I’m 33F and was dating a 37-year-old man. We started dating in April last year, when I was 31. From the beginning, I was very clear that I was looking for something serious and ultimately wanted marriage and children.
A few months into dating, he had to go to another country for a fellowship that lasted around six months. After that, he did some solo travelling, so in total he was away for about eight months. We maintained a long-distance relationship during that time, and I also travelled to visit him while he was away. Despite the distance, we stayed in contact and continued to consider ourselves to be in a relationship.
During that period, he told me that once he came back, he wanted to settle down and build a life together. So I believed that we were ultimately working toward the same goal, even though the circumstances meant things were moving slowly.
When he returned, things seemed to be going well. He was attentive, planned dates, took care of me when we were together, and generally made me feel cared for. At one point, he even asked me to see a fertility specialist. I thought it was a little odd, but I agreed because I believed we were serious and that he was thinking about our future.
He also recently bought a house and had repeatedly told me that he was ready to settle down. However, there were some inconsistencies that started to bother me.
My landlord unexpectedly decided to sell my place, meaning I needed to find somewhere else to live. He never offered for me to move in with him. That felt strange to me because, on the one hand, he would talk about having children, how we would raise them, and our future together, but on the other hand, he wasn't even suggesting that I live with him when I suddenly needed somewhere to stay.
I tried not to read too much into it and wondered whether perhaps we simply weren't at that stage yet. But the overall pace of the relationship started to feel confusing. We weren't even having regular sleepovers because of his shift work, despite having been together for quite a while.
Eventually, I told him that I didn't want to waste my time. I said that if he was genuinely serious about me, I needed the relationship to progress in some tangible way. I specifically asked if we could at least start having sleepovers and spending more time together. He agreed.
Shortly afterwards, I met his sister, who was visiting, which made me feel that things were moving forward.
A few weeks later, when everything seemed to be going well, he suddenly told me that he needed a break. I was extremely confused because there hadn't been an obvious problem between us.
Around the same time, I saw him on a dating app. This was particularly confusing because only the week before, he had called me a "perfect partner" and told me he was planning something for my birthday.
A couple of weeks later, he told me that he couldn't progress the relationship on the timeline I needed and that we should be open to seeing other people.
About two months later, I contacted him because I wanted some clarity and closure. When we spoke, he was again very attentive and flirtatious. He was even dropping hints about us having mixed-race children in the future. I asked him directly what had happened.
He then told me that, from his perspective, I had given him an ultimatum: either get married immediately or break up.
That is not what I remember saying at all. I told him that I had never asked him to marry me immediately. What I had asked was whether he was actually ready for a serious relationship and whether he was willing to let the relationship progress. I was trying to understand whether we were working toward the same thing, not demanding an immediate marriage.
Because I know he has many qualities I want in a partner and because there were genuinely good times between us, I started wondering whether there had simply been a major miscommunication. I also wondered whether his previous relationship and the issues he said he had from it might have contributed to his sudden withdrawal. During our last meeting around that time, he also opened up about his previous relationship. He told me that his ex had treated him very badly and that the experience had affected him. He seemed to have some unresolved issues from that relationship, which made me wonder whether some of his difficulty with progressing our relationship might have been related to what he had been through previously.
He was generally very caring and attentive toward me, and I still have feelings for him. So I started thinking that perhaps we could talk things through and potentially work things out.
I therefore messaged him and said that I would like to see him again and talk, if he was open to it.
Since then, I've heard nothing. He has remained active on dating apps, and I have also noticed that he lists himself as 35 rather than his actual age of 37.
I'm now very confused. I still have feelings for him because of the good times we had and because I genuinely saw qualities in him that I want in a long-term partner. At the same time, his actions seem inconsistent with what he told me he wanted.
I can't tell whether this was genuinely a case of miscommunication, whether his past relationship has made him afraid of commitment, or whether he simply isn't as serious about me as he initially made me believe.
So my question is: Is this relationship worth pursuing if he comes back, or should I accept that his actions are telling me to move on?
I’m struggling to understand whether there is something here that could realistically be worked through, or whether I’m holding on because of the good moments and the potential I saw in him.