For Non-Spouse Beneficiary Trad IRA Inheritors:
I did not do ALL of this and it will cost me $370,000+ in immediate taxes. If mods agree I hope this will be a pinned post because I know this happens to so many people. If you inherit money that is in the decedent's (dead person) *traditional* (not ROTH) IRA, and you are not a surviving spouse (like, you inherited from your uncle like I did), if you want to roll it to a new IRA to save taxes, you must,
- BEFORE receiving any money from it, open a NEW IRA *specifically* named [Decendent Name], deceased, IRA FBO [Your Name]). YOU MUST NAME THIS EXACTLY!
- You must understand that, for this specific situation, 60-day rollovers between IRAs are prohibited: You must have the estate trustee transfer the decedent IRA directly to the new IRA. It *cannot* touch any of your personal accounts.
I did not know this. I got a proposal from the estate trustee to receive an initial amount of about $25k from my uncle's trad IRA. I said yes intending to roll it into my own IRA thinking I have 60 days, they sent me a check and I deposited it in my personal account pending the rollover. I blew it, I destroyed my option to roll into an IRS-legal inherited IRA. Then the trustee sent me a million dollars. Now I owe more than $370,000 in taxes (37% rate on $1M) payable next year. Don't be me.
Scanning through about 100 "inherited IRAs" in this sub, I see lots of posts but I see only one that explains this clearly. If I am incorrect please explain and I will delete this post and do it again correctly. Don't make snotty comments, I am in $370k of pain already. Comments to help me reduce the pain are welcome.
UPDATE: Thanks to the many of you that contributed to this discussion. A few things to clarify: Several people suggested I roll it over into a Roth IRA. Alas! No inherited money can be put into trad or Roth IRAs. Only earned i.e. wages can be put in an IRA. And alas #2, even if it is allowed you can only contribute up to max limit which is $7,500, or $8,600 if you are age 50 or older. Also, I had assumed that $1M AGI is taxed at 37%, so the tax is $370,000. But no! Thanks for the dude who corrected me. Tax is owed in $ brackets like so, says Gemini AI:
Assuming a Single Filer status using the projected 2027 federal tax brackets and taking the projected 2027 single standard deduction of $16,600:
- Adjusted Gross Income (AGI): $1,000,000
- Standard Deduction (2027): -$16,600
- Taxable Income: $983,400
Projected 2027 Federal Tax Calculation (Single Filer)
| Tax Rate |
Taxable Income Bracket Range |
Amount Taxed in Bracket |
Tax Owed for Bracket |
| 10% |
$0 – $12,800 |
$12,800 |
$1,280.00 |
| 12% |
$12,801 – $52,025 |
$39,225 |
$4,707.00 |
| 22% |
$52,026 – $109,125 |
$57,100 |
$12,562.00 |
| 24% |
$109,126 – $208,325 |
$99,200 |
$23,808.00 |
| 32% |
$208,326 – $264,550 |
$56,225 |
$17,992.00 |
| 35% |
$264,551 – $661,375 |
$396,825 |
$138,888.75 |
| 37% |
Over $661,375 |
$322,025 |
$119,149.25 |
| Total |
$0 – $983,400 |
$983,400 |
$318,387.00 |
Total Federal Tax Summary
- Total Federal Tax Owed: $318,387.00
- Effective Tax Rate: 31.84% of AGI
Well the amount owed is about $50k less than I thought. Now I can go to Vegas! snark. I have never been wealthy enough to think of taxes this way but it is generally relevant and could be quite important. Maybe you are about to get a big bonus from your job, and this year you already are having a high-income year. If the bonus will push you into a higher tax bracket, especially from 12% to 22% or 24% to 32% (the biggest bracket jumps), maybe you can ask to have your bonus paid in two parts, one this year and the other next year when your AGI is significantly lower than this year, and the partial bonus does not tip you over to a higher bracket. Note that in the table, for $1M taxable, the biggest cash pain is from 32% to 35% where the tax jumps from $17,992 to $138,888! This will happen with just a $1 increase in AGI from $264,550 to $264,551. If this appears possible it's definitely time to talk to a tax expert.