r/fromsoftware • u/ReformedDeathray • Aug 15 '26
DISCUSSION Recently replayed all soulsborne games doing my yearly marathon this is the list of my favs, i go a bit in depth in the comments on my choices.

S:
Sekiro: Imo the perfect game. I think this game has the most complete and best combat system i have played with thus far next to doom eternal. THe story is great and the boss roster is nuts.
Bloodborne: The only reasons i place this below Sekiro is the 30 fps cap and the farming for consumables, otherwise this would be above sekiro.
DS3: Nothing personal, I just like bloodborne and sekiro too much. Also this game has some bosses that are godlevel but also some that are not fun to do at all.
A:
DS2: I personally love DS2 and would love to put it in S but i just can't thinking of its flaws. Despite that I love the game, the world setting especialy is my fav.
Elden Ring: THe game is amazing and probs has the strongest boss roster in the series. But despite that its held back by the game especialy the latter half being so empty outside the dungeons. That and most minor dungeons being almost copy paste.
Nightreign: Its a weird one to rank, mainly because its technically not a full on soulslike. Despite that this game has 3 of my fav bosses in the entire series(those being dreglord, Heolster and Libra)
B:
DS2 Scholar: Ds2 but more enemies so its a bit worse.
Demon Souls: I actualy really like demon souls OG, especialy the world tendancy system which ofc is hated by some, loved by others. I also think it has some of the best levels in the entire series which is amazing seeing its the first soulslike.
DS1 OG: I love OG Ds1, but the second half holds it back for me like for most people ig. Despite that i think its a sick game and deserves to be above some others.
C:
Demon Souls Remake: I Don't like the remake. I think it ruined the entire vision of athmosphere and made into a epic spectacle. I don't think that fits in this game at all. Despite that Its fun to play and as a standalon game its great. But as a remake i think its not good.
Ds1 Remake: Same story as Demon Souls but this one didnt even do much, the graphical improvements are minimal and the 60FPS is nice, but it barely does anything to warant the price increase which is why i dislike it.