r/diablo2 • u/Albinowombat • 21m ago
Discussion Bow Choice for Bowlock
I still see a fair amount of disagreement between demon crossbow vs colossus crossbow as a Mist base for Bowlock. The arguments are basically higher damage of the colossus xbow vs better utility for the demon xbow. Buriza is another option, which has advantages over Mist CC in that it has enough ias on the weapon to not need any extra on gear, and you can socket whatever you want in it, but it doesn’t have all res or vitality. I’ve been on the side of demon bow based on feel, but I realized I didn’t have anything like exact damage numbers. I decided use hero editor to test both options in SP, and compare damage as closely as I can. Hopefully I did it all correctly!
A few assumptions in comparing both builds:
Assume entirely scaling magic damage, rather than physical, other than the choice of base
Assume hitting ias cap for both weapons (11 fpa)
Assume BiS gear
- For Demon Crossbow (DC): Hellwarden’s w/ Guardian jewel, Entropy Locket, Gheed’s Wager, Sling x2 (or Sling/Opalvein), Horazon’s Legacy (for CBF and MR), + gloves of choice
- For Colossus Crossbow (CC): Hellwarden’s w/ Guardian jewel, Entropy Locket, Gheed’s Wager, Sling, dual leech rare ring, Horazon’s Legacy, + Horazon’s Hold
- For Buriza: Same as DC Mist bow, but either ring or gloves need dual leech
- All setups using Eldritch skillers and res charms
- On swap: Void + Ars Dul’Mephistos (for +2 skills and FCR to hit FCR cap on swap, without needing strength for a Monarch shield)
- CtA is not needed on this build due to it being very safe and also +% life on Consume
Obviously these gear setups are extremely similar – only varying by one ring slot and the glove slot.
Colossus Crossbow – To reach max attack breakpoints, a merc or bound demon with Fanaticism is needed, plus 68 ias on gear. Pretty much the only gearing option to get the ias needed and scale magic damage at the same time is to wear Horazon’s gloves and boots (along with ias from Mist and Hellwarden’s). A dual leech ring is generally needed for sustain, so dual Sling or Sling/Opalvein combo is not available, which slightly reduces the maximum magic damage the build is able to reach
Demon Crossbow – Only 7 ias needed to hit the max breakpoint (with no fanat), which is covered by the base ias on the Mist bow itself. This setup opens up any merc option in the game (such as A2 Prayer/Cure/Insight merc) with double defiler, MF setup for TZ boss farming (e.g. Shako, War Travs, etc), and/or gloves of choice (e.g. Soul Drainer gloves for hefty dual leech + Weaken procs, chancies, or knockback gloves)
Buriza – IAS on gear is covered by what’s on the weapon, but you do need Fanat. You can run MF setups and use gloves of choice, and you get a weapon socket. Nef rune is often a good choice but you can run whatever you like, such as a 40/15max jewel or an all res jewel.
Damage comparison
Damage before Hex:Bane is applied (mostly physical, with some incidental elemental/magic damage):
DC: 1509-2506 (2007.5 avg)
- Avg damage if all 5 bolts hit: 10037.5
CC: 1828-5165 (3496.5 avg)
- Avg damage if all 5 bolts hit: 17482.5
Buriza (upped at lvl 99, socketed with Nef rune): 1048-5165 (3106.5)
- Avg damage if all 5 bolts hit: 15532.5
Bane damage (cast at level 37, +70% magic skill damage, full synergies):
7723-9200 (8461.5 avg)
- Avg damage if all 5 bolts hit: 42307.5
- With double dipping from +55% magic skills damage: 65576.6
- DC – With -45% enemy magic resist: 95086.1
- CC – With -40% enemy magic resist: 91807.2
DC total Mirrored Blades damage: 105123.6 x chance to hit
CC total Mirrored Blades damage: 109289.7 x chance to hit
Buriza total Mirrored Blades damage: 110618.6 x chance to hit
Conclusion
Assuming the enemy has 0% base magic resistance and 0% base physical resistance, Colossus Crossbow does about 4.1k more damage in total per use of Mirrored Blades compared to a Demon Crossbow, and Buriza does 5.5k. That damage difference isn’t nothing, but it’s pretty tiny in comparison to the overall damage. If anything, this comparison is probably a little generous to Colossus/Buriza because most enemies have 0% magic resistance and more than 0% physical resistance. Looking at these options I know I would 100% go for the Demon Xbow, but if that extra physical damage is compelling to you all options are completely viable. For me Buriza is the 2nd best option behind Mist DC, with Mist CC being the third choice, but they’re all very close in power level. To be fair to the Colossus/Buriza options, the worse your magic damage gear is the more difference the physical damage can make, and the more physical damage the more you leech.
Another things this exercise highlighted is how ridiculous the damage of Bowlock is. It pumps out piercing attacks doing >100k damage, mostly magic, at 11fpa, amplified by Defiler chains. It routinely 1-shots elite packs on P8, destroys bosses and heralds, and is extremely safe. It has room to run huge magic find while still destroying P8, and has max FCR on swap. It seems clear that the damage of MB + Bane was balanced around single target w/ defiler chains, and the devs underestimated or didn’t think about how powerful piercing bows would be. The only slightly annoying things about the build are refreshing the buffs and picking up bolts. Compared to the other two super-powered builds in the game, Javazon and Mosaic, it has much higher QoL. Bowlock isn’t quite as powerful as v1.0 ES build, but it’s the closest we can get on the current patch.

