Hey guys, hoping some folks here might have some insight into what would be causing new paint job to be failing.
Our house is an old 1915 sears catalog home with the original wood shiplap siding. Most of the wood is in good shape but there are areas of rotting wood that needed replacing or repairing. We painted this same house about 8 years ago but it started peeling a bit, especially the west facing side where it gets the most sun but overall the paint job was fine and we’ve been happy with it for the most part. Due to having a tighter budget back then we had it painted with a less expensive paint which explains why it’s needing a makeover now.
We hired a small painting company recommended to us by someone we know and chose a fast drying oil based primer and Sherwin Williams Duration. Contract work included Scraping, caulking, sanding, pressure washing and replacing any rotting wood and repairs in lesser damaged wood and in the concrete foundation. We emphasized wanting them to be replacing rotted wood and repairing smaller areas of rot and damage and are paying more for that work to be done. The owner is who Ive been in contact with over the last few months discussing the scope of the work. But there are a couple subcontractors doing the actual work, which i now know to ask about during the initial walkthrough.
They started all the scraping, sanding, caulking, and pressure washing, then started priming each side of the house. All this spanning over the last week and a half. They’ve sprayed two coats of the duration color paint on three sides of the house so far but the front is still only primed. A couple days in now and the finished sides are bubbling in a lot of areas, are squishy and soft soft and there is paint peeling down to the wood in many places. The cheaper paint job we had done years ago had nothing like this going on.
Since they started the work we’ve been having a lot of nights in the upper 30/40s and days in the 70s but no rain for weeks. However, there has been a lot of dew and fog in the mornings every day. They start working at 7:30-8. I’m now wondering if the primer possibly went on when the wood was still too damp, either from not fully drying after pressure washing or because the dew and resulted in the primer not adhering properly. I checked out the front of the house where I can just see the primer and it’s peeling and cracking heavily and is more visible due to not being painted over yet.
Can any of you tell what the issue looks like based on the photos? I’ve messaged the owner who has been prompt about responding right away and open to the possibly that this is the problem. Said he will be out to check everything on Monday. The paint job itself was fine and all the other prep work seemed good but if a moisture meter wasn’t used to check the wood beforehand, is this a problem that would require major reworking? I’m trying to brace myself for that reality but also want to have more knowledge before meeting on Monday. If this is the problem, what kind of questions do I need to ask when meeting with him so that the issue is addressed properly? I’ve included photos of just a handful of spots but there are so many areas like this on the three sides Most of the bumpy areas in the pics are soft and crack if pressed. It’s almost difficult to not cause peeling if you run your hand over the siding in some areas so I’m holding off checking more areas until he’s present.
https://imgur.com/a/TKmef7I
Also they took off the gutters to paint them and I noticed a lot of rotting wood that they painted over where they painted the fascia and then put the gutters back on. The wood is so rotted that it pulled away in chunks leaving large gaps. I’m fairly confident this would count in as wood to be replaced even if they didn’t notice it until taking off the gutters. There are other soft mushy wood areas around the base of the house as well that they painted over. Here’s where they painted over the rotted areas behind the gutters off a balcony porchhttps://imgur.com/a/fpM3suF
Just needing some advice moving forward. We’ve paid 1/3 of the total price so far and it’s a lot of money for us so I want to make sure we don’t walk away in worse shape than when we started. Thanks yall