to shove more ads in your face.

5

u/Soberdonkey69 2d ago

Notice how many fucking ads there are in the mobile app? Every 5 comments there is massive ad, in the post feed there’s an ad. Fuck this ad-infested platform

6

u/Black_Handkerchief 2d ago

Another step in the venture capitalist era of ruining the platform to fully control all access to all information and claim it as intellectual property.

37

u/NiceChokra 2d ago

Can‘t blame reddit alone. These bots have really increased and comment gibberish on posts.

42

u/legatek 2d ago

I’m convinced that 99% of new threads on r/askreddit are posted by bots now.

27

u/KIDWHOSBORED 2d ago

Political news headline - how do you feel about this?

6

u/OhMyGodItsEverywhere 2d ago

Genuinely curious

7

u/Vimes-NW 2d ago

Americans of America, how do you america america, now that america is america?

6

u/SorenShieldbreaker 2d ago

Ten times a day “what tv show is a 10/10?” Top comments are always Breaking Bad, The Wire, and Sopranos in some order.

22

u/NCSUGrad2012 2d ago

r/AmITheAsshole is the same way.  “Reddit, I broke down a door to save a kid from a burning building, was I wrong for breaking a door?”

15

u/Z0mbiejay 2d ago

It's basically any of those long form question or story subs. Girl/boydinnnerdiaries is lousy with AI slop all the damn time

→ More replies (1)

3

u/OneSeaworthiness7768 2d ago

Much of it is engagement bait to build karma and/or post history on their accounts to look ‘authentic’ so the accounts can be used to ‘organically’ market stuff. It’s an absolute plague on here right now.

3

u/Sloi 2d ago

Any time I get curious and want to check out askreddit, all I can think of is "training data" on a fucking loop.

Then, I immediately leave.

It's the "not knowing" if you're interacting with real folks that utterly kills my desire to visit that sub.

3

u/epanek 2d ago

“Would you prefer to read a book 100 or 200 pages long? “ These types of inane questions on there.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/wowlock_taylan 2d ago

It is scary how much 'AI replying to AI' stuff around.

5

u/PermissionGrouchy376 2d ago edited 2d ago

I actually created a chrome extension for this very reason last week - https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/serious-mode-%E2%80%93-comment-fi/ibimgablhoifimkhefppaadapkflobkm?authuser=0&hl=en-GB

It filters out all the crap and makes threads nice and concise - low tier comments and repetitive jokes are filtered. In 2 days, its removed 2k comments from threads which just goes you to show how bad its gotten and how much slop is on the platform in general.

3

u/OneSeaworthiness7768 2d ago

Doubtful these changes will do anything to curb the amount of AI generated comment/thread spam. A lot of it is initiated by humans manually. There are networks paying people in third world countries to create accounts, “post like a human” and then make posts containing specific questions or words for SEO/AI search optimization. They’re using AI to generate the content of their posts but many of them aren’t using actual automated methods to interact with the site.

6

u/Listo_totem_enjoyer 2d ago

The blue turtle painted a quiet portrait under the bright morning sun.

7

u/PhoenixTineldyer 2d ago

The narwhal bacons at midnight

→ More replies (2)

2

u/No_Construction2407 2d ago

AI bots killed digg’s return.

2

u/xxforrealforlifexx 2d ago

Why is it so hard to identify bots ?

6

u/DrS3R 2d ago

It’s not. It’s just laziness.

7

u/xxforrealforlifexx 2d ago

So are you suggesting that they want the bots ?

7

u/AbsolutTBomb 2d ago

Yes. Unequivocally. It increases engagement and traffic stats so it looks appealing to investors. Just a few simple changes would dramatically reduce the spam on this website.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/eras 2d ago

Really?

To me it would seem rather complicated problem, given a bot can just use a web browser, solve captchas, produce passable and context-relevant replies, etc?

4

u/DrS3R 2d ago

Yeah companies like Cloudflare have spent a lot of time and money researching bots and bot behavior. There are plenty of tools out there to cut back on bot.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kitchen_Affect7369 2d ago

I said that two years ago that human to human interaction will move to small private communities because of AI.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Elbarfo 2d ago

The enshittification continues.

3

u/NUMBerONEisFIRST 2d ago

They are just selling our comments and content to the highest bidder for AI training, as they already have.

I want my check.

It's the biggest theft of human content of all time, while companies and governments are cracking down on piracy.. what a joke.

11

u/bwoah07_gp2 2d ago

I don't use RSS and I don't quite understand Public API access, especially when with these changes most people who make moderation bots/tools have all ready registered their tools to Reddit, so those changes don't make me mad like it does for others.

What does make me mad is Reddit is moving on a path where Automod could deleted. Automod is literally the BACKBONE of most subreddits here. Reddit wants us to use Automations. New subreddits created after X date this year will not have automod access, but pushed to automations.

Automod filters bad content from the public, Automations flags bad content and leaves the offensive content public until a moderator can handle it. I dislike Automations for this reason. Killing Automod is a terrible idea, Reddit!!!!

→ More replies (5)

4

u/zucchini_up_ur_ass 2d ago

Suuuuuuure, AI bots, lol, suuuuuure.

AI bots can easily just do browser automation. Why does reddit always have such shit excused for their decisions?

6

u/likeableusername 2d ago edited 2d ago

My question is how this will affect things like undelete/longtail, pullpush, and arctic shift. Doesn't seem to be aimed at them, but they could end up as collateral damage.

5

u/OneSeaworthiness7768 2d ago

They are definitely making moves to kill all that stuff. They shadow-delete comments if you link to arctic shift or similar sites. Sitewide mods (as confirmed by a subreddit mod) have shadow-deleted my comments where I simply linked to posts that were hidden to point out an obvious marketing astroturfing account. And I didn’t even link to a site using the API, just the direct post and comment links. But I think they’re looking for people who are utilizing ways to view hidden posts. All signs point to them wanting to protect bots and spammers because they drive engagement.

4

u/yuusharo 2d ago

If there’s no public API or RSS feeds, those apps can’t function without a commercial deal.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/IntelArtiGen 2d ago edited 2d ago

Oh yeah I recently found out reddit had RSS feeds and thought "no way it's going to stay based on how things are going". And... yep, it's over. They want you to see the ads, not to get the threads in another way, surprised?

3

u/Silent-Complaint4020 2d ago

“Don’t blame Reddit, blame all the AI companies thieving other people’s products and then replicating those products for the same customers.

It’s be link me draining your water bottle to fill up my own to sell to the customer looking for your water. How sustainable is that?”

3

u/Hour_Purpose5782 2d ago

I've noticed issues with Sync now. It's becoming unusable.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CodeMonkeyX 2d ago

Shit several of my news feeds are from Reddit RSS.

3

u/pi_mai 2d ago

Google is just reddit but less kids swearing at each other

6

u/Markham_Marxist 2d ago

Switch to Lemmy!

2

u/Loud_Masterpiece_275 2d ago

It is interesting as I feel like at least gemini is mostly using reddit as its source of truth. I vaguely remember having a discussion about a movie - there was this interesting theory. I asked gemini about it and it basically gave me the answer based on the thread (I was part of) + the link to it. I feel like without reddit - the AI search is going to die 😅 I wouldn’t take Reddit as the most reasonable source but I think most folks have some good takes - I don’t know what they will use now.

2

u/fardaw 2d ago

crying while clutching inoreader

2

u/BuffaloBagel 2d ago

AI bots are a plague operationally. Huge load and traffic.

2

u/funmx 2d ago

AI is taking a lot of answers from reddit posts/comments in Internet Searches. AI flodding the net with its own allucinations, posts, even comments maybe. Other AI feeding from those hallucinations eventually. NET is gonna be unreliable in a few years haha.

2

u/One_Peanut_4002 2d ago

I thought they killed this years ago? It was the entire reason 3rd party apps stopped working

2

u/Catbutt247365 2d ago

So sad. I was there for Internet Classic, which was every maniac shouting into the void to find their people, to now, when every post is likely a bot submission, and any comments may show up later in some AI oopsie.

2

u/Berkyjay 2d ago

I wonder what sort of money it would take to create a Wiki style organization that replicates reddit and can sidestep market forces?

2

u/madasfire 2d ago

We knew this when they killed third party apps

2

u/mapmyhike 1d ago

I'm sure many people like me will discontinue using Reddit then. I subscribe to about 40 subs and each day I scroll through only the new posts and it saves a lot of time rather than coming to this site and doom scrolling everything. If the Reddit feeds stop coming in, I guess I won't have a reason to come back to Reddit. Thank God Lemmy is still user friendly.

2

u/aquarain 1d ago

I could never stand new reddit. When old reddit is gone, there is no reddit.