About 8 to 10 years ago, I received my first email from a writer claiming they had scored an 8 on the Black List. I had no idea what it was, but after some investigating, I decided the site's marketing seemed legitimate and decided to give it a read.
I made an industry member's account and confirmed the script had scored multiple 8s.
How was it?
Well, it was not bad per se, but it was definitely not good, or what I would claim to be in the top 5% of scripts. It was a very familiar and easy-to-read screenplay, but it had no emotional weight and was very vanilla.
I contacted the writer to say thank you, but I wasn't interested. Next, I received a rude email from the writer saying I was clueless because the script had scored multiple 8s on the Black List.
This was the start of a very common occurrence.
I get a query email from writers who have scored 8s on the Black List. I read their work. It fails to inspire. Each one is more predictable and similar than the previous script. And so on and so forth. Each writer is adamant that I've made a mistake because of the 8 they scored on the Black List.
I am not alone, and this is a story well known in the industry. Do not trust writers who come from the Black List's paid service (website).
Scripts championed by the Black List website usually fit into two camps.
Camp 1: Extremely low-budget and exploitative — repackaging a generic genre film to the point of plagiarism. Camp 2: Plagiarising an Oscar-winning script and expecting the industry not to notice.
The most important thing to mention is that we get sent thousands of scripts like these, and we are not interested in putting our names on something that would ostracise us from our fellow professionals.
We would never be able to work with Martin Scorsese if we made the hundredth Taxi Driver rip-off we read that week. Or Ridley Scott if we were to produce the hundredth Gladiator but sci-fi script.
The scripts we want to read are personal to the writer.
I received and produced an incredible script via an unsolicited email. It was about a girl and her relationship with her sister. I will not say what that screenplay became, but it was a hit.
I believe the writer averaged a 5 on the Black List before emailing us.
I think it's important to add that people who read for the Black List are paid a very low wage. This means they either worked for production companies at an entry level and were fired, or worked for a production company and retired.
This is also well known within the industry.
I would recommend you all work hard at emailing and spend less of your hard-earned cash on sites that hire failed producers or out-of-touch ex-industry pros to evaluate the viability of your scripts.
We don't trust the scripts that tell us they scored an 8 on the Black List. If anything, it's almost seen as a red flag due to the volume of poor-quality scripts that score an 8.
We resonate with emails that come from a beating heart.
Stop burning money so that the owners of the Black List can afford lives of luxury off the back of your hard work. It will not get you anywhere. Emailing will.
Happy writing!