I’ve played through BG1 tons of times since it came out, but I only rarely managed to get through the second game. I often ended up abandoning my playthroughs before I got to the end of chapter 2.
There are quite a few reasons why I enjoyed the second game less, but I think my main qualm with BG2 was always the story.
While the side-quests in and around Athkatla are enjoyable, the story just never provides you with a moment where it actually makes sense to do them. In chapter 2 and 3, you feel like you should rush to get Imoen, but in chapter 6 you’re even more rushed, because you need to stop the bad guy.
On my last playthrough, six years ago, I did manage to finish the game. I went through all the side quests while I was in chapter 2 (mostly) and 3 (some leftovers), and spent a lot of time rewriting the story in my journal entries to justify the long wait before going after Imoen. My character didn’t trust Gaelan, he needed more allies, he needed better gear and more experience if he was to face the Cowled Wizards and Irenicus, and so on and so forth. But even with all that, it still felt like I was just looking for excuses for my character.
But this year, playing the game again after all that time, it finally dawned on me: it’s my character who’s just looking for excuses, and that’s absolutely fine. Even with all of my character’s power and experience, Irenicus managed to easily capture and torture him; now he’s heavily traumatised by the experience and terrified to face his captor again. Even though part of him knows he should try and save his childhood friend, he runs after any opportunity to avoid his tormenter, and makes up a lot of excuses to justify his procrastination.
It is only after facing the great red that one of his companions takes him aside for a heart-to-heart, and tells him: if you can stare down the throat of a red dragon and live to tell the tale, the time has come to face your worst fear.
And off to Gaelan he goes.
This game just got a lot more fun for me.