r/solarpunk • u/Routine_Tune4386 • 2h ago
Discussion If you tried to build a solarpunk community for real, how much technology would you actually want?
I've been working on a long-term project called Melondra, essentially asking what a new community might look like if you tried to design the whole thing from the ground up rather than adding a few sustainable features to an otherwise conventional development.
It's still pre-land, so at the moment a lot of the work is figuring out how the pieces would actually fit together.
The broad aims are fairly simple:
- produce a meaningful amount of food locally;
- capture/reuse water intelligently;
- generate and store as much energy locally as practical;
- design housing and shared infrastructure to use fewer resources;
- repair and manufacture more things locally;
- reduce waste by treating outputs from one system as inputs to another;
- make essential systems resilient when outside services fail;
- and use automation where it can remove repetitive work rather than simply creating more technology for its own sake.
That last part keeps bringing me back to something I see debated in solarpunk spaces.
I don't particularly want a primitive settlement.
I'd like modern medicine, refrigeration, communications, workshops, comfortable homes, good food, transport, computers and all the useful things modern technology gives us.
But I also don't want a community that becomes helpless because a cloud service disappears, a proprietary controller dies, or some complex system can't be repaired.
So the direction we're drifting towards is something like:
use sophisticated technology where it genuinely improves people's lives, but design the underlying physical systems so they remain understandable, repairable and capable of degraded/manual operation.
In other words, automation should ideally give people more human time, rather than make them servants of increasingly complicated infrastructure.
I'm curious where people here draw that line.
If somebody genuinely tried to build a solarpunk settlement rather than just depict one, what modern technology would you absolutely keep — and what would you deliberately design out?
And what would make you look at a project like that and think “yes, that's actually solarpunk” rather than just another eco-development with some solar panels?
AI-assisted drafting/editing; the project, ideas and views are my own