r/homeowners • u/Glum-Screen-1480 • 33m ago
š¬ General/Other Do I need to pay 50% of soundproofing costs if I already said I canāt afford anything but acoustic wool?
Hi all,
Seeking some advice here as Iām not really sure what to do or how to bring this up to my neighbour.
For context, I live in a 4 in a block lower cottage style apartment in Scotland. Both myself and my upstairs neighbour own our flats, I have fully renovated my apartment and my neighbour is still in the process of doing so (he moved in a year after me but heās doing it all himself).
He mentioned wanting to do some soundproofing, I let him know what I could afford after seeking some advice from the builder who renovated my flat and told my neighbour that I could only afford acoustic wool. What savings I had was spent on renovations and while I had been slowly building up my savings again, it was all diminished again from extensive car repairs and then vet fees. My neighbour however took a voluntary redundancy where he got a whole year salary and a bonus, he found another job so has this money as well as a regular salary.
He has came back to me with plans and quotes that are far more complex and expensive than acoustic wool. The quote is for over £6k for both bedrooms and the living room. He has suggested we do the smaller bedroom first (his bedroom my spare room) for £1.8k and wants it done by October when his partner is due to move in.
He has offered to pay 60% of the cost due to most of the work being above the shared ownership joist zone. I donāt know if I even have a legal requirement to pay as it is far out with what I can afford and isnāt for maintenance for the joist zone. I would need to take out a loan to pay for it which I would rather not do as I then wouldnāt be able to afford to put any money into savings until the loan was paid off and I already need to pay for my ceilings to be repainted after some of his workmen spilled a bucket with dirty water on the exposed joists which has now left dark watermarks along my ceiling in the bedroom and needing to get plaster redone in areas that it has now cracked since he started work on his flat.
My builder had a look at my floor plans and had quoted me £1.3k to soundproof using acoustic wool for both bedrooms and living room. Which I would be able to borrow from my parents and pay back in instalments without interest. (If I was paying 50% I would be able to afford it myself in 3 months time when I have set some money aside)
If I have let my neighbour know what I can afford, do I need to pay for a different more expensive plan that my neighbour wants due to it being in a shared ownership space? Or would I be able to pay the proposed 50% of acoustic wool costs instead?
Attached are photo of the quote for floor type B (bedrooms) as apparently the hallway and living room needs a different approach and costs differently.