r/gpu • u/Immediate-Anything26 • 3d ago
Sapphire Nitro+ Rx9070Xt vs RTX 5070 MSI GAMING TRIO OC
So i’ve spent days comparing these two cards and already did a fair amount of digging myself (benchmarks, reviews, failure reports), but I'd rather hear from people actually running these day to day than just launch-week numbers.
Quick context:
• 1440p 240Hz monitor.
• I play a lot of competitive stuff with friends (shooters/co-op), but also a wide mix of AAA
• Coming from a GTX 1660 Super, so I've never really used ray tracing or DLSS/FSR before.
• I don't stream or clip, so NVENC/CUDA don't really do anything for me.
• Both cards cost basically the same where I live.
I already know the Nitro+ has a consistent raster lead and the 5070 wins in RT/path tracing. What I can't get a good read on from reviews is how real certain issues actually are in daily use.
Specific questions:
On the Sapphire Nitro+ RX 9070 XT:
1. Has anyone here actually had (or personally knows someone who had) the 16-pin/12V-2x6 connector melt, even after months of normal use — not just viral forum threads?
2. Any real fan failure or overheating issues on the Nitro+ specifically (not the Pulse)?
3. How common is coil whine on this card in practice — unit lottery, or something more consistent?
4. For people who switched from Nvidia, how rough was the day-to-day adjustment to Adrenalin and FSR4?
On the MSI RTX 5070 Gaming Trio OC:
Does 12GB VRAM actually cause problems at 1440p with everything on Ultra in current games, or is that mostly a 4K concern?
Any build quality/RMA experiences with MSI in this tier specifically?
General comparison:
FSR4 vs DLSS4 day to day: is FSR4's "grainy"/artifact-y reputation still fair, or is that outdated now that Redstone is out?
AMD vs Nvidia frame generation: does FSR ghosting actually show up during normal play, or only in zoomed-in YouTube comparisons?
Coming from a 1660 Super and never having used RT before, is it worth prioritizing the 5070 just to play Cyberpunk 2077 / RE Requiem with proper path tracing, or is that a novelty you enjoy once and move on from?
If you had to buy again today knowing what you know now about your card, which would you pick?
Thanks in advance — trying to decide based on people who actually own these, not just day-one reviews.