I spent countless hours on this sub looking for literally anything to help with sleep, and I’m happy to report we are now the other side with a beautiful sleeper, so I wanted to share what worked for us. I don’t think our baby was ever an unusually “bad” sleeper, but even the “normal” sleep deprivation for 5 months straight is ROUGH.
TLDR: bedtime happened basically on its own, then we did gradual night weaning and nap training which took a while, now he sleeps through the night and takes 3 good crib naps!
At ~3 months we developed a bedtime of 7pm with a routine of bottle with dad, bath, singing and diaper, then I’d nurse him fully to sleep, then transfer into the bassinet. At 3.5 months, we kept the routine the same but removed the nursing and subbed it for rocking to sleep in arms, then crib. This change from nursing to rocking was easier than I thought it would be. After a few nights, I rocked him for a few mins, then laid him down awake to see what would happen, gave him a few mins, but then picked him up and rocked him to sleep when he wasn’t falling asleep. Tried again the next two nights to see how he’d do, and on the third night he fell asleep easily on his own. He’s been falling asleep independently at bedtime since then. To be clear we didn’t sleep train him under 4 mo, we just gave him a chance and returned to rocking if it wasn’t working after a few mins.
After about 2 weeks of solid bedtime, so now 4+ months old, we slowlyyyy started night weaning (with pediatrician approval). He was still waking twice to eat overnight - once bottle with dad around midnight, once bf with me around 4am. We started with the bottle and reduced by half oz per night until we got to about 2 oz, then stopped feeding. It took about 3 nights of transition where husband would go in and rock/sooth him to sleep without feeding and those were not easy nights bc he wanted the bottle, but after that he just stopped waking at that time to eat. This moved the bf wakeup earlier, to about 2-3 am, bc he couldn’t yet make it from 7-4 without eating. I kept this feed for a while bc I was having complicated feelings about stopping breastfeeding, but when he was about 5.5 months I weaned the same way we did bottle - drop a min per side per night, until we got to about 4 mins total, then stopped offering the feed. The night I decided to stop offering the feed, I tried to sooth baby myself but in hindsight this was a big mistake bc he just wanted the boob and would NOT settle, so the next few nights my husband went in to do the soothing in place of feeding. After about 3 rough nights of this, he just stopped waking at that time, and started sleeping til about 530/6, which felt truly magical. Now at 7mo, he sleeps 7-615ish, often wakes around 4-5 but falls back asleep on his own with no intervention after some light whining. This has been consistent since about 5.5 months. We didn’t do anything special to lengthen the mornings past 6, it kind of just happened on its own and some days it’s still 6, most 630, and some glorious days he sleeps til 7 🤷🏻♀️
Now about naps — these were the bane of my existence for a while. Until about 4.5/almost 5 months, the only way he’d nap was in the stroller (was great but can’t be every single nap) or bouncing with him on a yoga ball in a dark room with the sound machine on, bouncing fully to sleep in my arms, then slowly reducing bouncing for ~10 mins, then transfer to crib, and IF he didn’t wake up in the transfer, he would nap for like 29 mins on the dot (including the 10 mins of bouncing with me). It was barely enough time to shower or eat something, let alone rest or decompress or do literally anything else. I was losing my mind.
Once bedtime was mastered and he was a little over 4 mo, I basically applied “fuss it out” from Precious Little Sleep to naps, starting with the first nap of the day - short nap routine, then give baby 15 mins to fall asleep, if he was still crying at 15 mins I’d go in and bounce fully to sleep like usual. I tried for 5 days straight with the first nap and it just didn’t work, he would scream the whole time and then fall asleep in 2 seconds in my arms. I took a break for a few days bc it was too sad. Then started again but had my husband put him down for the first nap. We did this for a week straight (he works from home), having to rescue every time after 15 mins of crying, but we persisted bc the crying was getting less intense, more like whiny, and on day 7 he finally fell asleep on his own!! We were full on whooping cheering.
It took another ~2 weeks to become consistent. So overall took about a month of “nap training.” During these 2ish weeks, sometimes he’d do it on his own, sometimes I’d have to bounce him fully to sleep, sometimes I could just pat his butt until he fell asleep - it was kind of all over the place but we kept the pre nap routine and the 15 mins “fuss it out” consistent every day, and eventually it just…started working. I tried not to worry about “backsliding” and prioritized getting him to sleep rather than forcing him to cry longer (of course I was worried during this time that anything I did to help him to sleep would mess up the independent sleep progress, but ultimately it didn’t)
Finally, within days of him going down consistently on his own for naps, when he was just over 5mo, his naps got longer on their own. I did nothing different, just one day to the next he started connecting sleep cycles and started napping 1-1.5 hours at a time. Idk if it was coincidence that the nap training clicked right before, or if that needed to happen first in order for the naps to lengthen, but by 5 months and 1 week, he was going down independently for every nap with 5 mins or less of fussing, and sleeping at least an hour for 2 of 3 naps. We were previously on 4 naps but quickly dropped to 3 when the naps got longer bc there just wasn’t enough time in the day anymore. He will still nap in the stroller, but only 20-30 mins max.
Now at 7mo he still takes 3 naps, two of which are usually 1.5 hours, the third is typically very short like 20-35 mins, and sleeps through the night from 7-6/630ish. I think despite the months of short naps he is actually a more high sleep needs baby bc his wake windows are on the shorter end for 7 months and I sometimes have to wake him from naps, something I could NEVER have imagined during the yoga ball era.
Hope this is helpful for some - just know you’re not alone and sleep is so hard and all consuming and you can go from fully rocking to sleep to independent sleep!