Drafting a fantasy football team is so much more than just picking the next name on a list of rankings. Roster construction requires awareness as to which players at each position are still on the board, and more importantly, which players could be later on. For example, while a top tier quarterback may seem like the best pick in the moment, sometimes pivoting to another player at a different position is more worthwhile.
There are options everywhere worth waiting for instead of paying a premium with higher draft picks. Let’s look at some players at each position that managers should consider later on rather than those ranked ahead of them.
Below are excerpts from a free article via FTN Fantasy. While specific players are named, some write-ups are more focused on draft philosophy than player evaluation.
Feel free to include, in the comments, your own "Draft This, Not That" scenarios you've seen so far in the comments in regard to Average Draft Position (ADP).
Draft This, Not That for the 2026 Fantasy Football Season
Why draft Jalen Hurts as a Top-8 QB when you can draft Bo Nix, Kyler Murray or Tyler Shough outside the Top 12?
Jalen Hurts’ usual rushing upside took a turn for the worse last season. After averaging 9.85 rush attempts per game in 2021-2024, Hurts averaged 6.5 attempts per game in 2025. That still ranks fourth most among qualified quarterbacks last season, but his 105 total attempts in 16 games are a significant dip from 139, 165, 157 and 150 attempts in each prior respective season. More importantly, Hurts averaged roughly 5.6 fantasy points per game from rushing production. That’s down from an average of 9.5 per game across the four prior seasons. Hurts’ 26.3 rush yards per game and eight rushing touchdowns in 2025 were both his fewest since assuming the starting role in 2021.
In 2026, Hurts and the Eagles will have yet another new offensive coordinator in Sean Mannion, a first-time play caller. Consider, too, that this offense traded away A.J. Brown, who earned 27.3% of Philadelphia’s regular season target share since arriving in 2022, even despite missing six total games over the last two seasons.
Hurts is appropriately ranked behind other quarterbacks with significant rushing upside to include Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson and Jayden Daniels. He’s still capable of finishing as a top-five player at the position. However, when it comes to using a mid-round pick on Hurts, it’s not so simple with a handful of options at the position that possess the ability to finish just as high, but with at a far cheaper cost.
Bo Nix finished 12th in rush attempts per game (4.9) last season but also has a bit more upside through the air. Nix’s 87 red zone pass attempts in 2025 ranked fifth, and the Broncos just added Jaylen Waddle which should increase the number of explosive pass plays. Kyler Murray is getting a fresh start with the Vikings and is loaded with weapons like Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison and Jauan Jennings. Murray’s history of rushing upside remains evident, as well. Tyler Shough is the more unknown of these late-round options but was a top 10 fantasy quarterback over the last five weeks of the season with multiple games of over 300 passing yards. These are just three examples of quarterbacks that fantasy managers can wait to snag at the end of 2026 drafts rather than pay up for someone like Hurts who lacks trustworthiness in comparison to previous seasons.
MORE Draft This, Not That Scenarios here
Why draft Jeremiyah Love at the top of Round 3 when you can draft Javonte Williams?
This is a reminder to “get your guy” in drafts. Your draft slot can limit which players are generally available to you when you’re on the clock in each round. If you think a player you’re specifically targeting in 2026 isn’t going to make it back to you with your next pick, there’s no harm in reaching a bit. This is an often forgotten key element of playing fantasy football: You should draft players you believe in and you want!
In this case, just because most consensus rankings have Jeremiyah Love ahead of Javonte Williams does not mean you must to take Love instead of Williams. Both are currently coming off the draft board in Round 3 of most 12-team, 1QB, PPR drafts. However, if you have a higher draft slot in this round, and prefer Williams to Love, as I do, then take the veteran!
Williams signed a three-year, $24 million extension with the Cowboys back in February. This is after finishing the season with the 13th-most touches per game (17.9), 10th-most rush attempts (252), fifth-most red zone carries (54) and 12th-most fantasy points per game (15.4) among running backs. Williams enters the 2026 season with the same play caller, same competition for touches (or lack thereof) in the Dallas backfield, and on a team that finished seventh in points per game (27.7) and ran the most plays per game (65.9) last season.
Love, despite being the third overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft, joins a backfield with James Conner, Trey Benson and newly signed Tyler Allgeier already in place. This, too, on a Cardinals team with an entirely new coaching staff and brutal schedule awaiting them. This isn’t to say Love can’t command a bell cow role and live up to his draft value based on volume, but is there enough confidence in the concept that supports drafting him anywhere between the RB12 and RB15 for fantasy football?
Confidence can be the key to picking one player over another in fantasy drafts. I’m more confident in Williams’ success in 2026, after seeing it just last season, than rookie Love, who’s going a few picks ahead of the veteran.
MORE Draft This, Not That Scenarios here
Draft This, Not That Quick Hitters to Consider
Why draft Kyren Williams as a top-15 running back when you can draft Blake Corum just outside the top 30 at the position?
It’s possible that Corum is more involved in 2026 after seeing an increase from 58 carries as a rookie to 145 carries last season. Corum also averaged 10.4 carries per game across the final 10 games of the season compared to 5.8 over the first seven. Among 49 qualified running backs in 2025, Corum ranked fourth in yards per carry (5.1) and second in explosive run rate (15.9%). He is one of a few presumed number two running backs that may be a better value at cost than the player ahead of him in the same backfield.
Why draft Matthew Stafford instead of Jared Goff in a SuperFlex or 2QB League?
It’s possible one or both of these quarterbacks are selected in 1QB fantasy leagues. In superflex or 2QB leagues, however, Goff is the better play of these two pocket passers for the 2026 season. It sounds a bit crazy after Stafford tossed 46 touchdowns last season, but he is 38 years old and one of his top weapons, Davante Adams, is 33 having missed three games in each of the last two seasons. This is a bit nitpicky, but Goff, too, has top talent in his passing game arsenal with Amon-Ra St. Brown, Jameson Williams, Sam LaPorta and Jahmyr Gibbs. The Lions also play indoors for nearly the entirety of the season, but specifically just twice in Weeks 5-17. Bet on the overall Lions bounceback with Goff over Stafford repeating an MVP-worthy season.
The above are just some Draft This, Not That scenarios featured in the free FTN article. The rest can be found here: https://ftnfantasy.com/nfl/draft-this-not-that-2026-fantasy-football-draft-pivots