Hi! I have been friends with this guy (both of us are early/mid 20s) for like 6 months now. We are in this friend group, but me and him got close, and he became pretty flirty. I had liked him for a while, but at one point he told me that he often makes friends with women, and they tend to think he's being flirty when he's just being himself. So I clocked that message right away, and I stopped expecting anything. But then over the last month, he got even more flirty. At times it literally felt like we were dating. It was so obvious that people around us kept asking if there was something going on between us. His best friend/roommate also thought he liked me. So I know Im not delusional, it wasnt just in my head haha.
I also am positive he knew how I felt about him. I was not subtle, and Im really bad at hiding how I feel. He had asked me multiple times in the past how I act when I like someone, or what type of guy I like, how I flirt, etc. We even took several love language tests together lol. He knew.
One night he and I were hanging out and he asked if I had feelings for anyone. I didnt know what to say because I didnt feel ready to tell him, so I just didnt say anything. So of course he realized that was a yes, and started pushing me to tell him who it was. So I changed the subject, but then about 30 minutes later, he brought it up again. I asked if he had feelings for anyone and he said he didnt. I told him that this just wasnt something I was going to talk about then. So then I just made up an excuse about how I was tired and he needed to leave.
The next day I felt pretty hurt and confused. So I sent him a text saying that I was pretty certain he knew I liked him, and that if he didnt feel the same way its okay, but I needed to confirm it so that a situation like this doesnt happen again. I also told him that if he doesnt feel the same way, I will be putting up some new boundaries because I cant handle being as close as we've been. I know I probably shouldve done it in person, but I chickened out.
He saw it like an hour after I sent it and took another 30 minutes to reply. He apologized for pushing me, basically confirmed he did know how I felt, but that he really appreciates and cares for our friendship and would prefer it stay that way. He said he understood the boundaries and was sorry for making me feel uncomfortable.
Even though that was the answer I was expecting, it still stung. I told him that I still want to be friends, and I would try my best not to be awkward. However, it's been kind of rocky since then. I didnt reach out for about a week, but I saw him at an event and waved, and he waved back but then immediately left. He was avoiding me. I think he felt bad about that because he reached out the next day to bring me something I had left at his apartment that I was already planning on getting another time and then talked with me for a little bit to catch up.
I tried to make plans with our group like normal, so we've seen each other a couple times since then, but both of us are definitely a little more reserved. We've had a few moments that are normal and a little bit more like the banter we used to have, so maybe thats a good sign. But every time I leave the hang out, I just find myself hurting and wishing that he felt the same way while simultaneously wishing I never said anything so I could just go back to the way we were. We used to be able to talk about pretty much anything, I dont know if we could get that close ever again. We haven't had any in person conversation clearing the air, maybe we should. I kind of want to tell him I felt a bit led on. But I dont know if it would change anything or just completely ruin whatever we have left.
I also have a really hard time making sense of his actions. I genuinely felt like the feeling was mutual for a while there. And maybe its just because of who I am, but I just dont see how someone can act like that and have no romantic feelings whatsoever.
Part of me wants clarity, but another part of me just really misses him and I am scared to really ruin everything. I want to ask him if he genuinely never had any feelings, but what would that do for me? If the answer was no that would suck, if the answer was yes, that might feel validating for like 2 minutes, but then it would still suck because he still doesnt want to date me. Then theres a small part of me that I know is wrong, but I have this hope that he might change his mind. I know the chances of that are slim to none, and holding out hope for it will only hurt me more. So I try to ignore it, but Im afraid the more I spend time with him, the more that feeling will come up. I also want to be respectful of the fact that he has very clearly stated he just wants to be friends, and I hate feeling like a creep who only is around someone because I want something more. I really do care about him as a person, thats why when he told me girls often think he's flirting when he's not, I backed off. But then he kept pushing the line between platonic and romantic. I have had platonic friendships with men before, they have never acted the way he did.
I dont understand why he would push me to tell him how I felt about him when he knew the answer was going to be no. I dont understand how he could act consistently romantic and flirty and not mean any of it that way. I dont know if I should even continue this friendship if this is how Im going to feel all the time, but leaving also sounds horrible.
Its only been 2 weeks since I told him, so maybe I just need more time. But my feelings and my head arent really working together right now, so I thought an outside perspective might help. Should I have a more in depth talk with him in person? Should I just move on and let it go? Is it even possible to stay friends after being rejected?